From satya at cs.cmu.edu Fri Jul 10 07:49:46 2015 From: satya at cs.cmu.edu (Mahadev Satyanarayanan) Date: Fri, 10 Jul 2015 07:49:46 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] Weekly Thursday sync meetings Message-ID: <201507100749.46911.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Hi everyone, This is a new mailing list to help us streamline our regular sync Webex calls. There are just 10 people on this mailing list: Vodafone: Guenter Klas, Rolf Schuster Huawei: Yunchao Hu, Patrice Hede, Prakash Ramachandran Intel: Valerie Young, Mike Kozuch, Babu Pillai CMU: Kiryong Ha, Satya We are the sync team that will meet regularly to track progress and to push things along. Please use this mailing list for all communications --- that way we won't omit people accidentally. For some weeks, for specific topics, there may be extra people we add explicitly to the "To" or "CC" lines. The intent is to keep this regular group size small and manageable (current size of 10 is max). Please reserve Thursdays 10:00-11:30 EDT on your schedules for our sync calls. We may not meet every week, but reserving the time will help us to be efficient as our work intensifies. In some rare cases, a few of us may have to miss a specific meeting. But hopefully these will be quite rare. We all make the effort to try and attend each meeting. We'd like at least one person from each organization to attend every meeting. Over the summer (because of vacations, for many of us), we have only two planned meetings: July 16 (next week) and August 20. Starting from the August 20 meeting onwards, I propose that we decide at each meeting whether the next week's meeting is needed. On Thursdays where there is no meeting, I will send out email asking whether we need to meet the following week. That way, we are always able to meet as a group with only one week's notice. OK? I will send out email about next week's meeting and agenda separately. I am also working with Webex on getting in-country callin numbers to simplify the Webex setup. There are complications regarding billing that are slowing the process down, hopefully I can resolve these with Webex today or latest by Monday. This should help us ensure good voice quality without needing Huawei to set up voice callins for each person every week. More soon. -- Satya From Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com Mon Jul 13 04:32:26 2015 From: Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com (Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group) Date: Mon, 13 Jul 2015 08:32:26 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Weekly Thursday sync meetings - DRAFT AGENDA + ACTIONS Message-ID: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A5F6BDD@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Satya, all yes, sounds good. Let's give it a go. Means, all parties/companies should be present. If someone cannot attend, a delegate should be present and stand in. Regarding the conf call this week on 16 July: - Plan is to purely use CMU's webex and dial-in to that webex conference using our phones (in the hope the quality then is ok). - Working procedure: As Rolf summarised last time, we need to improve the efficiency with these calls. Thus, preparation + feedback + off-line discussions in advance is key. DRAFT AGENDA: 1. Dial-in ritual (getting all to use webex and dial in via their phone) 10 min 2. Status of actions from action item list (see the ACTIONs in below text). PLEASE SEND RESULTS FROM ACTIONS TO THIS LIST BY Wed 15 July COB, so we are more efficient on the call. 10 min 3. Proposal to set up a document store, so less MBs need to be sent around 10 min 4. Status regarding Catalysing Cloudlets in CMU course, funding situation, decision (we had documents D004, D005 as input last time. Please comment.) 10 min 5. Outreach Program Progress Outreach plan and actions (content of slides has been for review, document D001. Please comment by Wed 15 July) 15 min Outreach presentation (has been for review, document D002. Please comment by Wed 15 July) 10 min 6. Technical Program Progress (we had document D003 as input last time. We should get a fresh update sent before 16 July) 15 min 7. MEC Requirement Progress (verbal feedback) 10 min 8. AoB Summary from Rolf from 26 June 2015 meeting: Rolf wrote- ... To improve things going forward, I suggest to change our approach slightly ? From now on we will hold weekly technical meetings and just report the technical program status into the overall calls ? We will distribute the call material 2 days before the call to minimise the presentation & discussion time ? We will change the meeting set-up. It is just too complicated with two bridges. For the next meeting I suggest that we us just WebEx for voice AND application sharing. EVERYBODY should dial-in via phone (not VoIP). Chase is trying to provide the dial-in numbers for all local countries. Here is a quick summary of the results of the meeting: Technical Program ? Project plan details with resource estimate and time plan? (Kiryong, Prakash) ? Prakash presented current technical work program (attached) ? ACTION: Kiryong and Prakash will distribute a detailed work plan including scope, deliverables, timeline and required resources until 14 July to everybody ? ACTION: Prakash will send an invite for weekly technical meetings with Kiryong, Jean, Joe, Guenter and Rolf. Everybody else is welcome to join as well. Please let Prakash know... ? Testing and certification (Yun Chao) and procurement (Guenter) -->Guenter has shared his finding around open source procurement Outreach Program ? Open Edge Marketing message (attached deck) ? ACTION ALL: We did not discuss that deck. Still we urgently need an overview deck for the initiative to share with application providers and IT companies. Please have a look and send your feedback to Guenter and myself ? Outreach program (time plan + resource estimate) ? ACTION ALL: We did not discuss that deck. Please do not hesitate to send your comments to Guenter and myself. ? ACTION Yun Chao + Valerie: in case you can get some marketing resources (as suggested in the deck) it would be great ? Edge application competition (Satya) ? Satya suggested to run the competition in a CMU course first ? ACTION Valerie, Yun Chao, Guenter: any chance to support that (funding decision by 16 July 2015 required) ? Outreach to target industries: Augmented Reality (Rolf), Manufacturers (Yun Chao), Automotive (Rolf, Valerie), ? Not discussed ? Outreach to organisations: OpenStack (Prakash), John Garbutt (OpenStack Project Lead, Guenter, Yun Chao) ? Not discussed MEC update (Adrian, Patrice) ? Next steps? Support for 29 June? ? Not discussed. However, Adrian got in touch with marketing people from NOKIA to get their support for the open edge requirements ? Next Steps, AOB ? White Paper MeC, Business Cases ? Application World Congress ? MEC Congress ? Not discussed For your convenience please find all the documents below. Please note that I will be on holiday from today. I will be back in the office on 23 July. Guenter will take over the lead of the next call on 16 July 2015. Kind regards Rolf. -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Mahadev Satyanarayanan Sent: 10 July 2015 12:50 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: [oe-sync] Weekly Thursday sync meetings Hi everyone, This is a new mailing list to help us streamline our regular sync Webex calls. There are just 10 people on this mailing list: Vodafone: Guenter Klas, Rolf Schuster Huawei: Yunchao Hu, Patrice Hede, Prakash Ramachandran Intel: Valerie Young, Mike Kozuch, Babu Pillai CMU: Kiryong Ha, Satya We are the sync team that will meet regularly to track progress and to push things along. Please use this mailing list for all communications --- that way we won't omit people accidentally. For some weeks, for specific topics, there may be extra people we add explicitly to the "To" or "CC" lines. The intent is to keep this regular group size small and manageable (current size of 10 is max). Please reserve Thursdays 10:00-11:30 EDT on your schedules for our sync calls. We may not meet every week, but reserving the time will help us to be efficient as our work intensifies. In some rare cases, a few of us may have to miss a specific meeting. But hopefully these will be quite rare. We all make the effort to try and attend each meeting. We'd like at least one person from each organization to attend every meeting. Over the summer (because of vacations, for many of us), we have only two planned meetings: July 16 (next week) and August 20. Starting from the August 20 meeting onwards, I propose that we decide at each meeting whether the next week's meeting is needed. On Thursdays where there is no meeting, I will send out email asking whether we need to meet the following week. That way, we are always able to meet as a group with only one week's notice. OK? I will send out email about next week's meeting and agenda separately. I am also working with Webex on getting in-country callin numbers to simplify the Webex setup. There are complications regarding billing that are slowing the process down, hopefully I can resolve these with Webex today or latest by Monday. This should help us ensure good voice quality without needing Huawei to set up voice callins for each person every week. More soon. -- Satya _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150713/1b710304/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: OE Docs for 16 July 2015.zip Type: application/x-zip-compressed Size: 6217074 bytes Desc: OE Docs for 16 July 2015.zip Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150713/1b710304/attachment-0001.bin From satya at cs.cmu.edu Wed Jul 15 07:57:18 2015 From: satya at cs.cmu.edu (Mahadev Satyanarayanan) Date: Wed, 15 Jul 2015 07:57:18 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] New country-specific Webex callin numbers Message-ID: <201507150757.18300.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Hi everyone, Our sync call tomorrow (Thursday, July 16) will be from 11:00-12:30 EDT. This is a one-time deviation from our usual 10:00-11:30 EDT. Please see attached PDF file with country-specific callin Webex numbers. These numbers are permanent. Once you call in, it will ask you for an access code for the meeting. Chase will include that access code in his Webex email. This new procedure lets each person make an in-country call, but still get good voice quality. We will be trying this new setup for tomorrow's call. Hopefully it will prove to be a success and we completely avoid all the complications we have had in the past. -- Satya -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: webex-international-callin-numbers-by-country.pdf Type: application/pdf Size: 7232 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150715/afccbab1/attachment.pdf From satya at cs.cmu.edu Wed Jul 15 07:57:48 2015 From: satya at cs.cmu.edu (Mahadev Satyanarayanan) Date: Wed, 15 Jul 2015 07:57:48 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] New country-specific Webex callin numbers Message-ID: <201507150757.48991.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Hi everyone, Our sync call tomorrow (Thursday, July 16) will be from 11:00-12:30 EDT. This is a one-time deviation from our usual 10:00-11:30 EDT. Please see attached PDF file with country-specific callin Webex numbers. These numbers are permanent. Once you call in, it will ask you for an access code for the meeting. Chase will include that access code in his Webex email. This new procedure lets each person make an in-country call, but still get good voice quality. We will be trying this new setup for tomorrow's call. Hopefully it will prove to be a success and we completely avoid all the complications we have had in the past. -- Satya -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: webex-international-callin-numbers-by-country.pdf Type: application/pdf Size: 7232 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150715/fea0894b/attachment.pdf From satya at cs.cmu.edu Wed Jul 15 08:02:28 2015 From: satya at cs.cmu.edu (Mahadev Satyanarayanan) Date: Wed, 15 Jul 2015 08:02:28 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] Draft agenda for tomorrow Message-ID: <201507150802.28641.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Attached is the earlier email that Guenter sent out with draft agenda. Please review the details and respond. Since Rolf is on vacation, Guenter will be chairing. Chase: when you have set up the Webex for tomorrow, please send details to this mailing list. -- Satya -------------- next part -------------- An embedded message was scrubbed... From: "Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group" Subject: [oe-sync] Weekly Thursday sync meetings - DRAFT AGENDA + ACTIONS Date: Mon, 13 Jul 2015 08:32:26 +0000 Size: 8456176 Url: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150715/21f1cc85/attachment-0001.mht From krha at cmu.edu Wed Jul 15 15:51:08 2015 From: krha at cmu.edu (Kiryong Ha) Date: Wed, 15 Jul 2015 15:51:08 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] Weekly Thursday sync meetings - DRAFT AGENDA + ACTIONS In-Reply-To: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A5F6BDD@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A5F6BDD@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: Hi all, Please find the attachment for the detailed work plan including scope, deliverables, timeline and required resources. I'll explain the slide at the meeting tomorrow. Thanks. -- Kiryong On Mon, Jul 13, 2015 at 4:32 AM, Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group wrote: > Satya, all > > > > yes, sounds good. Let's give it a go. Means, all parties/companies should be > present. If someone cannot attend, a delegate should be present and stand > in. > > > > Regarding the conf call this week on 16 July: > > - Plan is to purely use CMU?s webex and dial-in to that > webex conference using our phones (in the hope the quality then is ok). > > - Working procedure: As Rolf summarised last time, we > need to improve the efficiency with these calls. Thus, preparation + > feedback + off-line discussions in advance is key. > > DRAFT AGENDA: > > 1. Dial-in ritual (getting all to use webex and dial in via their > phone) 10 min > > 2. Status of actions from action item list (see the ACTIONs in below > text). PLEASE SEND RESULTS FROM ACTIONS TO THIS LIST BY Wed 15 July COB, so > we are more efficient on the call. 10 min > > 3. Proposal to set up a document store, so less MBs need to be sent > around 10 min > > 4. Status regarding Catalysing Cloudlets in CMU course, funding > situation, decision (we had documents D004, D005 as input last time. Please > comment.) 10 min > > 5. Outreach Program Progress > Outreach plan and actions (content of slides has been for review, document > D001. Please comment by Wed 15 July) 15 min > Outreach presentation (has been for review, document D002. Please comment by > Wed 15 July) 10 min > > 6. Technical Program Progress (we had document D003 as input last > time. We should get a fresh update sent before 16 July) 15 min > > 7. MEC Requirement Progress (verbal feedback) 10 min > > 8. AoB > > > > Summary from Rolf from 26 June 2015 meeting: Rolf wrote- > > ... To improve things going forward, I suggest to change our approach > slightly > > > > ? From now on we will hold weekly technical meetings and just report > the technical program status into the overall calls > > ? We will distribute the call material 2 days before the call to > minimise the presentation & discussion time > > ? We will change the meeting set-up. It is just too complicated with > two bridges. For the next meeting I suggest that we us just WebEx for voice > AND application sharing. EVERYBODY should dial-in via phone (not VoIP). > Chase is trying to provide the dial-in numbers for all local countries. > > Here is a quick summary of the results of the meeting: > > > > Technical Program > > ? Project plan details with resource estimate and time plan? > (Kiryong, Prakash) > > ? Prakash presented current technical work program (attached) > > ? ACTION: Kiryong and Prakash will distribute a detailed work plan > including scope, deliverables, timeline and required resources until 14 July > to everybody > > ? ACTION: Prakash will send an invite for weekly technical meetings > with Kiryong, Jean, Joe, Guenter and Rolf. Everybody else is welcome to join > as well. Please let Prakash know? > > ? Testing and certification (Yun Chao) and procurement (Guenter) > > ?Guenter has shared his finding around open source procurement > > Outreach Program > > > > ? Open Edge Marketing message (attached deck) > > ? ACTION ALL: We did not discuss that deck. Still we urgently need > an overview deck for the initiative to share with application providers and > IT companies. Please have a look and send your feedback to Guenter and > myself > > ? Outreach program (time plan + resource estimate) > > ? ACTION ALL: We did not discuss that deck. Please do not hesitate > to send your comments to Guenter and myself. > > > > ? ACTION Yun Chao + Valerie: in case you can get some marketing > resources (as suggested in the deck) it would be great > > ? Edge application competition (Satya) > > ? Satya suggested to run the competition in a CMU course first > > ? ACTION Valerie, Yun Chao, Guenter: any chance to support that > (funding decision by 16 July 2015 required) > > ? Outreach to target industries: > > Augmented Reality (Rolf), Manufacturers (Yun Chao), Automotive (Rolf, > Valerie), > > ? Not discussed > > ? Outreach to organisations: OpenStack (Prakash), John Garbutt > (OpenStack Project Lead, Guenter, Yun Chao) > > ? Not discussed > > > > MEC update (Adrian, Patrice) > > ? Next steps? Support for 29 June? > > ? Not discussed. However, Adrian got in touch with marketing people > from NOKIA to get their support for the open edge requirements > > ? Next Steps, AOB > > > > ? White Paper MeC, Business Cases > > ? Application World Congress > > ? MEC Congress > > ? Not discussed > > > > For your convenience please find all the documents below. > > > > Please note that I will be on holiday from today. I will be back in the > office on 23 July. Guenter will take over the lead of the next call on 16 > July 2015. > > > > Kind regards > > > > Rolf. > > > > -----Original Message----- > From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On > Behalf Of Mahadev Satyanarayanan > Sent: 10 July 2015 12:50 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: [oe-sync] Weekly Thursday sync meetings > > > > Hi everyone, > > This is a new mailing list to help us streamline our regular sync Webex > calls. There are just 10 people on this mailing list: > > > > Vodafone: Guenter Klas, Rolf Schuster > > > > Huawei: Yunchao Hu, Patrice Hede, Prakash Ramachandran > > > > Intel: Valerie Young, Mike Kozuch, Babu Pillai > > > > CMU: Kiryong Ha, Satya > > > > We are the sync team that will meet regularly to track progress and to push > things along. Please use this mailing list for all communications --- that > way we won't omit people accidentally. For some weeks, for specific topics, > there may be extra people we add explicitly to the "To" or "CC" lines. The > intent is to keep this regular group size small and manageable (current size > of 10 is max). > > > > Please reserve Thursdays 10:00-11:30 EDT on your schedules for our sync > calls. We may not meet every week, but reserving the time will help us to > be efficient as our work intensifies. In some rare cases, a few of us may > have to miss a specific meeting. But hopefully these will be quite rare. > We all make the effort to try and attend each meeting. We'd like at least > one person from each organization to attend every meeting. > > > > Over the summer (because of vacations, for many of us), we have only two > planned meetings: July 16 (next week) and August 20. > > > > Starting from the August 20 meeting onwards, I propose that we decide at > each meeting whether the next week's meeting is needed. On Thursdays where > there is no meeting, I will send out email asking whether we need to meet > the following week. That way, we are always able to meet as a group with > only one week's notice. > > > > OK? I will send out email about next week's meeting and agenda separately. > I am also working with Webex on getting in-country callin numbers to > simplify the Webex setup. There are complications regarding billing that > are slowing the process down, hopefully I can resolve these with Webex today > or latest by Monday. This should help us ensure good voice quality without > needing Huawei to set up voice callins for each person every week. > > > > More soon. > > -- Satya > > _______________________________________________ > > oe-sync mailing list > > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync > > > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync > -- Kiryong -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: OpenEdge.pptx Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.presentationml.presentation Size: 66214 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150715/dfbdea01/attachment-0001.bin From satya at cs.cmu.edu Wed Jul 15 16:46:54 2015 From: satya at cs.cmu.edu (Mahadev Satyanarayanan) Date: Wed, 15 Jul 2015 16:46:54 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] Webex callin details for tomorrow (July 16, 11:00 EDT) Message-ID: <201507151646.54384.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Hi everyone, We will be using a new Webex account that allows global call-in using an in-country phone number. I sent you the .pdf of the phone numbers earlier. Including again on this email for convenience. The steps are: 1. Use Meeting link below (or point your browser at http://cmusatyalab.webex.com) 2. Join the meeting scheduled for 11:00 EDT tomorrow (you will need the password shown below) 3. Dial the phone number for your country from the list in the .pdf file When prompted for a meeting number, use the Meeting number shown below. If all goes well, everyone should have Webex screen sharing, and telco-quality voice quality for our meeting. Please be patient while we work out the glitches. Hopefully this will be a lot better than our convoluted procedure in the past. ------------ Webex Details ----------- oe-sync meeting on July 16 Thursday, July 16, 2015 11:00 am | Eastern Daylight Time (New York, GMT-04:00) | 1 hr 30 mins Join WebEx meeting Meeting number: 738 769 705 Meeting password: oesync Join by phone +1-415-655-0002 US Toll Access code: 738 769 705 Meeting link: https://cmusatyalab.webex.com/cmusatyalab/j.php?MTID=m7d886343316186a179dbfd18704040dc --------------------------------------------- Cheers -- Satya -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: webex-international-callin-numbers-by-country.pdf Type: application/pdf Size: 7232 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150715/f4558053/attachment.pdf From satya at cs.cmu.edu Thu Jul 16 10:52:21 2015 From: satya at cs.cmu.edu (Mahadev Satyanarayanan) Date: Thu, 16 Jul 2015 10:52:21 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] URGENT: corrected Webx instructions for 11:00 EDT Message-ID: <201507161052.21679.satya@cs.cmu.edu> DO NOT USE PDF FILE I SENT FOR GLOBAL CALLIN NUMBERS INSTEAD USE PROCEDURE BELOW 1. Go to URL below: https://cmusatyalab.webex.com/cmusatyalab/j.php?MTID=m7d886343316186a179dbfd18704040dc 2. Join meeting, using meeting password and meeting number: Meeting number: 738 769 705 Meeting password: oesync 3. Click on "Global call-in numbers' in the pop-up and pick the one for your country Now you should be able to join the voice call in progress. If you need to reach me, my cell # is (412)-339-0313. Talk to all of you in a few minutes -- Satya -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150716/7c14b531/attachment.html From Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com Thu Jul 16 10:56:39 2015 From: Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com (Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group) Date: Thu, 16 Jul 2015 14:56:39 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] IMPORTANT : URGENT: corrected Webx instructions for 11:00 EDT Message-ID: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A5FEB47@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Hi there, For the conf. call with Vodafone, CMU, Intel, Huawei at 11:00 EDT, 16:00 BST, 17:00 CET: - I'll chair the meting - My slides with agenda + dial-in procedure + action items + list of input is attached - Please start the webex first o First connect from your computer to Webex for screen sharing only o Second, look up your local dial-in number by clicking on the URL shown on the webex screen. o Use the displayed audio dial-in details to dial in from your smartphone: - Access code - Attendee ID - Dial-in at least 5 mins before the full hour, as it takes some time. - In case not seen Satya's email from 5 mins ago, see below. Guenter From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Mahadev Satyanarayanan Sent: 16 July 2015 15:52 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: [oe-sync] URGENT: corrected Webx instructions for 11:00 EDT DO NOT USE PDF FILE I SENT FOR GLOBAL CALLIN NUMBERS INSTEAD USE PROCEDURE BELOW 1. Go to URL below: https://cmusatyalab.webex.com/cmusatyalab/j.php?MTID=m7d886343316186a179dbfd18704040dc 2. Join meeting, using meeting password and meeting number: Meeting number: 738 769 705 Meeting password: oesync 3. Click on "Global call-in numbers' in the pop-up and pick the one for your country Now you should be able to join the voice call in progress. If you need to reach me, my cell # is (412)-339-0313. Talk to all of you in a few minutes -- Satya -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150716/fa8a5f0c/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: 150716 OE Sync Call GK.pptx Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.presentationml.presentation Size: 2743908 bytes Desc: 150716 OE Sync Call GK.pptx Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150716/fa8a5f0c/attachment-0001.bin From Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com Thu Jul 16 10:58:53 2015 From: Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com (Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group) Date: Thu, 16 Jul 2015 14:58:53 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] IMPORTANT : URGENT: corrected Webx instructions for 11:00 EDT In-Reply-To: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A5FEB47@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A5FEB47@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A5FEB6D@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> ... and, once you have started Webex, look up the audio-dial in details on the webex tab "Meeting Info", on the right side of "Quick Start". Guenter From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: 16 July 2015 15:57 To: Mahadev Satyanarayanan; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: [oe-sync] IMPORTANT : URGENT: corrected Webx instructions for 11:00 EDT Importance: High Hi there, For the conf. call with Vodafone, CMU, Intel, Huawei at 11:00 EDT, 16:00 BST, 17:00 CET: - I'll chair the meting - My slides with agenda + dial-in procedure + action items + list of input is attached - Please start the webex first o First connect from your computer to Webex for screen sharing only o Second, look up your local dial-in number by clicking on the URL shown on the webex screen. o Use the displayed audio dial-in details to dial in from your smartphone: - Access code - Attendee ID - Dial-in at least 5 mins before the full hour, as it takes some time. - In case not seen Satya's email from 5 mins ago, see below. Guenter From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Mahadev Satyanarayanan Sent: 16 July 2015 15:52 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: [oe-sync] URGENT: corrected Webx instructions for 11:00 EDT DO NOT USE PDF FILE I SENT FOR GLOBAL CALLIN NUMBERS INSTEAD USE PROCEDURE BELOW 1. Go to URL below: https://cmusatyalab.webex.com/cmusatyalab/j.php?MTID=m7d886343316186a179dbfd18704040dc 2. Join meeting, using meeting password and meeting number: Meeting number: 738 769 705 Meeting password: oesync 3. Click on "Global call-in numbers' in the pop-up and pick the one for your country Now you should be able to join the voice call in progress. If you need to reach me, my cell # is (412)-339-0313. Talk to all of you in a few minutes -- Satya -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150716/5c8fb39b/attachment.html From satya at cs.cmu.edu Wed Jul 22 06:01:14 2015 From: satya at cs.cmu.edu (Mahadev Satyanarayanan) Date: Wed, 22 Jul 2015 06:01:14 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] Minimize toll-free Webex use Message-ID: <201507220601.14979.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Hi everyone, Our use of Webex at the last meeting worked well. The voice quality was good, and it was much simpler to use a single system for everything rather than Webex for screen-sharing and a separate system for voice. We will continue to use this moving forward. However, Patrice pointed out something important: on many occasions, some of the Huawei participants may be in China (either located there, or visiting there). He observed that China is not one of the countries for which Webex has a callin number listed. I looked into this, and Patrice is partly correct. There are no toll callin lines for China. However, Webex does support a toll-free callin line for China (in fact two: one for south and one for north). This is also true for some other countries (e.g., India, Egypt, etc.). For this to work, I have to enable toll-free calling on Webex. However, this is very expensive and the cost per minute is directly billed to my account and is charged to my limited research budget. (Toll calls are also billed to my account, but the cost per minute is much cheaper). To facilitate our collaboration, I have enabled toll-free calling. However, I request that all of you respect the cost aspect. If you have a choice of toll or toll-free number listed for the country you are calling from, please use the toll number. Only use toll-free if no toll number is available. If you respect this simple rule, it will keep costs as low as possible. This is true for our weekly Thursday meetings, and also for any other ad hoc Webex meetings we set up. We have initiated a strong collaboration, and I look forward to many high-impact results from this collaboration over the next year. -- Satya From satya at cs.cmu.edu Wed Jul 22 06:02:19 2015 From: satya at cs.cmu.edu (Mahadev Satyanarayanan) Date: Wed, 22 Jul 2015 06:02:19 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] Minimize toll-free Webex use Message-ID: <201507220602.19169.