[oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week
Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group
Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com
Wed Sep 2 15:39:59 EDT 2015
Valerie, Guenter and Satya,
Many thanks for your feedback regarding our joint presentation. Below, I listed the changes I have done (in red) based on your feedback in the final deck (attached)..
@All,
Yes, there is still a lot of room for improvement with the deck. In particular we should discuss if anybody has access to marketing resources to improve the design and layout of the presentation. Still, I would like to get that approved in our call tomorrow, such that all of us have a "neutral" deck about the initiative to share.
Fine for you for now?
Kind regards
Rolf.
From: Young, Valerie J [mailto:valerie.j.young at intel.com]
Sent: Mittwoch, 26. August 2015 03:28
To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group
Cc: Mahadev Satyanarayanan (satya at cs.cmu.edu); yunchao hu (yunchao.hu at HUAWEI.COM)
Subject: RE: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week
Hi Rolf,
The deck is a good start. Some minor tweaks were made. Would it be better to state that the initiative is driving from the cloud to the network?
--> I changed the wording of the "main target" on slide 6 to "Enable Cloud Computing at the Edge". We should discuss that. I would avoid the work network, as that is everywhere...
When will you be presenting?
--> Potential partners, MEC Congress in September in London...
It does not have anything about the course and potential next steps. Should we discuss those?
--> I added a slide on current activities and plans. We have to remember to either update it regularly or take it out...
Thanks,
Best regards,
Valerie
Comments from Guenter
Page 3:
- What is meant with "Very small devices"? smaller smartphones? iWatch type? Google Glass type?
- On right side, what is meant by "Local Resilience"? Why "local"? Is the message, centralisation leads to reliance on a few DC facilities?
- We could add the factors which Satya has highlighted in papers and presentations: becoming available: new type of devices, engines for face recognition etc...., as these are enablers for very new use cases.
--> Yes, the slide requires the voice track to be understood. I have change the wording slightly for more clarity and added a note page with the explanation of the thoughts behind the trends.
Page 18:
- The arrows in the picture: how shall they be read: Arrow points from x to y: x calls an API on y? x invokes something on y?
- The arrow for A: Cloudlet Discover: Is this going indeed from device to the edge server, or instead to a discovery service (which can be located anywhere)? E.g. we said it could even be a Zynga-specific discovery server, found by the Zynga app on the device.
- The B-API for VM provisioning: Not sure whether the arrow makes sense. Is the cloud platform invoking something in a VM? Isn't the user/app deciding to use an edge service once discovered and starts to invoke the VM provisioning workflow? Should arrow B go from app on device to Open Cloud platform in the cloudlet?
- Similar for the C-API: Is triggered by the app on the device I suspect (at least in cloudlet context, not in ETSI MEC context).
--> Correct, the slide simplifies the flow quite a lot. And I think it would be good to have a simple slide everybody can understand. I changed the arrows to bring it closer to the true process, however, more complexity might not make the slide better. We have the next slide with the details. O.K.?
Further: Would it be useful to each have a slide for different stakeholder groups: Real-world touch points with Cloudlets or workflow interfaces to Cloudlets or operational aspects regarding cloudlets? .... As these slides could be used for outreach to different groups. To give some examples:
- For network operator:
- May deploy cloud software at edge locations (incl. base VMs)
- May operate a discovery service
- May offer PaaS components to developers e.g. to create launch VMs
- Etc.
For application developer:
- May create and run their own cloudlet discovery service
- May create applications designed to execute on both tier 1 cloud and at the edge
- May create apps that can offload execution to the edge on user demand
- Will use cloudlet platform API(s) to create launch VM and overlay VM
- Will make overlay VM available either together with app or on a particular web location
- May develop mechanism for the app to decide when to request a handoff
For an enterprise:
- May deploy edge servers at locations across the enterprise premises/campus
- Etc.
--> Good point. I have tried to cover some of that on slide 14, where I address the advantages for the various players. I suggest to add individual slides per target group once we have the discussions with various stakeholders.
