Paul.Dekkers at surfnet.nl
Mon Nov 7 05:59:39 EST 2005
Andrew Morgan wrote:
> On Sun, 6 Nov 2005, Michael Loftis wrote:
>> I'd also be VERY interested since our experience was quite the
>> opposite. ReiserFS was faster than all three, XFS trailing a dismal
>> third (also had corruption issues) and ext3 second or even more dismal
>> third, depending on if you ignored it's wretched large directory
>> performance or not. ReiserFS performed solidly and predictably in all
>> tests. Not the same could be said for XFS and ext3. This was about 2
>> yrs ago though.
> Make sure that you format ext3 partitions with dir_index which improves
> large directory performance.
... but decreases read performance in general... at least that is what I
found under RH / Fedora!
... to see that reading from ext3 with dir_index enabled takes about
2h15 to read 20 Gb of mail data, while...
... without dir_index it takes only 15 minutes! ReiserFS was a bit
slower for me with reads, but faster in writes. ReiserFS was also
predictable in writes, where ext3 was slow(er) on large directories, but
not that dramaticly. (I have graphs of that too.)
BTW: I found that chaning dir_index with tune2fs didn't work as
expected. If I disabled the dir_indexes, even after a forced fsck,
performance was still slow. Enabling didn't give predictable results
either: I had to specify it with mkfs.
I posted this to the RedHat list once, no-one replied. I decided that my
tests where satisfied my questions for what fs to use under RedHat 4 for
our NG mail platform... (ext3: supported, lots of (coroner) tools, fast
enough, available in the stock kernel (if you need RH), ... and ReiserFS
3 already has a successor, ...)
P.S. I also compared FreeBSD's UFS2 under 5.3. I should maybe try again
with 6, since that release should have improved filesystem and disk
performance in general. We use FreeBSD now, it's a pity we move to RH
for this, but "Dell hardware" maybe says enough.
P.S. You can look at the graph's including some comments on
More information about the Info-cyrus