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Hi everyone, Our use of Webex at the last meeting worked well. The voice quality was good, and it was much simpler to use a single system for everything rather than Webex for screen-sharing and a separate system for voice. We will continue to use this moving forward. However, Patrice pointed out something important: on many occasions, some of the Huawei participants may be in China (either located there, or visiting there). He observed that China is not one of the countries for which Webex has a callin number listed. I looked into this, and Patrice is partly correct. There are no toll callin lines for China. However, Webex does support a toll-free callin line for China (in fact two: one for south and one for north). This is also true for some other countries (e.g., India, Egypt, etc.). For this to work, I have to enable toll-free calling on Webex. However, this is very expensive and the cost per minute is directly billed to my account and is charged to my limited research budget. (Toll calls are also billed to my account, but the cost per minute is much cheaper). To facilitate our collaboration, I have enabled toll-free calling. However, I request that all of you respect the cost aspect. If you have a choice of toll or toll-free number listed for the country you are calling from, please use the toll number. Only use toll-free if no toll number is available. If you respect this simple rule, it will keep costs as low as possible. This is true for our weekly Thursday meetings, and also for any other ad hoc Webex meetings we set up. We have initiated a strong collaboration, and I look forward to many high-impact results from this collaboration over the next year. -- Satya _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync From satya at cs.cmu.edu Wed Jul 22 06:19:05 2015 From: satya at cs.cmu.edu (Mahadev Satyanarayanan) Date: Wed, 22 Jul 2015 06:19:05 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] Webex details for our weekly sync meetings Message-ID: <201507220619.05507.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Hi everyone, Our weekly 10:00-11:30 Thursday meetings don't start until August 20. However, I have set up the Webex reservation starting from tomorrow (July 23). If there is a need for a quick sync, this reservation is available. I will be away on vacation from July 29 to August 15 (no email or phone), but Kiryong can act as the host if a meeting is needed at short notice. Here are the Webex details (identical every week): Meeting URL: https://cmusatyalab.webex.com/cmusatyalab/j.php?MTID=m5f27b882a9334cf94cb69bba327b1a92 (If for some reason this URL gives you trouble, go to http://cmusatyalab.webex.com and manually enter details below) Meeting number: 737 865 028 Meeting password: oesync For US callers, you will see toll number and toll-free number listed in the popup. Please use toll number. For global callers, you will see "Global call-in numbers" listed in the popup. Follow the link, and find the country you are calling from. If both toll and toll-free number are listed, please use toll number. If only toll-free number is listed, use that. Cheers -- Satya From yunchao.hu at huawei.com Wed Jul 22 07:53:15 2015 From: yunchao.hu at huawei.com (yunchao hu) Date: Wed, 22 Jul 2015 11:53:15 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Webex details for our weekly sync meetings In-Reply-To: <201507220619.05507.satya@cs.cmu.edu> References: <201507220619.05507.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Message-ID: <1FD3A15C89FE6E44B312076ADE9488B80F346EB2@lhreml501-mbx> I would appreciate to have a meeting tomorrow, but I will be flying off at 19:15 UK time so a meeting early afternoon would be appreciated. Can we arrange this? /Yun Chao -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+yunchao.hu=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+yunchao.hu=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Mahadev Satyanarayanan Sent: 22 July 2015 12:19 To: Weekly open-edge sync Cc: Chase Klingensmith Subject: [oe-sync] Webex details for our weekly sync meetings Hi everyone, Our weekly 10:00-11:30 Thursday meetings don't start until August 20. However, I have set up the Webex reservation starting from tomorrow (July 23). If there is a need for a quick sync, this reservation is available. I will be away on vacation from July 29 to August 15 (no email or phone), but Kiryong can act as the host if a meeting is needed at short notice. Here are the Webex details (identical every week): Meeting URL: https://cmusatyalab.webex.com/cmusatyalab/j.php?MTID=m5f27b882a9334cf94cb69bba327b1a92 (If for some reason this URL gives you trouble, go to http://cmusatyalab.webex.com and manually enter details below) Meeting number: 737 865 028 Meeting password: oesync For US callers, you will see toll number and toll-free number listed in the popup. Please use toll number. For global callers, you will see "Global call-in numbers" listed in the popup. Follow the link, and find the country you are calling from. If both toll and toll-free number are listed, please use toll number. If only toll-free number is listed, use that. Cheers -- Satya _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync From satya at cs.cmu.edu Wed Jul 22 09:11:16 2015 From: satya at cs.cmu.edu (Mahadev Satyanarayanan) Date: Wed, 22 Jul 2015 09:11:16 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] Webex details for our weekly sync meetings In-Reply-To: <1FD3A15C89FE6E44B312076ADE9488B80F346EB2@lhreml501-mbx> References: <201507220619.05507.satya@cs.cmu.edu> <1FD3A15C89FE6E44B312076ADE9488B80F346EB2@lhreml501-mbx> Message-ID: <201507220911.16720.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Hi Yun Chao, If there is an urgent topic that you need to discuss, I can personally start earlier than 10:00 EDT tomorrow. Would 08:30 EDT tomorrow work for you? That would be 13:30 UK time, I believe. I don't know who else can attend at 08:30EDT. If you can mention the critical topic, perhaps it would help? Depending on the topic, my participation alone may not be adequate without Vodafone and Intel people. Our current plan is not to meet at all until August 20. -- Satya On Wednesday 22 July 2015 07:53:15 yunchao hu wrote: > I would appreciate to have a meeting tomorrow, but I will be flying off at 19:15 UK time so a meeting early afternoon would be appreciated. Can we arrange this? > > /Yun Chao > > -----Original Message----- > From: oe-sync-bounces+yunchao.hu=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+yunchao.hu=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Mahadev Satyanarayanan > Sent: 22 July 2015 12:19 > To: Weekly open-edge sync > Cc: Chase Klingensmith > Subject: [oe-sync] Webex details for our weekly sync meetings > > Hi everyone, > Our weekly 10:00-11:30 Thursday meetings don't start until August 20. > However, I have set up the Webex reservation starting from tomorrow (July 23). > If there is a need for a quick sync, this reservation is available. I will be > away on vacation from July 29 to August 15 (no email or phone), but Kiryong can act as the host if a meeting is needed at short notice. > > Here are the Webex details (identical every week): > > Meeting URL: > https://cmusatyalab.webex.com/cmusatyalab/j.php?MTID=m5f27b882a9334cf94cb69bba327b1a92 > > (If for some reason this URL gives you trouble, go to http://cmusatyalab.webex.com and manually enter details below) > > Meeting number: 737 865 028 > Meeting password: oesync > > For US callers, you will see toll number and toll-free number listed in the popup. > Please use toll number. > > For global callers, you will see "Global call-in numbers" listed in the popup. > Follow the link, and find the country you are calling from. If both toll and toll-free number > are listed, please use toll number. If only toll-free number is listed, use that. > > Cheers > -- Satya > > > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync > From Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com Wed Jul 22 11:18:27 2015 From: Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com (Prakash Ramchandran) Date: Wed, 22 Jul 2015 15:18:27 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Webex details for our weekly sync meetings In-Reply-To: <1FD3A15C89FE6E44B312076ADE9488B80F346EB2@lhreml501-mbx> References: <201507220619.05507.satya@cs.cmu.edu> <1FD3A15C89FE6E44B312076ADE9488B80F346EB2@lhreml501-mbx> Message-ID: <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB0893E85B@SJCEML702-CHM.china.huawei.com> Hi all, I will be on flight by 10 AM Beijing on 23rd, and do not know how I can make this call, please just send me minutes and will do follow up... I saw some Tacker(VNF-M) info from Gunter and am tracing it and there was lot of interest after OpenStack Summit(Vancouver) but it's on low priority of some other parties like Cisco and HP, and they seem to have backed off, and will try find more details later, as why there is a on-off activity on this and no steady work by folks in this team. However I have asked people in OpenStack Tacker team to confirm on this and will try attend their meeting next week. So I believe this will not affect our OEC efforts for StackFrge or BP's in Nova for our APIs. Thanks Prakash Prakash Ramchandran R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work:? +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of yunchao hu Sent: Wednesday, July 22, 2015 4:53 AM To: Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Weekly open-edge sync Cc: Chase Klingensmith Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Webex details for our weekly sync meetings I would appreciate to have a meeting tomorrow, but I will be flying off at 19:15 UK time so a meeting early afternoon would be appreciated. Can we arrange this? /Yun Chao -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+yunchao.hu=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+yunchao.hu=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Mahadev Satyanarayanan Sent: 22 July 2015 12:19 To: Weekly open-edge sync Cc: Chase Klingensmith Subject: [oe-sync] Webex details for our weekly sync meetings Hi everyone, Our weekly 10:00-11:30 Thursday meetings don't start until August 20. However, I have set up the Webex reservation starting from tomorrow (July 23). If there is a need for a quick sync, this reservation is available. I will be away on vacation from July 29 to August 15 (no email or phone), but Kiryong can act as the host if a meeting is needed at short notice. Here are the Webex details (identical every week): Meeting URL: https://cmusatyalab.webex.com/cmusatyalab/j.php?MTID=m5f27b882a9334cf94cb69bba327b1a92 (If for some reason this URL gives you trouble, go to http://cmusatyalab.webex.com and manually enter details below) Meeting number: 737 865 028 Meeting password: oesync For US callers, you will see toll number and toll-free number listed in the popup. Please use toll number. For global callers, you will see "Global call-in numbers" listed in the popup. Follow the link, and find the country you are calling from. If both toll and toll-free number are listed, please use toll number. If only toll-free number is listed, use that. Cheers -- Satya _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync From valerie.j.young at intel.com Wed Jul 22 11:32:41 2015 From: valerie.j.young at intel.com (Young, Valerie J) Date: Wed, 22 Jul 2015 15:32:41 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Webex details for our weekly sync meetings In-Reply-To: <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB0893E85B@SJCEML702-CHM.china.huawei.com> References: <201507220619.05507.satya@cs.cmu.edu> <1FD3A15C89FE6E44B312076ADE9488B80F346EB2@lhreml501-mbx> <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB0893E85B@SJCEML702-CHM.china.huawei.com> Message-ID: <96EFD7465592EA4A9CCEAAB849F4DFF6A4421BC8@ORSMSX105.amr.corp.intel.com> The time does not work me, too early for PST time zone... -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Prakash Ramchandran Sent: Wednesday, July 22, 2015 8:18 AM To: yunchao hu; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Weekly open-edge sync Cc: Chase Klingensmith Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Webex details for our weekly sync meetings Hi all, I will be on flight by 10 AM Beijing on 23rd, and do not know how I can make this call, please just send me minutes and will do follow up... I saw some Tacker(VNF-M) info from Gunter and am tracing it and there was lot of interest after OpenStack Summit(Vancouver) but it's on low priority of some other parties like Cisco and HP, and they seem to have backed off, and will try find more details later, as why there is a on-off activity on this and no steady work by folks in this team. However I have asked people in OpenStack Tacker team to confirm on this and will try attend their meeting next week. So I believe this will not affect our OEC efforts for StackFrge or BP's in Nova for our APIs. Thanks Prakash Prakash Ramchandran R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work:? +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of yunchao hu Sent: Wednesday, July 22, 2015 4:53 AM To: Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Weekly open-edge sync Cc: Chase Klingensmith Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Webex details for our weekly sync meetings I would appreciate to have a meeting tomorrow, but I will be flying off at 19:15 UK time so a meeting early afternoon would be appreciated. Can we arrange this? /Yun Chao -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+yunchao.hu=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+yunchao.hu=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Mahadev Satyanarayanan Sent: 22 July 2015 12:19 To: Weekly open-edge sync Cc: Chase Klingensmith Subject: [oe-sync] Webex details for our weekly sync meetings Hi everyone, Our weekly 10:00-11:30 Thursday meetings don't start until August 20. However, I have set up the Webex reservation starting from tomorrow (July 23). If there is a need for a quick sync, this reservation is available. I will be away on vacation from July 29 to August 15 (no email or phone), but Kiryong can act as the host if a meeting is needed at short notice. Here are the Webex details (identical every week): Meeting URL: https://cmusatyalab.webex.com/cmusatyalab/j.php?MTID=m5f27b882a9334cf94cb69bba327b1a92 (If for some reason this URL gives you trouble, go to http://cmusatyalab.webex.com and manually enter details below) Meeting number: 737 865 028 Meeting password: oesync For US callers, you will see toll number and toll-free number listed in the popup. Please use toll number. For global callers, you will see "Global call-in numbers" listed in the popup. Follow the link, and find the country you are calling from. If both toll and toll-free number are listed, please use toll number. If only toll-free number is listed, use that. Cheers -- Satya _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync From yunchao.hu at huawei.com Wed Jul 22 11:48:38 2015 From: yunchao.hu at huawei.com (yunchao hu) Date: Wed, 22 Jul 2015 15:48:38 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Webex details for our weekly sync meetings In-Reply-To: <96EFD7465592EA4A9CCEAAB849F4DFF6A4421BC8@ORSMSX105.amr.corp.intel.com> References: <201507220619.05507.satya@cs.cmu.edu> <1FD3A15C89FE6E44B312076ADE9488B80F346EB2@lhreml501-mbx> <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB0893E85B@SJCEML702-CHM.china.huawei.com> <96EFD7465592EA4A9CCEAAB849F4DFF6A4421BC8@ORSMSX105.amr.corp.intel.com> Message-ID: <1FD3A15C89FE6E44B312076ADE9488B80F347570@lhreml501-mbx> Hi all I have no major issues on my list yet. I would like to synch up with you but I can check this with G?nther or Rolf as well. So let skip the conf call tomorrow. Regards Yun Chao -----Original Message----- From: Young, Valerie J [mailto:valerie.j.young at intel.com] Sent: 22 July 2015 17:33 To: Prakash Ramchandran; yunchao hu; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Weekly open-edge sync Cc: Chase Klingensmith Subject: RE: [oe-sync] Webex details for our weekly sync meetings The time does not work me, too early for PST time zone... -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Prakash Ramchandran Sent: Wednesday, July 22, 2015 8:18 AM To: yunchao hu; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Weekly open-edge sync Cc: Chase Klingensmith Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Webex details for our weekly sync meetings Hi all, I will be on flight by 10 AM Beijing on 23rd, and do not know how I can make this call, please just send me minutes and will do follow up... I saw some Tacker(VNF-M) info from Gunter and am tracing it and there was lot of interest after OpenStack Summit(Vancouver) but it's on low priority of some other parties like Cisco and HP, and they seem to have backed off, and will try find more details later, as why there is a on-off activity on this and no steady work by folks in this team. However I have asked people in OpenStack Tacker team to confirm on this and will try attend their meeting next week. So I believe this will not affect our OEC efforts for StackFrge or BP's in Nova for our APIs. Thanks Prakash Prakash Ramchandran R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work:? +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of yunchao hu Sent: Wednesday, July 22, 2015 4:53 AM To: Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Weekly open-edge sync Cc: Chase Klingensmith Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Webex details for our weekly sync meetings I would appreciate to have a meeting tomorrow, but I will be flying off at 19:15 UK time so a meeting early afternoon would be appreciated. Can we arrange this? /Yun Chao -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+yunchao.hu=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+yunchao.hu=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Mahadev Satyanarayanan Sent: 22 July 2015 12:19 To: Weekly open-edge sync Cc: Chase Klingensmith Subject: [oe-sync] Webex details for our weekly sync meetings Hi everyone, Our weekly 10:00-11:30 Thursday meetings don't start until August 20. However, I have set up the Webex reservation starting from tomorrow (July 23). If there is a need for a quick sync, this reservation is available. I will be away on vacation from July 29 to August 15 (no email or phone), but Kiryong can act as the host if a meeting is needed at short notice. Here are the Webex details (identical every week): Meeting URL: https://cmusatyalab.webex.com/cmusatyalab/j.php?MTID=m5f27b882a9334cf94cb69bba327b1a92 (If for some reason this URL gives you trouble, go to http://cmusatyalab.webex.com and manually enter details below) Meeting number: 737 865 028 Meeting password: oesync For US callers, you will see toll number and toll-free number listed in the popup. Please use toll number. For global callers, you will see "Global call-in numbers" listed in the popup. Follow the link, and find the country you are calling from. If both toll and toll-free number are listed, please use toll number. If only toll-free number is listed, use that. Cheers -- Satya _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync From krha at cmu.edu Tue Jul 28 09:57:07 2015 From: krha at cmu.edu (Kiryong Ha) Date: Tue, 28 Jul 2015 09:57:07 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] A report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration, Message-ID: Hi all, Please find the attachment for the report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration (OpenStack++). This report covers design decision and implementation details of OpenStack++ including technical challenges. I believe it would be useful for anyone who wants to know the details about OpenStack++ implementation. Any feedback will be appreciated. I'll make it as a CMU tech report, so I hope to have feedback from you by 7/31 (Friday). Thanks. -- Kiryong -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: openstackpp.pdf Type: application/pdf Size: 4096215 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150728/c823bd47/attachment-0001.pdf From Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com Thu Jul 30 16:50:43 2015 From: Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com (Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group) Date: Thu, 30 Jul 2015 20:50:43 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Comments: A report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration, Message-ID: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A6182FD@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Hi Kiryong, Good document. I have added Adobe comments into the document itself. Please see attached. At the end of the document suggestions about what else could be mentioned in the document. Best regards Guenter -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Kiryong Ha Sent: 28 July 2015 14:57 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: [oe-sync] A report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration, Hi all, Please find the attachment for the report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration (OpenStack++). This report covers design decision and implementation details of OpenStack++ including technical challenges. I believe it would be useful for anyone who wants to know the details about OpenStack++ implementation. Any feedback will be appreciated. I'll make it as a CMU tech report, so I hope to have feedback from you by 7/31 (Friday). Thanks. -- Kiryong -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: openstackpp GK1 150730.pdf Type: application/pdf Size: 4126460 bytes Desc: openstackpp GK1 150730.pdf Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150730/a30d672b/attachment-0001.pdf From krha at cmu.edu Fri Jul 31 09:46:19 2015 From: krha at cmu.edu (Kiryong Ha) Date: Fri, 31 Jul 2015 09:46:19 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] Comments: A report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration, In-Reply-To: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A6182FD@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A6182FD@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: Hi Guenter, Thank you for the comment. I'll update the report and distribute the final version soon. Thanks again for your time. -- Kiryong On Thu, Jul 30, 2015 at 4:50 PM, Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group wrote: > Hi Kiryong, > > Good document. I have added Adobe comments into the document itself. Please see attached. > At the end of the document suggestions about what else could be mentioned in the document. > > Best regards > Guenter > > > -----Original Message----- > From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Kiryong Ha > Sent: 28 July 2015 14:57 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: [oe-sync] A report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration, > > Hi all, > > Please find the attachment for the report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration (OpenStack++). This report covers design decision and implementation details of OpenStack++ including technical challenges. > I believe it would be useful for anyone who wants to know the details about OpenStack++ implementation. > > Any feedback will be appreciated. I'll make it as a CMU tech report, so I hope to have feedback from you by 7/31 (Friday). Thanks. > > > -- > Kiryong -- Kiryong From Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com Fri Jul 31 12:12:20 2015 From: Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com (Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group) Date: Fri, 31 Jul 2015 16:12:20 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Comments: A report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration, In-Reply-To: References: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A6182FD@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A6198AB@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Kiryong, great, looking forward to the final version then. Guenter -----Original Message----- From: Kiryong Ha [mailto:krha at cmu.edu] Sent: 31 July 2015 14:46 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu; Haeffner, Walter, Vodafone DE; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group Subject: Re: Comments: [oe-sync] A report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration, Hi Guenter, Thank you for the comment. I'll update the report and distribute the final version soon. Thanks again for your time. -- Kiryong On Thu, Jul 30, 2015 at 4:50 PM, Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group wrote: > Hi Kiryong, > > Good document. I have added Adobe comments into the document itself. Please see attached. > At the end of the document suggestions about what else could be mentioned in the document. > > Best regards > Guenter > > > -----Original Message----- > From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > ] On Behalf Of Kiryong Ha > Sent: 28 July 2015 14:57 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: [oe-sync] A report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration, > > Hi all, > > Please find the attachment for the report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration (OpenStack++). This report covers design decision and implementation details of OpenStack++ including technical challenges. > I believe it would be useful for anyone who wants to know the details about OpenStack++ implementation. > > Any feedback will be appreciated. I'll make it as a CMU tech report, so I hope to have feedback from you by 7/31 (Friday). Thanks. > > > -- > Kiryong -- Kiryong From Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com Fri Jul 31 12:38:17 2015 From: Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com (Prakash Ramchandran) Date: Fri, 31 Jul 2015 16:38:17 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Comments: A report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration, In-Reply-To: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A6198AB@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A6182FD@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A6198AB@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB08940A08@SJCEML702-CHM.china.huawei.com> I will take a look tomorrow on this as was tied with OPNFV at ODL - thanks Prakash Prakash Ramchandran R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work:? +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Friday, July 31, 2015 9:12 AM To: Kiryong Ha Cc: Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Haeffner, Walter, Vodafone DE; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Comments: A report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration, Kiryong, great, looking forward to the final version then. Guenter -----Original Message----- From: Kiryong Ha [mailto:krha at cmu.edu] Sent: 31 July 2015 14:46 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu; Haeffner, Walter, Vodafone DE; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group Subject: Re: Comments: [oe-sync] A report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration, Hi Guenter, Thank you for the comment. I'll update the report and distribute the final version soon. Thanks again for your time. -- Kiryong On Thu, Jul 30, 2015 at 4:50 PM, Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group wrote: > Hi Kiryong, > > Good document. I have added Adobe comments into the document itself. Please see attached. > At the end of the document suggestions about what else could be mentioned in the document. > > Best regards > Guenter > > > -----Original Message----- > From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > ] On Behalf Of Kiryong Ha > Sent: 28 July 2015 14:57 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: [oe-sync] A report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration, > > Hi all, > > Please find the attachment for the report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration (OpenStack++). This report covers design decision and implementation details of OpenStack++ including technical challenges. > I believe it would be useful for anyone who wants to know the details about OpenStack++ implementation. > > Any feedback will be appreciated. I'll make it as a CMU tech report, so I hope to have feedback from you by 7/31 (Friday). Thanks. > > > -- > Kiryong -- Kiryong _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync From Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com Mon Aug 3 03:39:13 2015 From: Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com (Prakash Ramchandran) Date: Mon, 3 Aug 2015 07:39:13 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Comments: A report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration, In-Reply-To: <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB08940A08@SJCEML702-CHM.china.huawei.com> References: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A6182FD@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A6198AB@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB08940A08@SJCEML702-CHM.china.huawei.com> Message-ID: <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB08940E48@SJCEML702-CHM.china.huawei.com> Kiryong, Gunter has many comments and we can review and answer them and modify accordingly. However my concern is if we expect that Cloudlet is to be an independent module, we will need a separate API like Cloudlet - Register - POST image Provider timestamp - Create - POST tenant - List - Get - Show - Get - Update - Put ...(other attributes like share, up, down, image name...) - offload I am just pointing from RESTful APIs that will be supported by cloudlet Virtual Data Center (VDC) at the edge. We may need to look from Cloudlet python-client or DevOps persepective too. Since this is based currently on Nova, we need to see how we will intergrate through Nova and may be at later stage through Heat as Yaml template for stack creation for base + deltae (disk + images) So this needs some planning. Have added a blue print for now under launch pad with openstack. Rapid Just-in-time VM provisioning for cloud offload : Blueprints : cloudlet [image] Rapid Just-in-time VM provisioning for cloud offload : B... Cloudlet is a small-scale cloud data center(DC) at the edge of Internet. It is aimed to support resource-intensive and interactive mobile applications by providing ... View on blueprints.launchpa... Preview by Yahoo Tested the Tempest and that works now with Keystone with Neutron on my notebook. But that's not good enough except to review the tempest working with neutron. Repository Creator's Guide - OpenStack Project Infrastructure Manual 0.0.1.dev155 documentation Repository Creator's Guide - OpenStack Project Infrastructure Manual 0.0.1.dev155 documentation Adding the Repository to the CI System? To add a repository to the CI System, you need to modify some infrastructure configuration files using git and the OpenStack gerrit review server. Rest on the call morning. Thanks Prakash Prakash Ramchandran R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Prakash Ramchandran Sent: Friday, July 31, 2015 9:38 AM To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha Cc: Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Haeffner, Walter, Vodafone DE; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Comments: A report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration, I will take a look tomorrow on this as was tied with OPNFV at ODL - thanks Prakash Prakash Ramchandran R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Friday, July 31, 2015 9:12 AM To: Kiryong Ha Cc: Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Haeffner, Walter, Vodafone DE; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Comments: A report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration, Kiryong, great, looking forward to the final version then. Guenter -----Original Message----- From: Kiryong Ha [mailto:krha at cmu.edu] Sent: 31 July 2015 14:46 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu; Haeffner, Walter, Vodafone DE; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group Subject: Re: Comments: [oe-sync] A report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration, Hi Guenter, Thank you for the comment. I'll update the report and distribute the final version soon. Thanks again for your time. -- Kiryong On Thu, Jul 30, 2015 at 4:50 PM, Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group wrote: > Hi Kiryong, > > Good document. I have added Adobe comments into the document itself. Please see attached. > At the end of the document suggestions about what else could be mentioned in the document. > > Best regards > Guenter > > > -----Original Message----- > From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > ] On Behalf Of Kiryong Ha > Sent: 28 July 2015 14:57 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: [oe-sync] A report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration, > > Hi all, > > Please find the attachment for the report on OpenStack Cloudlet integration (OpenStack++). This report covers design decision and implementation details of OpenStack++ including technical challenges. > I believe it would be useful for anyone who wants to know the details about OpenStack++ implementation. > > Any feedback will be appreciated. I'll make it as a CMU tech report, so I hope to have feedback from you by 7/31 (Friday). Thanks. > > > -- > Kiryong -- Kiryong _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150803/b6ca4565/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image003.png Type: image/png Size: 20618 bytes Desc: image003.