Br
Guenter
From: oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu<mailto:oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu> [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group
Sent: Friday, August 21, 2015 7:38 AM
To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu<mailto:oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu>
Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com<mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com>
Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week
Dear all,
Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions...
Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August.
Many thanks
Rolf.
Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015
1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback
2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark)
3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit
4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong)
5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process.
6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.)
7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing
· (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc.
· (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc.
· (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox?
8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC
9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc.
10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.)
11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project
_____________________________________________
From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group
Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22
To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu<mailto:oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu>
Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com<mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com>
Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week
Dear all,
Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow
- Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions
- Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners)
I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow.
Kind regards
Rolf.
<< File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________
From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group
Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15
To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu<mailto:chasek at cs.cmu.edu>); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com<mailto:joe.g.cahill at intel.com>; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu<mailto:krha at cmu.edu>); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com<mailto:michael.a.kozuch at intel.com>
Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week
Dear all,
Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week,
· please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon.
· Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call
As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details.
Kind regards
Rolf.
<< File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >>
Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red)
1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash)
--> DONE
2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc.
Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties.
Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings.
Ideas: address verticals. 'Crowdsourcing' the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals.
--> Draft deck to be distributed
3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements.
Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details.
Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit.
Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly.
--> Has that happened?
4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context.
--> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015?
5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls.
--> Update durich call on 20 August 2015?
6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready.
--> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody.
7. All:
1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug - end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code.
2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is
familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers.
--> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks!
8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline.
Google docs? Own cloud at CMU?
Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal
--> Proposal from Satya under way...
_____________________________________________
From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group
Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38
To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu<mailto:chasek at cs.cmu.edu>); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com<mailto:joe.g.cahill at intel.com>; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu<mailto:krha at cmu.edu>); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com<mailto:michael.a.kozuch at intel.com>
Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015
Importance: High
Hi there,
Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July.
- The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well
- We went through all agenda points
- We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached.
- New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties.
- Various actions require follow-up in the next days.
Any questions, please let me know.
Best regards
Guenter
<< File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >>
-----Original Appointment-----
From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group
Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31
To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu<mailto:chasek at cs.cmu.edu>); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com<mailto:joe.g.cahill at intel.com>; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu<mailto:krha at cmu.edu>); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com<mailto:michael.a.kozuch at intel.com>
Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call
When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna.
Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below
Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers.
Rolf.
______________________________
Dear all,
As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas
· Outreach Program Progress
· Technical Program Progress
· MEC Requirement Progress
and go through the attached action item list.
Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com<mailto:uMeeting at huawei.com> for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite).
Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call.
Kind regards
Rolf.
Email from last meeting
<< Attachments:
Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx<http://eito-kvs16.internal.vodafone.com/EnterpriseVault/ViewMessage.asp?VaultId=13842BF18D179A3439EF1767A241699741110000eito-kvs&SavesetId=201506275371025~201506112131280000~Z~10A03256092D8F178258A43E01356041&AttachmentId=1> (34.5KB)
Webex call-in information July 16, 2015<http://eito-kvs16.internal.vodafone.com/EnterpriseVault/ViewMessage.asp?VaultId=13842BF18D179A3439EF1767A241699741110000eito-kvs&SavesetId=201506275371025~201506112131280000~Z~10A03256092D8F178258A43E01356041&AttachmentId=2> (11.7KB)
RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon<http://eito-kvs16.internal.vodafone.com/EnterpriseVault/ViewMessage.asp?VaultId=13842BF18D179A3439EF1767A241699741110000eito-kvs&SavesetId=201506275371025~201506112131280000~Z~10A03256092D8F178258A43E01356041&AttachmentId=3> (9.0MB)
>>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150902/058a483c/attachment-0001.html
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview - FINAL.pptx
Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.presentationml.presentation
Size: 1589796 bytes
Desc: Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview - FINAL.pptx
Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150902/058a483c/attachment-0001.bin
More information about the oe-sync
mailing list