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150803/b6ca4565/attachment-0001.png From Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com Sun Aug 9 06:49:07 2015 From: Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com (Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group) Date: Sun, 9 Aug 2015 10:49:07 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] apps development for edge cloud Message-ID: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A62E341@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Hi Kiryong, Rolf, Much effort is currently focusing on the edge cloud infrastructure due to many challenges still to solve. On the other hand, I'm also interested in understanding what an apps developer has to consider if a deployment of (parts of) an application on a Cloudlet is feasible. I assume that the CMU team has some good experience regarding 'application design for Cloudlets' from the demos created in the past. Questions that come to my mind: - Is application development exactly the same as when I develop an app for deployment on a mobile device + interaction with the SW in the tier 1 cloud? - Is application development exactly the same as today for different types of technologies: e.g. Android apps, web applications ...? If things are not exactly the same and if the apps developer has to "design with deployment on Cloudlets in mind", then I would argue we should run a workshop with the attendance of some selected apps developers to i) explain what needs to be taken into account and ii) to get their feedback. Once this is done, and once we have some "portable" or "recommendable" reference platform for Cloudlet in place, one could consider a hackathon to explore further with the apps developer community... Any thoughts about this? Guenter -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150809/717b2ea9/attachment.html From Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com Sun Aug 9 15:24:10 2015 From: Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com (Prakash Ramchandran) Date: Sun, 9 Aug 2015 19:24:10 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] apps development for edge cloud In-Reply-To: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A62E341@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A62E341@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB089422EF@SJCEML702-CHM.china.huawei.com> Gunter, I consider your inputs reasonable, since the adoption of any new use case depends on how the changes impact both application and systems to derive the benefits or value claimed. If there is a basis for that for anyone to adapt then we must educate them on why and how they should proceed. Let's talk about it and get consensus within the team to address going forward. Thanks Prakash Prakash Ramchandran [logo_huawei] R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Sunday, August 09, 2015 3:49 AM To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Subject: [oe-sync] apps development for edge cloud Hi Kiryong, Rolf, Much effort is currently focusing on the edge cloud infrastructure due to many challenges still to solve. On the other hand, I'm also interested in understanding what an apps developer has to consider if a deployment of (parts of) an application on a Cloudlet is feasible. I assume that the CMU team has some good experience regarding 'application design for Cloudlets' from the demos created in the past. Questions that come to my mind: - Is application development exactly the same as when I develop an app for deployment on a mobile device + interaction with the SW in the tier 1 cloud? - Is application development exactly the same as today for different types of technologies: e.g. Android apps, web applications ...? If things are not exactly the same and if the apps developer has to "design with deployment on Cloudlets in mind", then I would argue we should run a workshop with the attendance of some selected apps developers to i) explain what needs to be taken into account and ii) to get their feedback. Once this is done, and once we have some "portable" or "recommendable" reference platform for Cloudlet in place, one could consider a hackathon to explore further with the apps developer community... Any thoughts about this? Guenter -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150809/b448b1fc/attachment.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image001.png Type: image/png Size: 3243 bytes Desc: image001.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150809/b448b1fc/attachment.png From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Sun Aug 9 16:55:55 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Sun, 9 Aug 2015 20:55:55 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] apps development for edge cloud In-Reply-To: <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB089422EF@SJCEML702-CHM.china.huawei.com> References: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A62E341@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB089422EF@SJCEML702-CHM.china.huawei.com> Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832897AB@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Very relevant point. Developers will have to think of three entities: their app the edge server component (with a selected set of functionalities, e.g. low latency stuff) and the backend server component (with the rest of the functionalities e.g. large databases). This will be a new situation for developers. Over time we need a easy to use developer guide / introduction and a sand-box to play around. I guess also the OpenStack++-download package (Kiryong builds for the CMU-class) will be part of this. Kind regards Rolf. From: Prakash Ramchandran [mailto:Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com] Sent: Sonntag, 9. August 2015 21:24 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Subject: RE: apps development for edge cloud Gunter, I consider your inputs reasonable, since the adoption of any new use case depends on how the changes impact both application and systems to derive the benefits or value claimed. If there is a basis for that for anyone to adapt then we must educate them on why and how they should proceed. Let's talk about it and get consensus within the team to address going forward. Thanks Prakash Prakash Ramchandran [logo_huawei] R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Sunday, August 09, 2015 3:49 AM To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Subject: [oe-sync] apps development for edge cloud Hi Kiryong, Rolf, Much effort is currently focusing on the edge cloud infrastructure due to many challenges still to solve. On the other hand, I'm also interested in understanding what an apps developer has to consider if a deployment of (parts of) an application on a Cloudlet is feasible. I assume that the CMU team has some good experience regarding 'application design for Cloudlets' from the demos created in the past. Questions that come to my mind: - Is application development exactly the same as when I develop an app for deployment on a mobile device + interaction with the SW in the tier 1 cloud? - Is application development exactly the same as today for different types of technologies: e.g. Android apps, web applications ...? If things are not exactly the same and if the apps developer has to "design with deployment on Cloudlets in mind", then I would argue we should run a workshop with the attendance of some selected apps developers to i) explain what needs to be taken into account and ii) to get their feedback. Once this is done, and once we have some "portable" or "recommendable" reference platform for Cloudlet in place, one could consider a hackathon to explore further with the apps developer community... Any thoughts about this? Guenter -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150809/d7f97545/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image001.png Type: image/png Size: 3243 bytes Desc: image001.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150809/d7f97545/attachment-0001.png From padmanabhan.s.pillai at intel.com Mon Aug 10 14:10:22 2015 From: padmanabhan.s.pillai at intel.com (Padmanabhan Pillai) Date: Mon, 10 Aug 2015 14:10:22 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] apps development for edge cloud In-Reply-To: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A62E341@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A62E341@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <55C8E90E.8060108@intel.com> Hi Guenter, This is an excellent point. I think in general, to get the most out of cloudlets, one would need to design the system with the cloudlet tier in mind. For existing apps that are partitioned between client and cloud, this may require refactoring of the cloud part into cloudlet and cloud components. The difficulty of doing this will vary significantly by application. For a small set of applications, moving to cloudlets will be trivial. For these, the cloud backend is primarily computational, without a large amount of data. Here, the cloud component can just be run on the cloudlet instead of the remote cloud. Applications of this sort are the low-hanging fruit that can make use of cloudlets with no additional effort. Some of the new applications we have been exploring at CMU, such as the cognitive assistance apps, also fit in this category -- the backends are largely self-contained computation engines that don't rely on external data (other than sensor streams from the client). Some applications that have large cloud-based data sets can work well on cloudlets with relatively little modification. Although the whole data set may be very large, there may be significant locality to the data access from a particular cloudlet (and the clients it serves), so standard caching approaches may be sufficient to let these applications work well. I can imagine this can work well for map data (due to geographic locality) and any data that is tied to particular users (web file store, pictures, etc.). Perhaps a common "cloudlet recipe" for such applications is to leave the data store in the cloud, but put all of the application logic and a caching tier in the cloudlet component. I would imagine that for existing, large, high performance cloud applications, the storage is already a separate component, and the individual compute nodes in the datacenter likely use caching already anyway, so the cloudlet recipe would probably not entail significant modifications. For new applications, the structure prescribed is a good one, even if cloudlets were not the target platform. I like the idea of creating a reference that prescribes different "recipes" for designing / retrofitting various types of applications for cloudlet deployment. This will require some work -- I personally don't have a good feel for how to divide up the application space or on concrete recommendations. I think we will need a lot more experience with real applications to get a better sense of this. - Babu On 08/09/2015 06:49 AM, Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group wrote: > > Hi Kiryong, Rolf, > > Much effort is currently focusing on the edge cloud infrastructure due > to many challenges still to solve. On the other hand, I?m also > interested in understanding what an apps developer has to consider if > a deployment of (parts of) an application on a Cloudlet is feasible. > > I assume that the CMU team has some good experience regarding > ?application design for Cloudlets? from the demos created in the past. > > Questions that come to my mind: > > - Is application development exactly the same as when I develop an app > for deployment on a mobile device + interaction with the SW in the > tier 1 cloud? > > - Is application development exactly the same as today for different > types of technologies: e.g. Android apps, web applications ?? > > If things are not exactly the same and if the apps developer has to > ?design with deployment on Cloudlets in mind?, then I would argue we > should run a workshop with the attendance of some selected apps > developers to i) explain what needs to be taken into account and ii) > to get their feedback. > > Once this is done, and once we have some ?portable? or ?recommendable? > reference platform for Cloudlet in place, one could consider a > hackathon to explore further with the apps developer community? > > Any thoughts about this? > > Guenter > > > > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150810/da1e62f0/attachment.html From krha at cmu.edu Wed Aug 12 20:32:14 2015 From: krha at cmu.edu (Kiryong Ha) Date: Wed, 12 Aug 2015 20:32:14 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] Slide from today's meeting, Message-ID: Hi Ashlee, Please find attachments for the slide of today's meeting. 1. OpenEdge-schedule.pptx: slide for schedule and more resource 2. OpenEdge-implementation.pptx: slide for technical details and challenges Please find the details of the current status from the following links. 1) Starting point : http://reports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2015/CMU-CS-15-123.pdf 2) Technical details - Rapid Provisioning: http://krha.kr/data/pubs/vmsynthesis2013-slide.pptx (Paper: http://krha.kr/data/pubs/vmsynthesis2013.pdf) - VM handoff: http://reports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2015/CMU-CS-15-113.pdf 3) Code - Core library: https://github.com/cmusatyalab/elijah-provisioning - OpenStack binding: https://github.com/cmusatyalab/elijah-openstack In addition, we have weekly Open Edge Tech meeting on every Monday, from 11:30 am (EDT). Here's a WebEx information. link: https://cmusatyalab.webex.com/cmusatyalab/j.php?MTID=m159d6f4f3ea1cdc513901862739b7663 (If for some reason this URL gives you trouble, go to http://cmusatyalab.webex.com and manually enter details below) 1-650-479-3208 Call-in toll number (US/Canada) Meeting number: 735 021 043 Meeting password: openstack Thanks. I look forward to working with you and your team. -- Kiryong -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: OpenEdge-implementation.pptx Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.presentationml.presentation Size: 1024485 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150812/9f77f806/attachment-0002.bin -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: OpenEdge-schedule.pptx Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.presentationml.presentation Size: 76142 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150812/9f77f806/attachment-0003.bin From ashlee.young at huawei.com Thu Aug 13 00:02:51 2015 From: ashlee.young at huawei.com (Michael Young (Ashlee)) Date: Thu, 13 Aug 2015 04:02:51 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Slide from today's meeting, In-Reply-To: References: Message-ID: <6C7E468B-C9AD-4877-A569-10190F808B6B@huawei.com> Thanks Kiryong! I also sent the additional contacts to you in a separate email. Best, Ash Sent from my iPhone > On Aug 12, 2015, at 5:32 PM, Kiryong Ha wrote: > > Hi Ashlee, > > Please find attachments for the slide of today's meeting. > 1. OpenEdge-schedule.pptx: slide for schedule and more resource > 2. OpenEdge-implementation.pptx: slide for technical details and challenges > > Please find the details of the current status from the following links. > 1) Starting point : > http://reports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2015/CMU-CS-15-123.pdf > 2) Technical details > - Rapid Provisioning: > http://krha.kr/data/pubs/vmsynthesis2013-slide.pptx (Paper: > http://krha.kr/data/pubs/vmsynthesis2013.pdf) > - VM handoff: > http://reports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2015/CMU-CS-15-113.pdf > 3) Code > - Core library: https://github.com/cmusatyalab/elijah-provisioning > - OpenStack binding: https://github.com/cmusatyalab/elijah-openstack > > > In addition, we have weekly Open Edge Tech meeting on every Monday, > from 11:30 am (EDT). Here's a WebEx information. > > link: https://cmusatyalab.webex.com/cmusatyalab/j.php?MTID=m159d6f4f3ea1cdc513901862739b7663 > (If for some reason this URL gives you trouble, go to > http://cmusatyalab.webex.com and manually enter details below) > > 1-650-479-3208 Call-in toll number (US/Canada) > Meeting number: 735 021 043 > Meeting password: openstack > > > Thanks. I look forward to working with you and your team. > > > -- > Kiryong > > From chasek at cs.cmu.edu Mon Aug 17 16:16:17 2015 From: chasek at cs.cmu.edu (Chase Klingensmith) Date: Mon, 17 Aug 2015 16:16:17 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] Updated Webex Details for Bi-Weekly Sync Meetings Message-ID: Hello everyone, The Webex Weekly Sync Meetings that were previously scheduled for every week will instead be held on a bi-weekly basis starting this Thursday. Some of the numbers on the previous list were also found to be incorrect so please discard and instead use the link below to find international calling numbers. It appears that some of these change or have changed in the past so please double-check the link to find the number in case there are problems connecting. A number of countries also have toll and toll-free options. If both are present, please use the toll option. Thank you, Chase Klingensmith Administrative Assistant, CSD Carnegie Mellon University School of Computer Science (412) 268-3041 ?? Open Edge ?Weekly ?S ync ?Every 2 weeks on Thursdays Host: Mahadev Satyanarayanan ? Meeting number: 737 875 986 Meeting password: ?oesync? Audio connection: ? +1-415-655-0002 US Global Call-In Numbers ?Access code: 737 865 028 Meeting Link? -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150817/3f38a45d/attachment.html From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Wed Aug 19 09:22:08 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Wed, 19 Aug 2015 13:22:08 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88328DBEB@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. - Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) --> DONE 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. Ideas: address verticals. 'Crowdsourcing' the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. --> Draft deck to be distributed 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. --> Has that happened? 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. 7. All: 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug - end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal --> Proposal from Satya under way... _____________________________________________ From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 Importance: High Hi there, Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well - We went through all agenda points - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. Any questions, please let me know. Best regards Guenter << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. Rolf. ______________________________ Dear all, As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas - Outreach Program Progress - Technical Program Progress - MEC Requirement Progress and go through the attached action item list. Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. Kind regards Rolf. Email from last meeting << Attachments: Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) >> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150819/895de106/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf Type: application/pdf Size: 207081 bytes Desc: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150819/895de106/attachment-0001.pdf -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.presentationml.presentation Size: 504173 bytes Desc: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150819/895de106/attachment-0002.bin -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.presentationml.presentation Size: 1580392 bytes Desc: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150819/895de106/attachment-0003.bin From yunchao.hu at huawei.com Wed Aug 19 18:41:32 2015 From: yunchao.hu at huawei.com (yunchao.hu at huawei.com) Date: Wed, 19 Aug 2015 23:41:32 +0100 Subject: [oe-sync] =?utf-8?q?FW=3A_Open_Edge_Computing_Initiative_-_Progre?= =?utf-8?q?ss_Call_on_Thursday_this_week?= Message-ID: <55d5061c.6b68079a.e46AnyOffice.svn.huawei> An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150819/b5198e5c/attachment.html From Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com Thu Aug 20 07:45:56 2015 From: Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com (Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group) Date: Thu, 20 Aug 2015 11:45:56 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week In-Reply-To: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88328DBEB@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88328DBEB@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A63C28A@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> For discussion: Related to Outreach program (see Rolf's slides, p7): - sub-goal of the outreach will be to get new ideas for how to commercially use cloudlets, encourage people to try things out and share experience. - Should we maintain a 'stakeholder list': key influencers in the industry, status of our engagement with them, their stance (red, amber, green). If everything is red/remains red, action required...If all green, there should be visible momentum. - For more discussion with OpenStack players: What discussion material is most suitable? E.g. I consider as very important technical documents the following three: 1. CMU-CS-15-123 Kiryong final report OpenStack++.pdf 2. CMU-CS-15-113 Adaptive VM handoff.pdf 3. CMU-CS-12-148 JIT Provisioning for Cyber Foraging.pdf However, it's not easy to have a 121 session with some OpenStack players as above docs amount to 50+ pages. Would it be useful to create a technical slide deck on the basis of the ppt from Kiryong/Prakash from Pittsburgh? For my own understanding, I have recently thought about how I that presentation could be extended. I attach my thoughts from mid August: I have e.g. added the pages indicated in the top right corner with NEW (p6, 11, 12, 13, 14). Comments on the overview slides of the OECI: Page 3: - What is meant with "Very small devices"? smaller smartphones? iWatch type? Google Glass type? - On right side, what is meant by "Local Resilience"? Why "local"? Is the message, centralisation leads to reliance on a few DC facilities? - We could add the factors which Satya has highlighted in papers and presentations: becoming available: new type of devices, engines for face recognition etc...., as these are enablers for very new use cases. Page 18: - The arrows in the picture: how shall they be read: Arrow points from x to y: x calls an API on y? x invokes something on y? - The arrow for A: Cloudlet Discover: Is this going indeed from device to the edge server, or instead to a discovery service (which can be located anywhere)? E.g. we said it could even be a Zynga-specific discovery server, found by the Zynga app on the device. - The B-API for VM provisioning: Not sure whether the arrow makes sense. Is the cloud platform invoking something in a VM? Isn't the user/app deciding to use an edge service once discovered and starts to invoke the VM provisioning workflow? Should arrow B go from app on device to Open Cloud platform in the cloudlet? - Similar for the C-API: Is triggered by the app on the device I suspect (at least in cloudlet context, not in ETSI MEC context). Further: Would it be useful to each have a slide for different stakeholder groups: Real-world touch points with Cloudlets or workflow interfaces to Cloudlets or operational aspects regarding cloudlets? .... As these slides could be used for outreach to different groups. To give some examples: - For network operator: - May deploy cloud software at edge locations (incl. base VMs) - May operate a discovery service - May offer PaaS components to developers e.g. to create launch VMs - Etc. For application developer: - May create and run their own cloudlet discovery service - May create applications designed to execute on both tier 1 cloud and at the edge - May create apps that can offload execution to the edge on user demand - Will use cloudlet platform API(s) to create launch VM and overlay VM - Will make overlay VM available either together with app or on a particular web location - May develop mechanism for the app to decide when to request a handoff For an enterprise: - May deploy edge servers at locations across the enterprise premises/campus - Etc. Br Guenter From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 19 August 2015 14:22 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: [oe-sync] FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, ? please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. ? Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) --> DONE 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. Ideas: address verticals. 'Crowdsourcing' the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. --> Draft deck to be distributed 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. --> Has that happened? 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. 7. All: 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug - end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal --> Proposal from Satya under way... _____________________________________________ From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 Importance: High Hi there, Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well - We went through all agenda points - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. Any questions, please let me know. Best regards Guenter << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. Rolf. ______________________________ Dear all, As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas ? Outreach Program Progress ? Technical Program Progress ? MEC Requirement Progress and go through the attached action item list. Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. Kind regards Rolf. Email from last meeting << Attachments: Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) >> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150820/b637dac0/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: OpenEdgeComputing-implementation Kiryong GK.pptx Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.presentationml.presentation Size: 3022414 bytes Desc: OpenEdgeComputing-implementation Kiryong GK.pptx Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150820/b637dac0/attachment-0001.bin From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Fri Aug 21 09:48:11 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Fri, 21 Aug 2015 13:48:11 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week In-Reply-To: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A63C28A@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88328DBEB@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A63C28A@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88328DF86@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Thanks Guenter, I agree, it would be good to have a self-explanatory technical slide deck as we start distributing things now. Good points regarding my deck. I will look at it together with the other comments. Kind regards Rolf. From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 20. August 2015 13:46 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: RE: [oe-sync] FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week For discussion: Related to Outreach program (see Rolf's slides, p7): - sub-goal of the outreach will be to get new ideas for how to commercially use cloudlets, encourage people to try things out and share experience. - Should we maintain a 'stakeholder list': key influencers in the industry, status of our engagement with them, their stance (red, amber, green). If everything is red/remains red, action required...If all green, there should be visible momentum. - For more discussion with OpenStack players: What discussion material is most suitable? E.g. I consider as very important technical documents the following three: 1. CMU-CS-15-123 Kiryong final report OpenStack++.pdf 2. CMU-CS-15-113 Adaptive VM handoff.pdf 3. CMU-CS-12-148 JIT Provisioning for Cyber Foraging.pdf However, it's not easy to have a 121 session with some OpenStack players as above docs amount to 50+ pages. Would it be useful to create a technical slide deck on the basis of the ppt from Kiryong/Prakash from Pittsburgh? For my own understanding, I have recently thought about how I that presentation could be extended. I attach my thoughts from mid August: I have e.g. added the pages indicated in the top right corner with NEW (p6, 11, 12, 13, 14). Comments on the overview slides of the OECI: Page 3: - What is meant with "Very small devices"? smaller smartphones? iWatch type? Google Glass type? - On right side, what is meant by "Local Resilience"? Why "local"? Is the message, centralisation leads to reliance on a few DC facilities? - We could add the factors which Satya has highlighted in papers and presentations: becoming available: new type of devices, engines for face recognition etc...., as these are enablers for very new use cases. Page 18: - The arrows in the picture: how shall they be read: Arrow points from x to y: x calls an API on y? x invokes something on y? - The arrow for A: Cloudlet Discover: Is this going indeed from device to the edge server, or instead to a discovery service (which can be located anywhere)? E.g. we said it could even be a Zynga-specific discovery server, found by the Zynga app on the device. - The B-API for VM provisioning: Not sure whether the arrow makes sense. Is the cloud platform invoking something in a VM? Isn't the user/app deciding to use an edge service once discovered and starts to invoke the VM provisioning workflow? Should arrow B go from app on device to Open Cloud platform in the cloudlet? - Similar for the C-API: Is triggered by the app on the device I suspect (at least in cloudlet context, not in ETSI MEC context). Further: Would it be useful to each have a slide for different stakeholder groups: Real-world touch points with Cloudlets or workflow interfaces to Cloudlets or operational aspects regarding cloudlets? .... As these slides could be used for outreach to different groups. To give some examples: - For network operator: - May deploy cloud software at edge locations (incl. base VMs) - May operate a discovery service - May offer PaaS components to developers e.g. to create launch VMs - Etc. For application developer: - May create and run their own cloudlet discovery service - May create applications designed to execute on both tier 1 cloud and at the edge - May create apps that can offload execution to the edge on user demand - Will use cloudlet platform API(s) to create launch VM and overlay VM - Will make overlay VM available either together with app or on a particular web location - May develop mechanism for the app to decide when to request a handoff For an enterprise: - May deploy edge servers at locations across the enterprise premises/campus - Etc. Br Guenter From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 19 August 2015 14:22 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: [oe-sync] FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, ? please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. ? Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) --> DONE 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. Ideas: address verticals. 'Crowdsourcing' the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. --> Draft deck to be distributed 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. --> Has that happened? 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. 7. All: 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug - end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal --> Proposal from Satya under way... _____________________________________________ From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 Importance: High Hi there, Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well - We went through all agenda points - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. Any questions, please let me know. Best regards Guenter << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. Rolf. ______________________________ Dear all, As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas ? Outreach Program Progress ? Technical Program Progress ? MEC Requirement Progress and go through the attached action item list. Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. Kind regards Rolf. Email from last meeting << Attachments: Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) >> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150821/72f8dbd4/attachment-0001.html From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Fri Aug 21 10:37:36 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Fri, 21 Aug 2015 14:37:36 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88328DFA6@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions... Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. Many thanks Rolf. Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. - Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) --> DONE 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. Ideas: address verticals. 'Crowdsourcing' the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. --> Draft deck to be distributed 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. --> Has that happened? 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. 7. All: 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug - end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal --> Proposal from Satya under way... _____________________________________________ From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 Importance: High Hi there, Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well - We went through all agenda points - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. Any questions, please let me know. Best regards Guenter << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. Rolf. ______________________________ Dear all, As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas - Outreach Program Progress - Technical Program Progress - MEC Requirement Progress and go through the attached action item list. Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. Kind regards Rolf. Email from last meeting << Attachments: Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) >> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150821/8cf4f278/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.presentationml.presentation Size: 1580065 bytes Desc: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150821/8cf4f278/attachment-0001.bin From Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com Fri Aug 21 10:46:41 2015 From: Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com (Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group) Date: Fri, 21 Aug 2015 14:46:41 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Edge NFV project proposal approved in OPNFV - relevance? Message-ID: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A63DBF1@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Hi there, As a project proposal called Edge NFV has been approved in OPNFV on 18 August (a few days ago), can I ask whether anyone knows more about this and what the implications might be. URL to the meeting minutes form OPNFV, 18 Aug: https://wiki.opnfv.org/wiki/tsc Copied from there: Project creation review: Edge NFV: James outlines that the project intends to enable the utilization of edge compute capability in the OPNFV infrastructure, and the focus of EdgeNFV project is on the compute node. James has also been in communications with the LSO team and does not foresee conflicts between EdgeNFV & LSO projects. The project creation was approved via the IRC vote. URL to Edge NFV: https://wiki.opnfv.org/project_proposals/enfv Committers: James Buchanan - jbuchanan at advaoptical.com - Project Lead Qiao Fu - fuqiao at chinamobile.com Chris Donley / TBD - c.donley at cablelabs.com Prayson Pate - Prayson.Pate at overturenetworks.com OpenStack is one of the upstream communities they target. At least, the proposal reveals that certain companies do have an interesting in readying OpenStack, Open Daylight, OVS for edge computing. Br Guenter From Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com Sat Aug 22 05:40:19 2015 From: Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com (Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group) Date: Sat, 22 Aug 2015 09:40:19 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Example of prep work in downstream org to feed into upstream OpenStack project Message-ID: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A644A62@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Hi there, I was curious to understand how people in OPNFV successfully get stuff into OpenStack. So I searched for anything that apparently made it into OpenStack and I wanted to understand what happened i) on the OPNFV side (that would be comparable to our side on Open Edge Initiative) and ii) on OpenStack side. So this serves for illustration purposes of what other people have done. I may draw some analogies to Cloudlets as well. Before clicking on any links below, please read the whole email to get the gist of the story. I colour the text: Black: we are in OPNFV land. Red: we are moving into OpenStack land Green: we are in Launchpad land Starting on OPNFV side: 1. I discovered the OPNFV project Doctor (assume this is a project outside OpenStack like e.g. cloudlets). 2. Doctor is on the list of OPNFV projects that target the upstream OpenStack project to trigger improvements there. The list is here: https://wiki.opnfv.org/community/openstack 3. A URL in 2 leads to Doctor's summary description at OPNFV and its project management page (highly useful), see here: https://wiki.opnfv.org/doctor 4. A URL in 3 leads to the requirements and architecture document for Doctor, pdf 47 pages, see http://artifacts.opnfv.org/doctor/DoctorFaultManagementandMaintenance.pdf 5. A URL in 3 leads to the project proposal description (Doctor in OPNFV), incl. e.g. a presentation, see https://wiki.opnfv.org/_media/doctor_141208.pdf 6. A URL in 3 points to the blueprint targeting Nova. >From here we are now in OpenStack land: https://review.openstack.org/#/q/topic:bp/mark-host-down,n,z 7. Alternatively, still in OPNFV, there is a list of blueprints at OPNFV. See the line for Nova. Here you find 3 URLs referring to 3 blueprints targeting Nova for OPNV Doctor https://wiki.opnfv.org/community/openstack 8. Following the first URL in 7 under Nova (New Nova API call) leads into OpenStack land: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/169836/ The text here says: this implements a particular blueprint "mark host down". And the stuff has been included into some master branch of Nova. 9. A URL in 8 would link to the blueprint itself, but that appears to have vanished on Launchpad (maybe that's part of the process ;-) https://blueprints.launchpad.net/openstack/?searchtext=mark-host-down 10. Following the second URL in 7 under Nova (Support forcing service down) leads into Launchpad: 11. https://blueprints.launchpad.net/python-novaclient/+spec/support-force-down-service (this is for a Nova client). 12. From 11, there is a nice URL again to cross-reference another blueprint for "New Nova API call to mark nova-compute down" covering Nova itself, also on Launchpad. It leads to: https://blueprints.launchpad.net/nova/+spec/mark-host-down This is now very similar to Prakash's blueprint for cloudlets as we have seen. Takeaway: we talked about outreach on the side of Open Edge Initiative. Apart from CMU's/Satya's website and our new storage server, we currently have no website to share information with more people. Above is just an illustration of how the OPNFV people organise/share/store their work and prepare for the transition into OpenStack. I think it's quite useful/good. I recall that we talked about reusing OPNFV and then for the time being abandoned the idea as we felt it would introduce an intermediate stage not useful for us, as we need to target OpenStack anyway. My view now is: Path A: We create our own website for open edge initiative and structure info there to attract developers, organise work, have a hub of URLs that point to Launchpad, OpenStack etc. - Upside: no dependency on OPNFV. We could learn from the good things in OPNFV and avoid the things that work less well. - Downside: need to start pretty much from scratch, however I trust Ashlee it's all doable. Path B: We use the OPNFV existing website machinery to set up our own open edge initiative project (like Doctor and others) to organise work on the side of Open Edge Initiative and prepare for OpenStack. - Upside: reuse of the OPNFV website, exposure to the developers from the OPNFV community, similar to the Edge NFV project from China Mobile. - Downside: possible lack of identity for "Open Edge Initiative", need to get approval from OPNFV board, unclear positioning vis-?-vis Edge NFV project. Anyway, hope the illustration is insightful for those who aren't that familiar with OPNFV yet. Br Guenter -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150822/e2da19d6/attachment.html From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Tue Aug 25 05:17:26 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Tue, 25 Aug 2015 09:17:26 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88329374D@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, As agreed here is the invite for our bi-weekly progress call on Thursdays. Please distribute your deliverables / documents for that call to the participants latest on Wednesday before the call (best until noon EDT). Looking forward to discuss progress with you. Kind regards Rolf. Dial-in Details for bi-weekly Progress Call --> please use phone dial-in and NOT VoIP (to ensure acceptable voice quality) --> please use toll phone numbers outside of US (link below) to avoid additional cost for CMU the host of the WebEx session Host: Mahadev Satyanarayanan ?Meeting number: 737 875 986 Meeting password: oesync? Audio connection: ? +1-415-655-0002 US Global Call-In Numbers ? Access code: 737 865 028 Meeting Link? -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150825/b4ba00c1/attachment.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: not available Type: text/calendar Size: 2754 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150825/b4ba00c1/attachment.bin From Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com Sat Aug 29 19:30:02 2015 From: Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com (Prakash Ramchandran) Date: Sat, 29 Aug 2015 23:30:02 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Edge NFV project proposal approved in OPNFV - relevance? In-Reply-To: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A63DBF1@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A63DBF1@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB0895BB02@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> Hi all, Based on the proposal this is more to do with selective network traffic acceleration at the edge for a concept called Distributed NFV. The applications stated are for Ethernet over Optical and project looking for use cases that help build D-NFV. So one can think of this as connected isolated NFV PoPs, may be somewhat similar to Segmentation use case in ONOS as I recollect. Refer Scope: This is a requirements project, therefore it is proposed to develop use cases, requirements, as well as upstream project blue prints and associated test cases. Now please let me know if we want to leverage this to get a BP in OpenStack for our needs and add our use case to this. If so can some of you in MEC or OEC team draw an architectural difference between D-NFV, OEC/MEC & OPNFV(ETSI NFV Reference Architecture) for Infrastructure to say, if our use case applies to this. Certainly there is a low latency element but that bringing UP closer to CP or more to do more with DP acceleration for selective traffic through edge: WAN Acceleration, Content Caching, Firewalling? If everyone agrees, we can add one of our user applications like Glasses etc to it, but otherwise it appears to be more in Infrastructure MEF LSO like play. We can discuss this in our meetings. Thanks Prakash Ramchandran R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work:? +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Friday, August 21, 2015 7:47 AM To: Mahadev Satyanarayanan; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group Subject: [oe-sync] Edge NFV project proposal approved in OPNFV - relevance? Hi there, As a project proposal called Edge NFV has been approved in OPNFV on 18 August (a few days ago), can I ask whether anyone knows more about this and what the implications might be. URL to the meeting minutes form OPNFV, 18 Aug: https://wiki.opnfv.org/wiki/tsc Copied from there: Project creation review: Edge NFV: James outlines that the project intends to enable the utilization of edge compute capability in the OPNFV infrastructure, and the focus of EdgeNFV project is on the compute node. James has also been in communications with the LSO team and does not foresee conflicts between EdgeNFV & LSO projects. The project creation was approved via the IRC vote. URL to Edge NFV: https://wiki.opnfv.org/project_proposals/enfv Committers: James Buchanan - jbuchanan at advaoptical.com - Project Lead Qiao Fu - fuqiao at chinamobile.com Chris Donley / TBD - c.donley at cablelabs.com Prayson Pate - Prayson.Pate at overturenetworks.com OpenStack is one of the upstream communities they target. At least, the proposal reveals that certain companies do have an interesting in readying OpenStack, Open Daylight, OVS for edge computing. Br Guenter _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Tue Sep 1 16:53:36 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Tue, 1 Sep 2015 20:53:36 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88329A2AE@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and - please have a look at the action items below from our last call and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. Kind regards Rolf. Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 21. August 2015 16:38 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions... Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. Many thanks Rolf. << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx >> Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. - Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) --> DONE 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. Ideas: address verticals. 'Crowdsourcing' the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. --> Draft deck to be distributed 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. --> Has that happened? 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. 7. All: 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug - end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal --> Proposal from Satya under way... _____________________________________________ From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 Importance: High Hi there, Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well - We went through all agenda points - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. Any questions, please let me know. Best regards Guenter << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. Rolf. ______________________________ Dear all, As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas - Outreach Program Progress - Technical Program Progress - MEC Requirement Progress and go through the attached action item list. Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. Kind regards Rolf. Email from last meeting << Attachments: Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) >> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150901/7c54a3f4/attachment-0001.html From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Wed Sep 2 15:39:59 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Wed, 2 Sep 2015 19:39:59 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week In-Reply-To: <96EFD7465592EA4A9CCEAAB849F4DFF6A44823A6@ORSMSX105.amr.corp.intel.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88328DFA6@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <96EFD7465592EA4A9CCEAAB849F4DFF6A44823A6@ORSMSX105.amr.corp.intel.com> Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88329BD88@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Valerie, Guenter and Satya, Many thanks for your feedback regarding our joint presentation. Below, I listed the changes I have done (in red) based on your feedback in the final deck (attached).. @All, Yes, there is still a lot of room for improvement with the deck. In particular we should discuss if anybody has access to marketing resources to improve the design and layout of the presentation. Still, I would like to get that approved in our call tomorrow, such that all of us have a "neutral" deck about the initiative to share. Fine for you for now? Kind regards Rolf. From: Young, Valerie J [mailto:valerie.j.young at intel.com] Sent: Mittwoch, 26. August 2015 03:28 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: Mahadev Satyanarayanan (satya at cs.cmu.edu); yunchao hu (yunchao.hu at HUAWEI.COM) Subject: RE: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Hi Rolf, The deck is a good start. Some minor tweaks were made. Would it be better to state that the initiative is driving from the cloud to the network? --> I changed the wording of the "main target" on slide 6 to "Enable Cloud Computing at the Edge". We should discuss that. I would avoid the work network, as that is everywhere... When will you be presenting? --> Potential partners, MEC Congress in September in London... It does not have anything about the course and potential next steps. Should we discuss those? --> I added a slide on current activities and plans. We have to remember to either update it regularly or take it out... Thanks, Best regards, Valerie Comments from Guenter Page 3: - What is meant with "Very small devices"? smaller smartphones? iWatch type? Google Glass type? - On right side, what is meant by "Local Resilience"? Why "local"? Is the message, centralisation leads to reliance on a few DC facilities? - We could add the factors which Satya has highlighted in papers and presentations: becoming available: new type of devices, engines for face recognition etc...., as these are enablers for very new use cases. --> Yes, the slide requires the voice track to be understood. I have change the wording slightly for more clarity and added a note page with the explanation of the thoughts behind the trends. Page 18: - The arrows in the picture: how shall they be read: Arrow points from x to y: x calls an API on y? x invokes something on y? - The arrow for A: Cloudlet Discover: Is this going indeed from device to the edge server, or instead to a discovery service (which can be located anywhere)? E.g. we said it could even be a Zynga-specific discovery server, found by the Zynga app on the device. - The B-API for VM provisioning: Not sure whether the arrow makes sense. Is the cloud platform invoking something in a VM? Isn't the user/app deciding to use an edge service once discovered and starts to invoke the VM provisioning workflow? Should arrow B go from app on device to Open Cloud platform in the cloudlet? - Similar for the C-API: Is triggered by the app on the device I suspect (at least in cloudlet context, not in ETSI MEC context). --> Correct, the slide simplifies the flow quite a lot. And I think it would be good to have a simple slide everybody can understand. I changed the arrows to bring it closer to the true process, however, more complexity might not make the slide better. We have the next slide with the details. O.K.? Further: Would it be useful to each have a slide for different stakeholder groups: Real-world touch points with Cloudlets or workflow interfaces to Cloudlets or operational aspects regarding cloudlets? .... As these slides could be used for outreach to different groups. To give some examples: - For network operator: - May deploy cloud software at edge locations (incl. base VMs) - May operate a discovery service - May offer PaaS components to developers e.g. to create launch VMs - Etc. For application developer: - May create and run their own cloudlet discovery service - May create applications designed to execute on both tier 1 cloud and at the edge - May create apps that can offload execution to the edge on user demand - Will use cloudlet platform API(s) to create launch VM and overlay VM - Will make overlay VM available either together with app or on a particular web location - May develop mechanism for the app to decide when to request a handoff For an enterprise: - May deploy edge servers at locations across the enterprise premises/campus - Etc. --> Good point. I have tried to cover some of that on slide 14, where I address the advantages for the various players. I suggest to add individual slides per target group once we have the discussions with various stakeholders. Br Guenter From: oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Friday, August 21, 2015 7:38 AM To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions... Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. Many thanks Rolf. Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing ? (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. ? (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. ? (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, ? please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. ? Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) --> DONE 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. Ideas: address verticals. 'Crowdsourcing' the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. --> Draft deck to be distributed 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. --> Has that happened? 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. 7. All: 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug - end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal --> Proposal from Satya under way... _____________________________________________ From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 Importance: High Hi there, Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well - We went through all agenda points - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. Any questions, please let me know. Best regards Guenter << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. Rolf. ______________________________ Dear all, As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas ? Outreach Program Progress ? Technical Program Progress ? MEC Requirement Progress and go through the attached action item list. Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. Kind regards Rolf. Email from last meeting << Attachments: Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) >> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150902/058a483c/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview - FINAL.pptx Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.presentationml.presentation Size: 1589796 bytes Desc: Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview - FINAL.pptx Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150902/058a483c/attachment-0001.bin From valerie.j.young at intel.com Wed Sep 2 15:44:34 2015 From: valerie.j.young at intel.com (Young, Valerie J) Date: Wed, 2 Sep 2015 19:44:34 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week In-Reply-To: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88329A2AE@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88329A2AE@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <96EFD7465592EA4A9CCEAAB849F4DFF6A448B56A@ORSMSX105.amr.corp.intel.com> Hi All, I have been called away and have to fly tomorrow. I am in process of pulling together a poc submission to ETSI will send out by the end of the week. Thanks, Best regards, valerie From: oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Tuesday, September 01, 2015 1:54 PM To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, * please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and * please have a look at the action items below from our last call and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. Kind regards Rolf. Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing * (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. * (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. * (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 21. August 2015 16:38 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions... Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. Many thanks Rolf. << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx >> Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing * (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. * (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. * (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, * please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. * Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) --> DONE 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. Ideas: address verticals. 'Crowdsourcing' the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. --> Draft deck to be distributed 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. --> Has that happened? 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. 7. All: 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug - end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal --> Proposal from Satya under way... _____________________________________________ From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 Importance: High Hi there, Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well - We went through all agenda points - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. Any questions, please let me know. Best regards Guenter << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. Rolf. ______________________________ Dear all, As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas * Outreach Program Progress * Technical Program Progress * MEC Requirement Progress and go through the attached action item list. Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. Kind regards Rolf. Email from last meeting << Attachments: Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) >> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150902/4ff4f83f/attachment-0001.html From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Wed Sep 2 15:50:31 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Wed, 2 Sep 2015 19:50:31 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88329BE1B@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 1. September 2015 22:54 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and - please have a look at the action items below from our last call and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. Kind regards Rolf. Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 21. August 2015 16:38 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions... Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. Many thanks Rolf. << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx >> Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. - Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) --> DONE 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. Ideas: address verticals. 'Crowdsourcing' the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. --> Draft deck to be distributed 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. --> Has that happened? 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. 7. All: 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug - end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal --> Proposal from Satya under way... _____________________________________________ From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 Importance: High Hi there, Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well - We went through all agenda points - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. Any questions, please let me know. Best regards Guenter << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. Rolf. ______________________________ Dear all, As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas - Outreach Program Progress - Technical Program Progress - MEC Requirement Progress and go through the attached action item list. Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. Kind regards Rolf. Email from last meeting << Attachments: Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) >> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150902/02782e29/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: 2015-09-03 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.presentationml.presentation Size: 505406 bytes Desc: 2015-09-03 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150902/02782e29/attachment-0001.bin From ashlee at onosfw.com Thu Sep 3 09:43:54 2015 From: ashlee at onosfw.com (Ashlee Young) Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2015 06:43:54 -0700 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week In-Reply-To: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88329BE1B@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88329BE1B@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <0ED343E2-37A0-42F7-B945-7E1FE198325A@onosfw.com> Hi Rolf, I don?t know when our call is this morning or what the call-in details are. So I?m not sure if it overlaps with any other commitments I have. Here?s some input: 1) I?ve circulated an email thread to spark further discussion and collaboration around the Qemu re-write 2) I?ve not heard back from Alan Clark and will call him today as follow-up. 3) I have not received or heard anything about the Intel SDK, so I have no further opinion on it. 4) I abandoned the Wordpress CMS approach to the website and went with a simplistic Twitter Bootstrap on NGINX web server approach. It?s up and running at openedgecomputing.org . 5) We have openedgecomputing.org/.net/.com with all pointers going to the .org site. 6) I?ve created a discourse-based discussion forum for us at forum.openedgecomputing.org 7) We have a github repository at https://github.com/openedgecomputing and can begin adding our existing repos as git submodules to maintain the version control history 8) I?ve located the gerrit source code to use as a gate for code review. Same goes for Jenkins and for Jira. This is the basis for a CI environment. Rather than host on our lab resources, I think these should be deployed via AWS EC2. That?s what I?ve done for the website and the forum. The costs for each micro instance VM is roughly $20/mo, but these costs are waived for the first 12 months as long as we don?t exceed the usage model for a micro instance. 9) Currently working on logo and content format for the website, along with qemu code analysis. I will let Prakash report on where the Vedams guys are. They hit a slight snag, but have started making progress. Best, Ash > On Sep 2, 2015, at 12:50 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group wrote: > > Dear all, > Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow > - Presentation with call agenda and > - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure > > I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > _____________________________________________ > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Dienstag, 1. September 2015 22:54 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week > > > Dear all, > Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, > please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and > please have a look at the action items below from our last call and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call > Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. > Kind regards > Rolf. > > Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 > > (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback > (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) > (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit > (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) > (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. > (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) > We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing > (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. > (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. > (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? > (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC > (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. > (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) > (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project > > > _____________________________________________ > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Freitag, 21. August 2015 16:38 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com > Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week > > > Dear all, > Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions? > > Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. > > Many thanks > Rolf. > > << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx >> > > Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 > > (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback > (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) > (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit > (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) > (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. > (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) > We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing > (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. > (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. > (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? > (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC > (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. > (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) > (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project > > > > _____________________________________________ > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com > Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week > > > Dear all, > Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow > - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions > - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) > > I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 > To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu ); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com ; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu ); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com > Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week > > > Dear all, > Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, > please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. > Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call > As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> > Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) > Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) > ? DONE > Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. > Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. > Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. > Ideas: address verticals. ?Crowdsourcing? the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. > ? Draft deck to be distributed > Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them ? need endorsements. > Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. > Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. > Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. > ? Has that happened? > Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. > ? Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? > Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. > ? Update durich call on 20 August 2015? > Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. > ? The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. > All: > 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug ? end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. > 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is > familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. > ? DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! > All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. > Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? > Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal > ? Proposal from Satya under way? > > _____________________________________________ > From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group > Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu ); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com ; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu ); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com > Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 > Importance: High > > > Hi there, > > Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. > - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well > - We went through all agenda points > - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. > - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. > - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. > Any questions, please let me know. > > Best regards > > Guenter > << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> > > > -----Original Appointment----- > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu ); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com ; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu );michael.a.kozuch at intel.com > Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call > When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. > Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below > > > Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. > Rolf. > > ______________________________ > > Dear all, > As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas > Outreach Program Progress > Technical Program Progress > MEC Requirement Progress > and go through the attached action item list. > > Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). > > Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > Email from last meeting > > > << Attachments: > > Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) > Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) > RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) > >> > > <2015-09-03 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx>_______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150903/08ccad10/attachment-0001.html From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Thu Sep 3 09:51:29 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2015 13:51:29 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week In-Reply-To: <0ED343E2-37A0-42F7-B945-7E1FE198325A@onosfw.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88329BE1B@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <0ED343E2-37A0-42F7-B945-7E1FE198325A@onosfw.com> Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88329C66B@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Ashlee, Thanks for your update. My apologies, I thought you are on the oe-sync list which I used to send the invite. I have just re-send the invite. I will also send the material I distributed yesterday? Please do not hesitate to dial-in via phone and Webex as usual. You find the details in the invite. Kind regards Rolf. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Donnerstag, 3. September 2015 15:44 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Hi Rolf, I don?t know when our call is this morning or what the call-in details are. So I?m not sure if it overlaps with any other commitments I have. Here?s some input: 1) I?ve circulated an email thread to spark further discussion and collaboration around the Qemu re-write 2) I?ve not heard back from Alan Clark and will call him today as follow-up. 3) I have not received or heard anything about the Intel SDK, so I have no further opinion on it. 4) I abandoned the Wordpress CMS approach to the website and went with a simplistic Twitter Bootstrap on NGINX web server approach. It?s up and running at openedgecomputing.org. 5) We have openedgecomputing.org/.net/.com with all pointers going to the .org site. 6) I?ve created a discourse-based discussion forum for us at forum.openedgecomputing.org 7) We have a github repository at https://github.com/openedgecomputing and can begin adding our existing repos as git submodules to maintain the version control history 8) I?ve located the gerrit source code to use as a gate for code review. Same goes for Jenkins and for Jira. This is the basis for a CI environment. Rather than host on our lab resources, I think these should be deployed via AWS EC2. That?s what I?ve done for the website and the forum. The costs for each micro instance VM is roughly $20/mo, but these costs are waived for the first 12 months as long as we don?t exceed the usage model for a micro instance. 9) Currently working on logo and content format for the website, along with qemu code analysis. I will let Prakash report on where the Vedams guys are. They hit a slight snag, but have started making progress. Best, Ash On Sep 2, 2015, at 12:50 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 1. September 2015 22:54 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, ? please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and ? please have a look at the action items below from our last call and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. Kind regards Rolf. Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing ? (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. ? (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. ? (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 21. August 2015 16:38 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions? Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. Many thanks Rolf. << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx >> Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing ? (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. ? (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. ? (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, ? please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. ? Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) --> DONE 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. Ideas: address verticals. ?Crowdsourcing? the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. --> Draft deck to be distributed 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. --> Has that happened? 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. 7. All: 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug ? end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal --> Proposal from Satya under way? _____________________________________________ From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 Importance: High Hi there, Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well - We went through all agenda points - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. Any questions, please let me know. Best regards Guenter << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu);michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. Rolf. ______________________________ Dear all, As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas ? Outreach Program Progress ? Technical Program Progress ? MEC Requirement Progress and go through the attached action item list. Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. Kind regards Rolf. Email from last meeting << Attachments: Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) >> <2015-09-03 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx>_______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150903/5b556fa6/attachment-0001.html From ashlee at onosfw.com Thu Sep 3 10:12:45 2015 From: ashlee at onosfw.com (Ashlee Young) Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2015 07:12:45 -0700 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week In-Reply-To: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88329C66B@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88329BE1B@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <0ED343E2-37A0-42F7-B945-7E1FE198325A@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88329C66B@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: I have the slides, but no invite with call details. Assuming everyone likes the site layout in the slides, I think I have a great starting point and can probably have all of it in place this weekend. I just need to be added to the calendar invite and need the Intel SDK info. Sent from my iPhone > On Sep 3, 2015, at 6:51 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group wrote: > > Ashlee, > Thanks for your update. My apologies, I thought you are on the oe-sync list which I used to send the invite. I have just re-send the invite. I will also send the material I distributed yesterday? > > Please do not hesitate to dial-in via phone and Webex as usual. You find the details in the invite. > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] > Sent: Donnerstag, 3. September 2015 15:44 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week > > Hi Rolf, > > I don?t know when our call is this morning or what the call-in details are. So I?m not sure if it overlaps with any other commitments I have. > > Here?s some input: > > 1) I?ve circulated an email thread to spark further discussion and collaboration around the Qemu re-write > 2) I?ve not heard back from Alan Clark and will call him today as follow-up. > 3) I have not received or heard anything about the Intel SDK, so I have no further opinion on it. > 4) I abandoned the Wordpress CMS approach to the website and went with a simplistic Twitter Bootstrap on NGINX web server approach. It?s up and running at openedgecomputing.org. > 5) We have openedgecomputing.org/.net/.com with all pointers going to the .org site. > 6) I?ve created a discourse-based discussion forum for us at forum.openedgecomputing.org > 7) We have a github repository at https://github.com/openedgecomputing and can begin adding our existing repos as git submodules to maintain the version control history > 8) I?ve located the gerrit source code to use as a gate for code review. Same goes for Jenkins and for Jira. This is the basis for a CI environment. Rather than host on our lab resources, I think these should be deployed via AWS EC2. That?s what I?ve done for the website and the forum. The costs for each micro instance VM is roughly $20/mo, but these costs are waived for the first 12 months as long as we don?t exceed the usage model for a micro instance. > 9) Currently working on logo and content format for the website, along with qemu code analysis. > > I will let Prakash report on where the Vedams guys are. They hit a slight snag, but have started making progress. > > Best, > > Ash > > > On Sep 2, 2015, at 12:50 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group wrote: > > Dear all, > Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow > - Presentation with call agenda and > - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure > > I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > _____________________________________________ > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Dienstag, 1. September 2015 22:54 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week > > > Dear all, > Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, > ? please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and > ? please have a look at the action items below from our last call and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call > Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. > Kind regards > Rolf. > > Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 > > 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback > 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) > 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit > 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) > 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. > 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) > 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing > ? (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. > ? (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. > ? (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? > 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC > 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. > 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) > 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project > > > _____________________________________________ > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Freitag, 21. August 2015 16:38 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com > Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week > > > Dear all, > Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions? > > Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. > > Many thanks > Rolf. > > << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx >> > > Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 > > 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback > 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) > 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit > 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) > 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. > 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) > 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing > ? (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. > ? (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. > ? (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? > 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC > 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. > 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) > 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project > > > > _____________________________________________ > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com > Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week > > > Dear all, > Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow > - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions > - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) > > I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 > To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com > Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week > > > Dear all, > Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, > ? please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. > ? Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call > As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> > Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) > 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) > ? DONE > 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. > Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. > Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. > Ideas: address verticals. ?Crowdsourcing? the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. > ? Draft deck to be distributed > 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them ? need endorsements. > Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. > Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. > Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. > ? Has that happened? > 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. > ? Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? > 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. > ? Update durich call on 20 August 2015? > 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. > ? The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. > 7. All: > 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug ? end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. > 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is > familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. > ? DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! > 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. > Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? > Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal > ? Proposal from Satya under way? > > _____________________________________________ > From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group > Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com > Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 > Importance: High > > > Hi there, > > Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. > - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well > - We went through all agenda points > - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. > - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. > - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. > Any questions, please let me know. > > Best regards > > Guenter > << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> > > > -----Original Appointment----- > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu);michael.a.kozuch at intel.com > Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call > When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. > Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below > > > Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. > Rolf. > > ______________________________ > > Dear all, > As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas > ? Outreach Program Progress > ? Technical Program Progress > ? MEC Requirement Progress > and go through the attached action item list. > > Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). > > Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > Email from last meeting > > > << Attachments: > > Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) > Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) > RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) > >> > > <2015-09-03 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx>_______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150903/a64906b0/attachment-0001.html From satya at cs.cmu.edu Thu Sep 3 10:12:53 2015 From: satya at cs.cmu.edu (Mahadev Satyanarayanan) Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2015 10:12:53 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] Here is the Webex info for call currently in progress (SAME EVERY WEEK) In-Reply-To: <0ED343E2-37A0-42F7-B945-7E1FE198325A@onosfw.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88329BE1B@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <0ED343E2-37A0-42F7-B945-7E1FE198325A@onosfw.com> Message-ID: <201509031012.53522.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Meeting link: https://cmusatyalab.webex.com/cmusatyalab/j.php?MTID=m5f27b882a9334cf94cb69bba327b1a92 Meeting number: 737 865 028 Meeting password: oesync Audio connection: +1-855-797-9485 US Toll free +1-415-655-0002 US Toll Global call-in numbers Show toll-free dialing restrictions Access code: 737 865 028 URL for documents: https://owncloud.cmusatyalab.org/owncloud/public.php?service=files&t=c9f5bf1c36948d874459dea2fa50e57a On Thursday 03 September 2015 09:43:54 Ashlee Young wrote: > Hi Rolf, > > I don?t know when our call is this morning or what the call-in details are. So I?m not sure if it overlaps with any other commitments I have. > > Here?s some input: > > 1) I?ve circulated an email thread to spark further discussion and collaboration around the Qemu re-write > 2) I?ve not heard back from Alan Clark and will call him today as follow-up. > 3) I have not received or heard anything about the Intel SDK, so I have no further opinion on it. > 4) I abandoned the Wordpress CMS approach to the website and went with a simplistic Twitter Bootstrap on NGINX web server approach. It?s up and running at openedgecomputing.org . > 5) We have openedgecomputing.org/.net/.com with all pointers going to the .org site. > 6) I?ve created a discourse-based discussion forum for us at forum.openedgecomputing.org > 7) We have a github repository at https://github.com/openedgecomputing and can begin adding our existing repos as git submodules to maintain the version control history > 8) I?ve located the gerrit source code to use as a gate for code review. Same goes for Jenkins and for Jira. This is the basis for a CI environment. Rather than host on our lab resources, I think these should be deployed via AWS EC2. That?s what I?ve done for the website and the forum. The costs for each micro instance VM is roughly $20/mo, but these costs are waived for the first 12 months as long as we don?t exceed the usage model for a micro instance. > 9) Currently working on logo and content format for the website, along with qemu code analysis. > > I will let Prakash report on where the Vedams guys are. They hit a slight snag, but have started making progress. > > Best, > > Ash > > > > On Sep 2, 2015, at 12:50 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group wrote: > > > > Dear all, > > Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow > > - Presentation with call agenda and > > - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure > > > > I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. > > > > Kind regards > > Rolf. > > > > > > _____________________________________________ > > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > > Sent: Dienstag, 1. September 2015 22:54 > > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > > Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week > > > > > > Dear all, > > Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, > > please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and > > please have a look at the action items below from our last call and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call > > Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. > > Kind regards > > Rolf. > > > > Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 > > > > (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback > > (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) > > (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit > > (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) > > (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. > > (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) > > We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing > > (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. > > (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. > > (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? > > (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC > > (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. > > (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) > > (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project > > > > > > _____________________________________________ > > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > > Sent: Freitag, 21. August 2015 16:38 > > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > > Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com > > Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week > > > > > > Dear all, > > Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions? > > > > Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. > > > > Many thanks > > Rolf. > > > > << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx >> > > > > Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 > > > > (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback > > (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) > > (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit > > (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) > > (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. > > (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) > > We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing > > (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. > > (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. > > (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? > > (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC > > (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. > > (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) > > (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project > > > > > > > > _____________________________________________ > > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > > Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 > > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > > Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com > > Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week > > > > > > Dear all, > > Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow > > - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions > > - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) > > > > I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. > > > > Kind regards > > Rolf. > > > > > > << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ > > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > > Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 > > To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu ); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com ; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu ); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com > > Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week > > > > > > Dear all, > > Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, > > please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. > > Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call > > As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. > > > > Kind regards > > Rolf. > > > > << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> > > Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) > > Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) > > ? DONE > > Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. > > Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. > > Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. > > Ideas: address verticals. ?Crowdsourcing? the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. > > ? Draft deck to be distributed > > Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them ? need endorsements. > > Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. > > Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. > > Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. > > ? Has that happened? > > Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. > > ? Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? > > Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. > > ? Update durich call on 20 August 2015? > > Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. > > ? The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. > > All: > > 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug ? end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. > > 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is > > familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. > > ? DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! > > All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. > > Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? > > Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal > > ? Proposal from Satya under way? > > > > _____________________________________________ > > From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group > > Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 > > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu ); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com ; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu ); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com > > Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 > > Importance: High > > > > > > Hi there, > > > > Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. > > - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well > > - We went through all agenda points > > - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. > > - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. > > - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. > > Any questions, please let me know. > > > > Best regards > > > > Guenter > > << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> > > > > > > -----Original Appointment----- > > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > > Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 > > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu ); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com ; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu );michael.a.kozuch at intel.com > > Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call > > When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. > > Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below > > > > > > Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. > > Rolf. > > > > ______________________________ > > > > Dear all, > > As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas > > Outreach Program Progress > > Technical Program Progress > > MEC Requirement Progress > > and go through the attached action item list. > > > > Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). > > > > Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. > > > > Kind regards > > Rolf. > > > > > > Email from last meeting > > > > > > << Attachments: > > > > Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) > > Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) > > RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) > > >> > > > > <2015-09-03 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx>_______________________________________________ > > oe-sync mailing list > > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150903/ed99927e/attachment-0001.html From chasek at cs.cmu.edu Thu Sep 3 11:05:11 2015 From: chasek at cs.cmu.edu (Chase Klingensmith) Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2015 11:05:11 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] corrected webex details Message-ID: Hello everyone, Here's the correct meeting number and access code for the bi-weekly sync. I've tested all the links and they should all work as well. Thanks, Chase Open Edge ?Weekly ?S ync ?Every 2 weeks on Thursdays Host: Mahadev Satyanarayanan ? Meeting number: 737 865 028 Meeting password: ?oesync? Audio connection: ? +1-415-655-0002 US Global Call-In Numbers ?Access code: 737 865 028 Meeting Link? -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150903/7f42c91b/attachment.html From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Thu Sep 3 12:22:52 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2015 16:22:52 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC88329C86C@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Thanks for the constructive call today. Here are the action items. I uploaded the meeting slides as well as the Open Edge Computing Overview slides to our file repository (link again below). @Ashlee, are you receiving these mails by now? Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from Progress call 3rd September 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 14 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack summit AND OPNFV Summit 2. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) 3. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 17 Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 4. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 4 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 5. (Kiriong, until 5 Sept) Meeting with Vedams on Monday, 7 September, Meeting on OpenStack roadmap on Monday, 14 September (with Yun-Chao) 6. (Kiryong, until 5 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student 7. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) License discussion for Open Edge Initiative --> at Technical Program Call on 14 Sept? 8. (Yun-Chao, until 17 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting 9. (Yun-Chao and Rolf, 14 Sept) put together a proposal for membership structure + web-site + new partner outreach 10. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 11. Info: Cloudlet Class applicatin demonstration session on 1 December 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All welcome! Link to repository: https://owncloud.cmusatyalab.org/owncloud/public.php?service=files&t=c9f5bf1c36948d874459dea2fa50e57a _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 2. September 2015 21:50 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-09-03 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 1. September 2015 22:54 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and - please have a look at the action items below from our last call and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. Kind regards Rolf. Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 21. August 2015 16:38 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions... Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. Many thanks Rolf. << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx >> Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. - Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) --> DONE 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. Ideas: address verticals. 'Crowdsourcing' the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. --> Draft deck to be distributed 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. --> Has that happened? 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. 7. All: 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug - end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal --> Proposal from Satya under way... _____________________________________________ From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 Importance: High Hi there, Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well - We went through all agenda points - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. Any questions, please let me know. Best regards Guenter << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. Rolf. ______________________________ Dear all, As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas - Outreach Program Progress - Technical Program Progress - MEC Requirement Progress and go through the attached action item list. Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. Kind regards Rolf. Email from last meeting << Attachments: Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) >> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150903/bcfd884e/attachment-0001.html From satya at cs.cmu.edu Thu Sep 3 19:52:48 2015 From: satya at cs.cmu.edu (Mahadev Satyanarayanan) Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2015 19:52:48 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] Progress on cloudlet-based class projects Message-ID: <201509031952.48343.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Hi everyone, As I mentioned at the meeting today, our class projects are off to a good start. There are 25 students in class. More than half of them (7 x 2-person groups) are doing cloudlet-based projects. You can see the project descriptions at this web site: http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~15-821/project-descriptions.html (Projects #1 to #8 are the cloudlet-based ones) The mentors for each project are members of my research team and Babu Pillai from Intel. They came up with the high-level sketches of the projects to make sure that they would highlight the value of cloudlets. The students will refine these high-level project sketches under the guidance of their mentors, and then implement them. Demo and poster day is December 1, 2015 from 3-6pm. You are all welcome to attend this open event and to see what the students have built! The cloudlet hardware from Intel arrived yesterday. My team is working hard to get everything installed into the racks, tested, etc. Kiryong has been successful in getting his software installed on one of the machines. Lot of hard work ahead in the next few days in getting everything set up. This was just-in-time delivery for this class. Even a few days later would have made things very difficult for the class. Even now it is touch and go! Kiryong and Jan are working very hard to get everything up and running. Many thanks to Valerie Young and JoZell Johnson of Intel for getting the machines delivered to us in time. And, of course, to Intel for this substantial donation of resources (including Babu Pillai's time as a mentor for two projects). Thanks also to Google for donation of Glass devices that will be used in some of these projects. We are off to a good start! -- Satya From ashlee at onosfw.com Thu Sep 3 20:26:26 2015 From: ashlee at onosfw.com (Ashlee Young) Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2015 17:26:26 -0700 Subject: [oe-sync] Progress on cloudlet-based class projects In-Reply-To: <201509031952.48343.satya@cs.cmu.edu> References: <201509031952.48343.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Message-ID: <758A6F0E-2810-4F19-8F53-872458CC40B9@onosfw.com> That is a fantastic report!!! Sent from my iPhone > On Sep 3, 2015, at 4:52 PM, Mahadev Satyanarayanan wrote: > > Hi everyone, > As I mentioned at the meeting today, our class projects are off to a good start. > There are 25 students in class. More than half of them (7 x 2-person groups) are doing > cloudlet-based projects. You can see the project descriptions at this > web site: http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~15-821/project-descriptions.html > (Projects #1 to #8 are the cloudlet-based ones) > > The mentors for each project are members of my research team and Babu Pillai > from Intel. They came up with the high-level sketches of the projects to make sure > that they would highlight the value of cloudlets. The students > will refine these high-level project sketches under the guidance of their > mentors, and then implement them. Demo and poster day is December 1, 2015 > from 3-6pm. You are all welcome to attend this open event and to see > what the students have built! > > The cloudlet hardware from Intel arrived yesterday. My team is working > hard to get everything installed into the racks, tested, etc. Kiryong has > been successful in getting his software installed on one of the machines. > Lot of hard work ahead in the next few days in getting everything set up. > This was just-in-time delivery for this class. Even a few days later would > have made things very difficult for the class. Even now it is touch and go! > Kiryong and Jan are working very hard to get everything up and running. > > Many thanks to Valerie Young and JoZell Johnson of Intel for getting the > machines delivered to us in time. And, of course, to Intel for this substantial > donation of resources (including Babu Pillai's time as a mentor for two projects). > Thanks also to Google for donation of Glass devices that will be used > in some of these projects. > > We are off to a good start! > > -- Satya > > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync From satya at cs.cmu.edu Fri Sep 4 06:37:19 2015 From: satya at cs.cmu.edu (Mahadev Satyanarayanan) Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2015 06:37:19 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] Progress on cloudlet-based class projects In-Reply-To: <201509031952.48343.satya@cs.cmu.edu> References: <201509031952.48343.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Message-ID: <201509040637.19368.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Slight correction: there are actually 8 x 2-student groups (not 7). I forgot that two groups are doing independent implementations of Project #4 (Interactive Google Street View hyper-lapse simulation). So that is a total of 16 students guided by 6 mentors who are exploring creative uses of cloudlets. Should be fun! -- Satya On Thursday 03 September 2015 19:52:48 Mahadev Satyanarayanan wrote: > Hi everyone, > As I mentioned at the meeting today, our class projects are off to a good start. > There are 25 students in class. More than half of them (7 x 2-person groups) are doing > cloudlet-based projects. You can see the project descriptions at this > web site: http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~15-821/project-descriptions.html > (Projects #1 to #8 are the cloudlet-based ones) > > The mentors for each project are members of my research team and Babu Pillai > from Intel. They came up with the high-level sketches of the projects to make sure > that they would highlight the value of cloudlets. The students > will refine these high-level project sketches under the guidance of their > mentors, and then implement them. Demo and poster day is December 1, 2015 > from 3-6pm. You are all welcome to attend this open event and to see > what the students have built! > > The cloudlet hardware from Intel arrived yesterday. My team is working > hard to get everything installed into the racks, tested, etc. Kiryong has > been successful in getting his software installed on one of the machines. > Lot of hard work ahead in the next few days in getting everything set up. > This was just-in-time delivery for this class. Even a few days later would > have made things very difficult for the class. Even now it is touch and go! > Kiryong and Jan are working very hard to get everything up and running. > > Many thanks to Valerie Young and JoZell Johnson of Intel for getting the > machines delivered to us in time. And, of course, to Intel for this substantial > donation of resources (including Babu Pillai's time as a mentor for two projects). > Thanks also to Google for donation of Glass devices that will be used > in some of these projects. > > We are off to a good start! > > -- Satya > > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync > From padmanabhan.s.pillai at intel.com Fri Sep 4 09:22:27 2015 From: padmanabhan.s.pillai at intel.com (Padmanabhan Pillai) Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2015 09:22:27 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] Latency + need for edge computing Message-ID: <55E99B13.4050703@intel.com> In the last sync meeting, the question of latency and showing the need for edge computing (as opposed to cloud computing) came up. The CMU team has done extensive work already on demonstrating the need for edge computing, and have a published paper on this topic (see attached). The work looks at a few interactive, compute-intensive applications, and compares mobile-only execution, offload to several different Amazon datacenters, and offload to a local edge server. In short, the paper shows that generally, edge computing comes out ahead in these interactive application scenarios. I hope you can use this work as supporting evidence when encountering naysayers questioning the need for edge computing. The paper was presented at the International Conference on Cloud Engineering (IC2E), 2013. Regards, - Babu -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: ic2e2013.pdf Type: application/pdf Size: 2705195 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150904/d3dc1639/attachment-0001.pdf From Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com Mon Sep 7 06:40:09 2015 From: Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com (Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group) Date: Mon, 7 Sep 2015 10:40:09 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Progress on cloudlet-based class projects In-Reply-To: <201509040637.19368.satya@cs.cmu.edu> References: <201509031952.48343.satya@cs.cmu.edu> <201509040637.19368.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Message-ID: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A661FF6@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Very important step I believe and a great opportunity to explore innovative applications benefiting from edge computing. Guenter -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Mahadev Satyanarayanan Sent: 04 September 2015 11:37 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Progress on cloudlet-based class projects Slight correction: there are actually 8 x 2-student groups (not 7). I forgot that two groups are doing independent implementations of Project #4 (Interactive Google Street View hyper-lapse simulation). So that is a total of 16 students guided by 6 mentors who are exploring creative uses of cloudlets. Should be fun! -- Satya On Thursday 03 September 2015 19:52:48 Mahadev Satyanarayanan wrote: > Hi everyone, > As I mentioned at the meeting today, our class projects are off to a good start. > There are 25 students in class. More than half of them (7 x 2-person groups) are doing > cloudlet-based projects. You can see the project descriptions at this > web site: http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~15-821/project-descriptions.html > (Projects #1 to #8 are the cloudlet-based ones) > > The mentors for each project are members of my research team and Babu > Pillai from Intel. They came up with the high-level sketches of the projects to make sure > that they would highlight the value of cloudlets. The students > will refine these high-level project sketches under the guidance of their > mentors, and then implement them. Demo and poster day is December 1, 2015 > from 3-6pm. You are all welcome to attend this open event and to see > what the students have built! > > The cloudlet hardware from Intel arrived yesterday. My team is working > hard to get everything installed into the racks, tested, etc. Kiryong has > been successful in getting his software installed on one of the machines. > Lot of hard work ahead in the next few days in getting everything set up. > This was just-in-time delivery for this class. Even a few days later > would have made things very difficult for the class. Even now it is touch and go! > Kiryong and Jan are working very hard to get everything up and running. > > Many thanks to Valerie Young and JoZell Johnson of Intel for getting > the machines delivered to us in time. And, of course, to Intel for > this substantial donation of resources (including Babu Pillai's time as a mentor for two projects). > Thanks also to Google for donation of Glass devices that will be used > in some of these projects. > > We are off to a good start! > > -- Satya > > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync > _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync From Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com Mon Sep 7 07:03:02 2015 From: Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com (Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group) Date: Mon, 7 Sep 2015 11:03:02 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Latency + need for edge computing In-Reply-To: <55E99B13.4050703@intel.com> References: <55E99B13.4050703@intel.com> Message-ID: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A66209E@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> The ITU report from 2014 (on tactile Internet) is also a good reference that firmly suggests the need for edge computing with response times down to 1 ms for certain application areas. Though mostly written by a German research community, I think many statements underpin the need for very low latency. https://www.itu.int/dms_pub/itu-t/oth/23/01/T23010000230001PDFE.pdf Guenter -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Padmanabhan Pillai Sent: 04 September 2015 14:22 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: [oe-sync] Latency + need for edge computing In the last sync meeting, the question of latency and showing the need for edge computing (as opposed to cloud computing) came up. The CMU team has done extensive work already on demonstrating the need for edge computing, and have a published paper on this topic (see attached). The work looks at a few interactive, compute-intensive applications, and compares mobile-only execution, offload to several different Amazon datacenters, and offload to a local edge server. In short, the paper shows that generally, edge computing comes out ahead in these interactive application scenarios. I hope you can use this work as supporting evidence when encountering naysayers questioning the need for edge computing. The paper was presented at the International Conference on Cloud Engineering (IC2E), 2013. Regards, - Babu From valerie.j.young at intel.com Mon Sep 7 11:25:03 2015 From: valerie.j.young at intel.com (Young, Valerie J) Date: Mon, 7 Sep 2015 15:25:03 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Progress on cloudlet-based class projects In-Reply-To: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A661FF6@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <201509031952.48343.satya@cs.cmu.edu> <201509040637.19368.satya@cs.cmu.edu> <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A661FF6@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <96EFD7465592EA4A9CCEAAB849F4DFF6A4490A6D@ORSMSX105.amr.corp.intel.com> This is great! Intel is happy to be able to supply the servers! Let us know if help is needed in set up. Best regards, valerie -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Monday, September 07, 2015 3:40 AM To: Mahadev Satyanarayanan ; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Progress on cloudlet-based class projects Very important step I believe and a great opportunity to explore innovative applications benefiting from edge computing. Guenter -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Mahadev Satyanarayanan Sent: 04 September 2015 11:37 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Progress on cloudlet-based class projects Slight correction: there are actually 8 x 2-student groups (not 7). I forgot that two groups are doing independent implementations of Project #4 (Interactive Google Street View hyper-lapse simulation). So that is a total of 16 students guided by 6 mentors who are exploring creative uses of cloudlets. Should be fun! -- Satya On Thursday 03 September 2015 19:52:48 Mahadev Satyanarayanan wrote: > Hi everyone, > As I mentioned at the meeting today, our class projects are off to a good start. > There are 25 students in class. More than half of them (7 x 2-person groups) are doing > cloudlet-based projects. You can see the project descriptions at this > web site: http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~15-821/project-descriptions.html > (Projects #1 to #8 are the cloudlet-based ones) > > The mentors for each project are members of my research team and Babu > Pillai from Intel. They came up with the high-level sketches of the projects to make sure > that they would highlight the value of cloudlets. The students > will refine these high-level project sketches under the guidance of their > mentors, and then implement them. Demo and poster day is December 1, 2015 > from 3-6pm. You are all welcome to attend this open event and to see > what the students have built! > > The cloudlet hardware from Intel arrived yesterday. My team is working > hard to get everything installed into the racks, tested, etc. Kiryong has > been successful in getting his software installed on one of the machines. > Lot of hard work ahead in the next few days in getting everything set up. > This was just-in-time delivery for this class. Even a few days later > would have made things very difficult for the class. Even now it is touch and go! > Kiryong and Jan are working very hard to get everything up and running. > > Many thanks to Valerie Young and JoZell Johnson of Intel for getting > the machines delivered to us in time. And, of course, to Intel for > this substantial donation of resources (including Babu Pillai's time as a mentor for two projects). > Thanks also to Google for donation of Glass devices that will be used > in some of these projects. > > We are off to a good start! > > -- Satya > > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync > _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Mon Sep 14 16:15:41 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Mon, 14 Sep 2015 20:15:41 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies - right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a "test and compliancy lab" Any comments or suggestions? In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). --> Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. What do you think? Kind regards Rolf. [http://www.vodafone.com/content/dam/global_email_signature/sigroundel.png] Rolf Schuster Head of Partner Innovation Centres Architecture & Research Vodafone Group Services GmbH Mobile: +491722360098 Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff vodafone.com This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150914/5521c374/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: 20150904_165221.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 3727667 bytes Desc: 20150904_165221.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150914/5521c374/attachment-0001.jpg From ashlee at onosfw.com Mon Sep 14 16:36:53 2015 From: ashlee at onosfw.com (Ashlee Young) Date: Mon, 14 Sep 2015 13:36:53 -0700 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: Hi Rolf, I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. Thanks, Ash Sent from my iPhone > On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group wrote: > > Dear all, > Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. > - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. > - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) > - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. > - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up > - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? > > Any comments or suggestions? > > In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). > ? Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. > > What do you think? > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > > > Rolf Schuster > Head of Partner Innovation Centres > Architecture & Research > Vodafone Group Services GmbH > Mobile: +491722360098 > Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com > > Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, > D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 > Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff > vodafone.com > > This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. > > > > > <20150904_165221.jpg> > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150914/44fb872d/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: 20150904_165221.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 22410 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150914/44fb872d/attachment-0001.jpg From ashlee at onosfw.com Mon Sep 14 18:02:27 2015 From: ashlee at onosfw.com (Ashlee Young) Date: Mon, 14 Sep 2015 15:02:27 -0700 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. Thanks, Ash > On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young wrote: > > Hi Rolf, > > I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) > > I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > Sent from my iPhone > > On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > >> Dear all, >> Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. >> - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. >> - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) >> - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. >> - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up >> - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? >> >> Any comments or suggestions? >> >> In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). >> ? Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. >> >> What do you think? >> >> Kind regards >> Rolf. >> >> >> <20150904_165221.jpg> >> >> Rolf Schuster >> Head of Partner InnovationCentres >> Architecture & Research >> Vodafone Group Services GmbH >> Mobile: +491722360098 >> Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com >> >> Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, >> D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 >> Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff >> vodafone.com? >> >> This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. >> >> >> >> >> <20150904_165221.jpg> >> _______________________________________________ >> oe-sync mailing list >> oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu >> https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150914/62178ff5/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: logo-6.png Type: image/png Size: 36506 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150914/62178ff5/attachment-0002.png -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: logo-icon-5.png Type: image/png Size: 8811 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150914/62178ff5/attachment-0003.png From Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com Tue Sep 15 03:28:37 2015 From: Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com (Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group) Date: Tue, 15 Sep 2015 07:28:37 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: Questions: 1) Where (in which aspects) does the initiative overlap with OPNFV? 2) To which extent would the initiative create similar items as OPNFV, e.g. test infrastructure for developers, sandbox, CI environment with tool chain? Indeed, that's expensive. 3) Do we want to create or nurture a 'complete system' or only selected building blocks (to stay deliberately with Satya's analogy of the narrow waist in IP)? Regarding the relationship to NFV: I can imagine to run both untrusted apps + trusted VNFs at the same cloud infrastructure at the edge, use the same cloud mgr software and a single orchestration SW.... Thus: relationships to what the NFV community is doing. My point: where there is potential overlap, possibly better to extend at the existing source (as we try to do with OpenStack) though with the risk of dependencies. 4) How would the 'coordination of implementation' happen in practice? Whose work would the initiative coordinate? How feasible is this? 5) What I think we need: - A place where open source code as we have it can be created. - A mechanism to interact with industry sectors that have use cases in the Tactile Internet. - An engine that coordinates or drives or lobbies for development in any upstream projects. - A mechanism to conduct PoCs with participants from those industry sectors. - A mechanism to provide some well scoped tested code platform to PoCs, either by offering platform download or access to labs for PoCs and 3rd parties from different tactile Internet sectors. Guenter "Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group" wrote: Dear all, Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? Any comments or suggestions? In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). --> Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. What do you think? Kind regards Rolf. [cid:2338055312557040903FEF07356C1EA6 at internal.vodafone.com] [http://www.vodafone.com/content/dam/global_email_signature/sigroundel.png] Rolf Schuster Head of Partner Innovation Centres Architecture & Research Vodafone Group Services GmbH Mobile: +491722360098 Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff vodafone.com This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/889865fc/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: 20150904_165221.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 3727667 bytes Desc: 20150904_165221.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/889865fc/attachment-0001.jpg From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Tue Sep 15 10:42:02 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Tue, 15 Sep 2015 14:42:02 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> Ashlee, Many thanks for working on the logo matter ? in spite of your overload! If we had the logo we might be able to move forward with the web-site quickly. Very much appreciated. Below please find my comments and suggestions. Please view this as constructive support rather than criticism. I am sure there will be lots of different views! Kind regards Rolf. Here is my feedback - I like the principle design idea around centring on the O E and C - If we want to improve I would change some of the following matters --> Colour selection is a bit hard: perhaps a bit less black, more light and friendly colours, see OPNFV & opendaylight below --> We could play with the colours also in the word Open Edge Computing and give Edge the same colour as the E bars in the logo. --> The design elements have rather hard corners and shapes. Some more round edges may be more in vogue --> Shorten the middle bar of the E on the right a bit further to avoid the one-ways street association - The question is how that would work / look like with the name ?Open Edge Computing? - Perhaps reduce the size of the logo in relation to the Letters OpenEdgeComputing Attached, please find a first attempt to put the logo on slides. [Home] [https://www.opendaylight.org/sites/all/themes/odl2/logo.png] From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 00:02 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. Thanks, Ash [cid:image008.png at 01D0EFD2.C6D2D1A0] [cid:image003.png at 01D0EFCF.5B26E9D0] On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Hi Rolf, I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. Thanks, Ash Sent from my iPhone On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: Dear all, Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? Any comments or suggestions? In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). --> Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. What do you think? Kind regards Rolf. <20150904_165221.jpg> [http://www.vodafone.com/content/dam/global_email_signature/sigroundel.png] Rolf Schuster Head of Partner InnovationCentres Architecture & Research Vodafone Group Services GmbH Mobile: +491722360098 Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff vodafone.com This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. <20150904_165221.jpg> _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/edd5dd3b/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image003.png Type: image/png Size: 8811 bytes Desc: image003.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/edd5dd3b/attachment-0004.png -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image005.png Type: image/png Size: 13789 bytes Desc: image005.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/edd5dd3b/attachment-0005.png -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image007.png Type: image/png Size: 7116 bytes Desc: image007.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/edd5dd3b/attachment-0006.png -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image008.png Type: image/png Size: 23502 bytes Desc: image008.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/edd5dd3b/attachment-0007.png -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: Open Edge Computing - Logo test.pptx Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.presentationml.presentation Size: 516602 bytes Desc: Open Edge Computing - Logo test.pptx Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/edd5dd3b/attachment-0001.bin From ashlee at onosfw.com Tue Sep 15 11:27:35 2015 From: ashlee at onosfw.com (Ashlee Young) Date: Tue, 15 Sep 2015 08:27:35 -0700 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: Great suggestions! I?ll get a couple more variations out shortly. > On Sep 15, 2015, at 7:42 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group wrote: > > Ashlee, > Many thanks for working on the logo matter ? in spite of your overload! If we had the logo we might be able to move forward with the web-site quickly. Very much appreciated. > > Below please find my comments and suggestions. Please view this as constructive support rather than criticism. I am sure there will be lots of different views! > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > Here is my feedback > - I like the principle design idea around centring on the O E and C > - If we want to improve I would change some of the following matters > ? Colour selection is a bit hard: perhaps a bit less black, more light and friendly colours, see OPNFV & opendaylight below > ? We could play with the colours also in the word Open Edge Computing and give Edge the same colour as the E bars in the logo. > ? The design elements have rather hard corners and shapes. Some more round edges may be more in vogue > ? Shorten the middle bar of the E on the right a bit further to avoid the one-ways street association > - The question is how that would work / look like with the name ?Open Edge Computing? > - Perhaps reduce the size of the logo in relation to the Letters OpenEdgeComputing > > Attached, please find a first attempt to put the logo on slides. > > > > > > > > From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] > Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 00:02 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > > > > > > > On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: > > Hi Rolf, > > I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) > > I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > Sent from my iPhone > > On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > > Dear all, > Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. > - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. > - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) > - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. > - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up > - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? > > Any comments or suggestions? > > In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). > ? Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. > > What do you think? > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > <20150904_165221.jpg> > > > Rolf Schuster > Head of Partner InnovationCentres > Architecture & Research > Vodafone Group Services GmbH > Mobile: +491722360098 > Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com > > Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, > D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 > Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff > vodafone.com? > > This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. > > > > > <20150904_165221.jpg> > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync > > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/41de5782/attachment-0001.html From ashlee at onosfw.com Tue Sep 15 12:37:54 2015 From: ashlee at onosfw.com (Ashlee Young) Date: Tue, 15 Sep 2015 09:37:54 -0700 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <86706B47-D635-4BD4-8A16-EA3F14F67CA3@onosfw.com> Just to get a sense for direction, can you take a look at the following comps and let me know choice of font combinations and/or colors. I?m also including a color palette for you to perhaps choose some other choices for colors. The palette is supposed to be indicative of popular 2015 color families. Thanks, Ash > On Sep 15, 2015, at 8:27 AM, Ashlee Young wrote: > > Great suggestions! I?ll get a couple more variations out shortly. > > >> On Sep 15, 2015, at 7:42 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: >> >> Ashlee, >> Many thanks for working on the logo matter ? in spite of your overload! If we had the logo we might be able to move forward with the web-site quickly. Very much appreciated. >> >> Below please find my comments and suggestions. Please view this as constructive support rather than criticism. I am sure there will be lots of different views! >> >> Kind regards >> Rolf. >> >> >> Here is my feedback >> - I like the principle design idea around centring on the O E and C >> - If we want to improve I would change some of the following matters >> ? Colour selection is a bit hard: perhaps a bit less black, more light and friendly colours, see OPNFV & opendaylight below >> ? We could play with the colours also in the word Open Edge Computing and give Edge the same colour as the E bars in the logo. >> ? The design elements have rather hard corners and shapes. Some more round edges may be more in vogue >> ? Shorten the middle bar of the E on the right a bit further to avoid the one-ways street association >> - The question is how that would work / look like with the name ?Open Edge Computing? >> - Perhaps reduce the size of the logo in relation to the Letters OpenEdgeComputing >> >> Attached, please find a first attempt to put the logo on slides. >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] >> Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 00:02 >> To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group >> Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu >> Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program >> >> Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. >> >> Thanks, >> >> Ash >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: >> >> Hi Rolf, >> >> I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) >> >> I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. >> >> Thanks, >> >> Ash >> >> Sent from my iPhone >> >> On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: >> >> Dear all, >> Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. >> - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. >> - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) >> - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. >> - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up >> - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? >> >> Any comments or suggestions? >> >> In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). >> ? Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. >> >> What do you think? >> >> Kind regards >> Rolf. >> >> >> <20150904_165221.jpg> >> >> >> Rolf Schuster >> Head of Partner InnovationCentres >> Architecture & Research >> Vodafone Group Services GmbH >> Mobile: +491722360098 >> Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com >> >> Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, >> D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 >> Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff >> vodafone.com? >> >> This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. >> >> >> >> >> <20150904_165221.jpg> >> _______________________________________________ >> oe-sync mailing list >> oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu >> https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync >> >> > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/2a97ee29/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: pallette.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 60839 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/2a97ee29/attachment-0001.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: logo-comps.png Type: image/png Size: 236980 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/2a97ee29/attachment-0001.png From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Tue Sep 15 16:08:11 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Tue, 15 Sep 2015 20:08:11 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FCD31@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and - please have a look at the action items below from our last call and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from progress call 3rd September 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 14 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack summit AND OPNFV Summit 2. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) 3. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 17 Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 4. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 4 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 5. (Kiriong, until 5 Sept) Meeting with Vedams on Monday, 7 September, Meeting on OpenStack roadmap on Monday, 14 September (with Yun-Chao) 6. (Kiryong, until 5 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student 7. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) License discussion for Open Edge Initiative --> at Technical Program Call on 14 Sept? 8. (Yun-Chao, until 17 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting 9. (Yun-Chao and Rolf, 14 Sept) put together a proposal for membership structure + web-site + new partner outreach 10. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 11. Info: Cloudlet Class applicatin demonstration session on 1 December 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All welcome! Link to repository: https://owncloud.cmusatyalab.org/owncloud/public.php?service=files&t=c9f5bf1c36948d874459dea2fa50e57a -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/d61a612e/attachment.html From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Tue Sep 15 16:41:52 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Tue, 15 Sep 2015 20:41:52 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: <86706B47-D635-4BD4-8A16-EA3F14F67CA3@onosfw.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <86706B47-D635-4BD4-8A16-EA3F14F67CA3@onosfw.com> Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FCD97@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> I like the colours from OPNFV and Opendaylight (see below). On your selection that could be close to Dragon Bay DE5725 and Orange Jewel DEA115. Style-wise I like the third option the most, perhaps with a different colour (the red would be quite close to VF though ;-)): [cid:image006.jpg at 01D0F007.B6507D70] Are there any other views? Regards Rolf. [Home] [https://www.opendaylight.org/sites/all/themes/odl2/logo.png] From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 18:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Just to get a sense for direction, can you take a look at the following comps and let me know choice of font combinations and/or colors. I?m also including a color palette for you to perhaps choose some other choices for colors. The palette is supposed to be indicative of popular 2015 color families. Thanks, Ash [cid:image003.jpg at 01D0F006.E09251E0] [cid:image007.png at 01D0F007.B6507D70] On Sep 15, 2015, at 8:27 AM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Great suggestions! I?ll get a couple more variations out shortly. On Sep 15, 2015, at 7:42 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: Ashlee, Many thanks for working on the logo matter ? in spite of your overload! If we had the logo we might be able to move forward with the web-site quickly. Very much appreciated. Below please find my comments and suggestions. Please view this as constructive support rather than criticism. I am sure there will be lots of different views! Kind regards Rolf. Here is my feedback - I like the principle design idea around centring on the O E and C - If we want to improve I would change some of the following matters --> Colour selection is a bit hard: perhaps a bit less black, more light and friendly colours, see OPNFV & opendaylight below --> We could play with the colours also in the word Open Edge Computing and give Edge the same colour as the E bars in the logo. --> The design elements have rather hard corners and shapes. Some more round edges may be more in vogue --> Shorten the middle bar of the E on the right a bit further to avoid the one-ways street association - The question is how that would work / look like with the name ?Open Edge Computing? - Perhaps reduce the size of the logo in relation to the Letters OpenEdgeComputing Attached, please find a first attempt to put the logo on slides. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 00:02 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. Thanks, Ash On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Hi Rolf, I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. Thanks, Ash Sent from my iPhone On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: Dear all, Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? Any comments or suggestions? In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). --> Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. What do you think? Kind regards Rolf. <20150904_165221.jpg> [http://www.vodafone.com/content/dam/global_email_signature/sigroundel.png] Rolf Schuster Head of Partner InnovationCentres Architecture & Research Vodafone Group Services GmbH Mobile: +491722360098 Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff vodafone.com This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. <20150904_165221.jpg> _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/f9bfbdcd/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image001.png Type: image/png Size: 13789 bytes Desc: image001.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/f9bfbdcd/attachment-0003.png -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image002.png Type: image/png Size: 7116 bytes Desc: image002.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/f9bfbdcd/attachment-0004.png -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image003.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 60839 bytes Desc: image003.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/f9bfbdcd/attachment-0002.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image006.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 3973 bytes Desc: image006.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/f9bfbdcd/attachment-0003.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image007.png Type: image/png Size: 175786 bytes Desc: image007.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/f9bfbdcd/attachment-0005.png From ashlee at onosfw.com Tue Sep 15 17:54:11 2015 From: ashlee at onosfw.com (Ashlee Young) Date: Tue, 15 Sep 2015 14:54:11 -0700 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FCD97@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <86706B47-D635-4BD4-8A16-EA3F14F67CA3@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FCD97@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <266F58D3-04CA-42E4-AB85-0981E6B1F37B@onosfw.com> Okay, in hopes of narrowing this further? :) > On Sep 15, 2015, at 1:41 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group wrote: > > I like the colours from OPNFV and Opendaylight (see below). On your selection that could be close to Dragon Bay DE5725 and Orange Jewel DEA115. > > Style-wise I like the third option the most, perhaps with a different colour (the red would be quite close to VF though ;-)): > > > Are there any other views? > > Regards > Rolf. > > > > > > > > > > From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] > Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 18:38 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Just to get a sense for direction, can you take a look at the following comps and let me know choice of font combinations and/or colors. I?m also including a color palette for you to perhaps choose some other choices for colors. The palette is supposed to be indicative of popular 2015 color families. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > > > > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 8:27 AM, Ashlee Young > wrote: > > Great suggestions! I?ll get a couple more variations out shortly. > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 7:42 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > > Ashlee, > Many thanks for working on the logo matter ? in spite of your overload! If we had the logo we might be able to move forward with the web-site quickly. Very much appreciated. > > Below please find my comments and suggestions. Please view this as constructive support rather than criticism. I am sure there will be lots of different views! > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > Here is my feedback > - I like the principle design idea around centring on the O E and C > - If we want to improve I would change some of the following matters > ? Colour selection is a bit hard: perhaps a bit less black, more light and friendly colours, see OPNFV & opendaylight below > ? We could play with the colours also in the word Open Edge Computing and give Edge the same colour as the E bars in the logo. > ? The design elements have rather hard corners and shapes. Some more round edges may be more in vogue > ? Shorten the middle bar of the E on the right a bit further to avoid the one-ways street association > - The question is how that would work / look like with the name ?Open Edge Computing? > - Perhaps reduce the size of the logo in relation to the Letters OpenEdgeComputing > > Attached, please find a first attempt to put the logo on slides. > > > > > > > > From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] > Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 00:02 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > > > > > > > On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: > > Hi Rolf, > > I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) > > I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > Sent from my iPhone > > On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > > Dear all, > Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. > - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. > - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) > - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. > - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up > - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? > > Any comments or suggestions? > > In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). > ? Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. > > What do you think? > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > <20150904_165221.jpg> > > > Rolf Schuster > Head of Partner InnovationCentres > Architecture & Research > Vodafone Group Services GmbH > Mobile: +491722360098 > Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com > > Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, > D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 > Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff > vodafone.com? > > This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. > > > > > <20150904_165221.jpg> > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync > > > > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/93422cbf/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: logo-comps-2.png Type: image/png Size: 242790 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/93422cbf/attachment-0001.png From Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com Tue Sep 15 18:00:32 2015 From: Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com (Prakash Ramchandran) Date: Tue, 15 Sep 2015 22:00:32 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: <266F58D3-04CA-42E4-AB85-0981E6B1F37B@onosfw.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <86706B47-D635-4BD4-8A16-EA3F14F67CA3@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FCD97@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <266F58D3-04CA-42E4-AB85-0981E6B1F37B@onosfw.com> Message-ID: <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB089688E5@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> My vote is for #2 of 6 as in logo as well monogram they will appear as distinct... Thanks Prakash Prakash Ramchandran [logo_huawei] R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Ashlee Young Sent: Tuesday, September 15, 2015 2:54 PM To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Okay, in hopes of narrowing this further? :) [cid:FA6F897F-8A5F-4E26-A5BC-262856AC9642 at hsd1.ca.comcast.net.] On Sep 15, 2015, at 1:41 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: I like the colours from OPNFV and Opendaylight (see below). On your selection that could be close to Dragon Bay DE5725 and Orange Jewel DEA115. Style-wise I like the third option the most, perhaps with a different colour (the red would be quite close to VF though ;-)): Are there any other views? Regards Rolf. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 18:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Just to get a sense for direction, can you take a look at the following comps and let me know choice of font combinations and/or colors. I?m also including a color palette for you to perhaps choose some other choices for colors. The palette is supposed to be indicative of popular 2015 color families. Thanks, Ash On Sep 15, 2015, at 8:27 AM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Great suggestions! I?ll get a couple more variations out shortly. On Sep 15, 2015, at 7:42 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: Ashlee, Many thanks for working on the logo matter ? in spite of your overload! If we had the logo we might be able to move forward with the web-site quickly. Very much appreciated. Below please find my comments and suggestions. Please view this as constructive support rather than criticism. I am sure there will be lots of different views! Kind regards Rolf. Here is my feedback - I like the principle design idea around centring on the O E and C - If we want to improve I would change some of the following matters --> Colour selection is a bit hard: perhaps a bit less black, more light and friendly colours, see OPNFV & opendaylight below --> We could play with the colours also in the word Open Edge Computing and give Edge the same colour as the E bars in the logo. --> The design elements have rather hard corners and shapes. Some more round edges may be more in vogue --> Shorten the middle bar of the E on the right a bit further to avoid the one-ways street association - The question is how that would work / look like with the name ?Open Edge Computing? - Perhaps reduce the size of the logo in relation to the Letters OpenEdgeComputing Attached, please find a first attempt to put the logo on slides. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 00:02 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. Thanks, Ash On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Hi Rolf, I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. Thanks, Ash Sent from my iPhone On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: Dear all, Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? Any comments or suggestions? In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). --> Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. What do you think? Kind regards Rolf. <20150904_165221.jpg> [http://www.vodafone.com/content/dam/global_email_signature/sigroundel.png] Rolf Schuster Head of Partner InnovationCentres Architecture & Research Vodafone Group Services GmbH Mobile: +491722360098 Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff vodafone.com This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. <20150904_165221.jpg> _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/63fc66b7/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image001.png Type: image/png Size: 3243 bytes Desc: image001.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/63fc66b7/attachment-0003.png -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image004.png Type: image/png Size: 206700 bytes Desc: image004.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/63fc66b7/attachment-0004.png -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image005.png Type: image/png Size: 983 bytes Desc: image005.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/63fc66b7/attachment-0005.png From ashlee at onosfw.com Tue Sep 15 18:02:41 2015 From: ashlee at onosfw.com (Ashlee Young) Date: Tue, 15 Sep 2015 15:02:41 -0700 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB089688E5@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <86706B47-D635-4BD4-8A16-EA3F14F67CA3@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FCD97@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <266F58D3-04CA-42E4-AB85-0981E6B1F37B@onosfw.com> <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB089688E5@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> Message-ID: <4CEF2DDD-9AFD-4638-B059-2A7FBE264444@onosfw.com> From the top or the bottom? > On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:00 PM, Prakash Ramchandran wrote: > > My vote is for #2 of 6 as in logo as well monogram they will appear as distinct... Thanks Prakash > > Prakash Ramchandran > R&D USA > FutureWei Technologies, Inc > Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com > Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 > Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 > 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA > > > > > From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu ] On Behalf Of Ashlee Young > Sent: Tuesday, September 15, 2015 2:54 PM > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Okay, in hopes of narrowing this further? :) > > > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 1:41 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > > I like the colours from OPNFV and Opendaylight (see below). On your selection that could be close to Dragon Bay DE5725 and Orange Jewel DEA115. > > Style-wise I like the third option the most, perhaps with a different colour (the red would be quite close to VF though ;-)): > > > Are there any other views? > > Regards > Rolf. > > > > > > > > > > From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] > Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 18:38 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Just to get a sense for direction, can you take a look at the following comps and let me know choice of font combinations and/or colors. I?m also including a color palette for you to perhaps choose some other choices for colors. The palette is supposed to be indicative of popular 2015 color families. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > > > > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 8:27 AM, Ashlee Young > wrote: > > Great suggestions! I?ll get a couple more variations out shortly. > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 7:42 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > > Ashlee, > Many thanks for working on the logo matter ? in spite of your overload! If we had the logo we might be able to move forward with the web-site quickly. Very much appreciated. > > Below please find my comments and suggestions. Please view this as constructive support rather than criticism. I am sure there will be lots of different views! > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > Here is my feedback > - I like the principle design idea around centring on the O E and C > - If we want to improve I would change some of the following matters > ? Colour selection is a bit hard: perhaps a bit less black, more light and friendly colours, see OPNFV & opendaylight below > ? We could play with the colours also in the word Open Edge Computing and give Edge the same colour as the E bars in the logo. > ? The design elements have rather hard corners and shapes. Some more round edges may be more in vogue > ? Shorten the middle bar of the E on the right a bit further to avoid the one-ways street association > - The question is how that would work / look like with the name ?Open Edge Computing? > - Perhaps reduce the size of the logo in relation to the Letters OpenEdgeComputing > > Attached, please find a first attempt to put the logo on slides. > > > > > > > > From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] > Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 00:02 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > > > > > > > On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: > > Hi Rolf, > > I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) > > I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > Sent from my iPhone > > On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > > Dear all, > Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. > - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. > - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) > - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. > - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up > - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? > > Any comments or suggestions? > > In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). > ? Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. > > What do you think? > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > <20150904_165221.jpg> > > > Rolf Schuster > Head of Partner InnovationCentres > Architecture & Research > Vodafone Group Services GmbH > Mobile: +491722360098 > Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com > > Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, > D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 > Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff > vodafone.com? > > This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. > > > > > <20150904_165221.jpg> > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync > > > > > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/297a520f/attachment-0001.html From ashlee at onosfw.com Tue Sep 15 18:19:23 2015 From: ashlee at onosfw.com (Ashlee Young) Date: Tue, 15 Sep 2015 15:19:23 -0700 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: <4CEF2DDD-9AFD-4638-B059-2A7FBE264444@onosfw.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <86706B47-D635-4BD4-8A16-EA3F14F67CA3@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FCD97@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <266F58D3-04CA-42E4-AB85-0981E6B1F37B@onosfw.com> <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB089688E5@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> <4CEF2DDD-9AFD-4638-B059-2A7FBE264444@onosfw.com> Message-ID: <887E8BDA-5CCA-4F16-917D-7CD6B5A8386A@onosfw.com> Here are some with the green and the orange. Ash > On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:02 PM, Ashlee Young wrote: > > From the top or the bottom? > > >> On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:00 PM, Prakash Ramchandran > wrote: >> >> My vote is for #2 of 6 as in logo as well monogram they will appear as distinct... Thanks Prakash >> >> Prakash Ramchandran >> R&D USA >> FutureWei Technologies, Inc >> Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com >> Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 >> Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 >> 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA >> >> >> >> >> From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu ] On Behalf Of Ashlee Young >> Sent: Tuesday, September 15, 2015 2:54 PM >> To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group >> Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu >> Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program >> >> Okay, in hopes of narrowing this further? :) >> >> >> >> >> On Sep 15, 2015, at 1:41 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: >> >> I like the colours from OPNFV and Opendaylight (see below). On your selection that could be close to Dragon Bay DE5725 and Orange Jewel DEA115. >> >> Style-wise I like the third option the most, perhaps with a different colour (the red would be quite close to VF though ;-)): >> >> >> Are there any other views? >> >> Regards >> Rolf. >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] >> Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 18:38 >> To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group >> Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu >> Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program >> >> Just to get a sense for direction, can you take a look at the following comps and let me know choice of font combinations and/or colors. I?m also including a color palette for you to perhaps choose some other choices for colors. The palette is supposed to be indicative of popular 2015 color families. >> >> Thanks, >> >> Ash >> >> >> >> >> >> >> On Sep 15, 2015, at 8:27 AM, Ashlee Young > wrote: >> >> Great suggestions! I?ll get a couple more variations out shortly. >> >> >> On Sep 15, 2015, at 7:42 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: >> >> Ashlee, >> Many thanks for working on the logo matter ? in spite of your overload! If we had the logo we might be able to move forward with the web-site quickly. Very much appreciated. >> >> Below please find my comments and suggestions. Please view this as constructive support rather than criticism. I am sure there will be lots of different views! >> >> Kind regards >> Rolf. >> >> >> Here is my feedback >> - I like the principle design idea around centring on the O E and C >> - If we want to improve I would change some of the following matters >> ? Colour selection is a bit hard: perhaps a bit less black, more light and friendly colours, see OPNFV & opendaylight below >> ? We could play with the colours also in the word Open Edge Computing and give Edge the same colour as the E bars in the logo. >> ? The design elements have rather hard corners and shapes. Some more round edges may be more in vogue >> ? Shorten the middle bar of the E on the right a bit further to avoid the one-ways street association >> - The question is how that would work / look like with the name ?Open Edge Computing? >> - Perhaps reduce the size of the logo in relation to the Letters OpenEdgeComputing >> >> Attached, please find a first attempt to put the logo on slides. >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] >> Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 00:02 >> To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group >> Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu >> Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program >> >> Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. >> >> Thanks, >> >> Ash >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: >> >> Hi Rolf, >> >> I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) >> >> I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. >> >> Thanks, >> >> Ash >> >> Sent from my iPhone >> >> On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: >> >> Dear all, >> Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. >> - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. >> - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) >> - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. >> - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up >> - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? >> >> Any comments or suggestions? >> >> In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). >> ? Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. >> >> What do you think? >> >> Kind regards >> Rolf. >> >> >> <20150904_165221.jpg> >> >> >> Rolf Schuster >> Head of Partner InnovationCentres >> Architecture & Research >> Vodafone Group Services GmbH >> Mobile: +491722360098 >> Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com >> >> Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, >> D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 >> Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff >> vodafone.com? >> >> This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. >> >> >> >> >> <20150904_165221.jpg> >> _______________________________________________ >> oe-sync mailing list >> oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu >> https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync >> >> >> >> >> > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/ef740636/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: logo-comps-3.png Type: image/png Size: 244208 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/ef740636/attachment-0001.png From Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com Tue Sep 15 20:06:27 2015 From: Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com (Prakash Ramchandran) Date: Wed, 16 Sep 2015 00:06:27 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: <887E8BDA-5CCA-4F16-917D-7CD6B5A8386A@onosfw.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <86706B47-D635-4BD4-8A16-EA3F14F67CA3@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FCD97@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <266F58D3-04CA-42E4-AB85-0981E6B1F37B@onosfw.com> <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB089688E5@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> <4CEF2DDD-9AFD-4638-B059-2A7FBE264444@onosfw.com> <887E8BDA-5CCA-4F16-917D-7CD6B5A8386A@onosfw.com> Message-ID: <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB08968A32@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> Any light color will cause visibility issue on paper as well web sites so would still stick to #2 or #4 from top...Thanks Prakash Prakash Ramchandran [logo_huawei] R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Tuesday, September 15, 2015 3:19 PM To: Prakash Ramchandran Cc: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Here are some with the green and the orange. Ash [cid:image002.png at 01D0EFD8.DB85D560] On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:02 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: From the top or the bottom? On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:00 PM, Prakash Ramchandran > wrote: My vote is for #2 of 6 as in logo as well monogram they will appear as distinct... Thanks Prakash Prakash Ramchandran R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Ashlee Young Sent: Tuesday, September 15, 2015 2:54 PM To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Okay, in hopes of narrowing this further? :) On Sep 15, 2015, at 1:41 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: I like the colours from OPNFV and Opendaylight (see below). On your selection that could be close to Dragon Bay DE5725 and Orange Jewel DEA115. Style-wise I like the third option the most, perhaps with a different colour (the red would be quite close to VF though ;-)): Are there any other views? Regards Rolf. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 18:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Just to get a sense for direction, can you take a look at the following comps and let me know choice of font combinations and/or colors. I?m also including a color palette for you to perhaps choose some other choices for colors. The palette is supposed to be indicative of popular 2015 color families. Thanks, Ash On Sep 15, 2015, at 8:27 AM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Great suggestions! I?ll get a couple more variations out shortly. On Sep 15, 2015, at 7:42 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: Ashlee, Many thanks for working on the logo matter ? in spite of your overload! If we had the logo we might be able to move forward with the web-site quickly. Very much appreciated. Below please find my comments and suggestions. Please view this as constructive support rather than criticism. I am sure there will be lots of different views! Kind regards Rolf. Here is my feedback - I like the principle design idea around centring on the O E and C - If we want to improve I would change some of the following matters --> Colour selection is a bit hard: perhaps a bit less black, more light and friendly colours, see OPNFV & opendaylight below --> We could play with the colours also in the word Open Edge Computing and give Edge the same colour as the E bars in the logo. --> The design elements have rather hard corners and shapes. Some more round edges may be more in vogue --> Shorten the middle bar of the E on the right a bit further to avoid the one-ways street association - The question is how that would work / look like with the name ?Open Edge Computing? - Perhaps reduce the size of the logo in relation to the Letters OpenEdgeComputing Attached, please find a first attempt to put the logo on slides. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 00:02 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. Thanks, Ash On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Hi Rolf, I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. Thanks, Ash Sent from my iPhone On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: Dear all, Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? Any comments or suggestions? In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). --> Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. What do you think? Kind regards Rolf. <20150904_165221.jpg> Rolf Schuster Head of Partner InnovationCentres Architecture & Research Vodafone Group Services GmbH Mobile: +491722360098 Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff vodafone.com This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. <20150904_165221.jpg> _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150916/9b683bdd/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image001.png Type: image/png Size: 3243 bytes Desc: image001.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150916/9b683bdd/attachment-0002.png -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image002.png Type: image/png Size: 220628 bytes Desc: image002.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150916/9b683bdd/attachment-0003.png From ashlee at onosfw.com Wed Sep 16 00:40:22 2015 From: ashlee at onosfw.com (Ashlee Young) Date: Tue, 15 Sep 2015 21:40:22 -0700 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB08968A32@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <86706B47-D635-4BD4-8A16-EA3F14F67CA3@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FCD97@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <266F58D3-04CA-42E4-AB85-0981E6B1F37B@onosfw.com> <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB089688E5@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> <4CEF2DDD-9AFD-4638-B059-2A7FBE264444@onosfw.com> <887E8BDA-5CCA-4F16-917D-7CD6B5A8386A@onosfw.com> <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB08968A32@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> Message-ID: <07170B37-191A-43A3-90F1-90FF3679279E@onosfw.com> Agreed. 2 and 4 are my favorites, as well? leaning towards #4. > On Sep 15, 2015, at 5:06 PM, Prakash Ramchandran wrote: > > Any light color will cause visibility issue on paper as well web sites so would still stick to #2 or #4 from top...Thanks Prakash > > Prakash Ramchandran > R&D USA > FutureWei Technologies, Inc > Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com > Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 > Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 > 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA > > > > > From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] > Sent: Tuesday, September 15, 2015 3:19 PM > To: Prakash Ramchandran > Cc: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Here are some with the green and the orange. > > Ash > > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:02 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: > > From the top or the bottom? > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:00 PM, Prakash Ramchandran > wrote: > > My vote is for #2 of 6 as in logo as well monogram they will appear as distinct... Thanks Prakash > > Prakash Ramchandran > R&D USA > FutureWei Technologies, Inc > Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com > Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 > Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 > 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA > > > > > From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu ] On Behalf Of Ashlee Young > Sent: Tuesday, September 15, 2015 2:54 PM > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Okay, in hopes of narrowing this further? :) > > > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 1:41 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > > I like the colours from OPNFV and Opendaylight (see below). On your selection that could be close to Dragon Bay DE5725 and Orange Jewel DEA115. > > Style-wise I like the third option the most, perhaps with a different colour (the red would be quite close to VF though ;-)): > > > Are there any other views? > > Regards > Rolf. > > > > > > > > > > From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] > Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 18:38 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Just to get a sense for direction, can you take a look at the following comps and let me know choice of font combinations and/or colors. I?m also including a color palette for you to perhaps choose some other choices for colors. The palette is supposed to be indicative of popular 2015 color families. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > > > > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 8:27 AM, Ashlee Young > wrote: > > Great suggestions! I?ll get a couple more variations out shortly. > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 7:42 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > > Ashlee, > Many thanks for working on the logo matter ? in spite of your overload! If we had the logo we might be able to move forward with the web-site quickly. Very much appreciated. > > Below please find my comments and suggestions. Please view this as constructive support rather than criticism. I am sure there will be lots of different views! > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > Here is my feedback > - I like the principle design idea around centring on the O E and C > - If we want to improve I would change some of the following matters > ? Colour selection is a bit hard: perhaps a bit less black, more light and friendly colours, see OPNFV & opendaylight below > ? We could play with the colours also in the word Open Edge Computing and give Edge the same colour as the E bars in the logo. > ? The design elements have rather hard corners and shapes. Some more round edges may be more in vogue > ? Shorten the middle bar of the E on the right a bit further to avoid the one-ways street association > - The question is how that would work / look like with the name ?Open Edge Computing? > - Perhaps reduce the size of the logo in relation to the Letters OpenEdgeComputing > > Attached, please find a first attempt to put the logo on slides. > > > > > > > > From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] > Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 00:02 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > > > > > > > On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: > > Hi Rolf, > > I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) > > I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > Sent from my iPhone > > On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > > Dear all, > Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. > - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. > - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) > - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. > - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up > - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? > > Any comments or suggestions? > > In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). > ? Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. > > What do you think? > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > <20150904_165221.jpg> > > > Rolf Schuster > Head of Partner InnovationCentres > Architecture & Research > Vodafone Group Services GmbH > Mobile: +491722360098 > Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com > > Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, > D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 > Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff > vodafone.com? > > This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. > > > > > <20150904_165221.jpg> > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync > > > > > > > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150915/62e83240/attachment-0001.html From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Wed Sep 16 17:34:48 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Wed, 16 Sep 2015 21:34:48 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: <887E8BDA-5CCA-4F16-917D-7CD6B5A8386A@onosfw.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <86706B47-D635-4BD4-8A16-EA3F14F67CA3@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FCD97@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <266F58D3-04CA-42E4-AB85-0981E6B1F37B@onosfw.com> <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB089688E5@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> <4CEF2DDD-9AFD-4638-B059-2A7FBE264444@onosfw.com> <887E8BDA-5CCA-4F16-917D-7CD6B5A8386A@onosfw.com> Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FD26A@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> O.K. #4 could be fine (from the top). To me a bit of read might be more friendly. What about #3 with the darker red from #5. That red seems to print in black and white o.k.. Attached in the presentation deck with #4 and #3. We could also have two versions and ask the rest of the team for their views tomorrow? What do you think? Regards Rolf. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Mittwoch, 16. September 2015 00:19 To: Prakash Ramchandran Cc: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Here are some with the green and the orange. Ash [cid:image001.png at 01D0F0D8.45E1EA20] On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:02 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: From the top or the bottom? On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:00 PM, Prakash Ramchandran > wrote: My vote is for #2 of 6 as in logo as well monogram they will appear as distinct... Thanks Prakash Prakash Ramchandran R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Ashlee Young Sent: Tuesday, September 15, 2015 2:54 PM To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Okay, in hopes of narrowing this further? :) On Sep 15, 2015, at 1:41 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: I like the colours from OPNFV and Opendaylight (see below). On your selection that could be close to Dragon Bay DE5725 and Orange Jewel DEA115. Style-wise I like the third option the most, perhaps with a different colour (the red would be quite close to VF though ;-)): Are there any other views? Regards Rolf. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 18:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Just to get a sense for direction, can you take a look at the following comps and let me know choice of font combinations and/or colors. I?m also including a color palette for you to perhaps choose some other choices for colors. The palette is supposed to be indicative of popular 2015 color families. Thanks, Ash On Sep 15, 2015, at 8:27 AM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Great suggestions! I?ll get a couple more variations out shortly. On Sep 15, 2015, at 7:42 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: Ashlee, Many thanks for working on the logo matter ? in spite of your overload! If we had the logo we might be able to move forward with the web-site quickly. Very much appreciated. Below please find my comments and suggestions. Please view this as constructive support rather than criticism. I am sure there will be lots of different views! Kind regards Rolf. Here is my feedback - I like the principle design idea around centring on the O E and C - If we want to improve I would change some of the following matters --> Colour selection is a bit hard: perhaps a bit less black, more light and friendly colours, see OPNFV & opendaylight below --> We could play with the colours also in the word Open Edge Computing and give Edge the same colour as the E bars in the logo. --> The design elements have rather hard corners and shapes. Some more round edges may be more in vogue --> Shorten the middle bar of the E on the right a bit further to avoid the one-ways street association - The question is how that would work / look like with the name ?Open Edge Computing? - Perhaps reduce the size of the logo in relation to the Letters OpenEdgeComputing Attached, please find a first attempt to put the logo on slides. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 00:02 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. Thanks, Ash On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Hi Rolf, I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. Thanks, Ash Sent from my iPhone On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: Dear all, Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? Any comments or suggestions? In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). --> Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. What do you think? Kind regards Rolf. <20150904_165221.jpg> Rolf Schuster Head of Partner InnovationCentres Architecture & Research Vodafone Group Services GmbH Mobile: +491722360098 Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff vodafone.com This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. <20150904_165221.jpg> _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150916/ac2beff7/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image001.png Type: image/png Size: 214992 bytes Desc: image001.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150916/ac2beff7/attachment-0001.png From ashlee at onosfw.com Wed Sep 16 18:47:55 2015 From: ashlee at onosfw.com (Ashlee Young) Date: Wed, 16 Sep 2015 15:47:55 -0700 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FD26A@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <86706B47-D635-4BD4-8A16-EA3F14F67CA3@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FCD97@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <266F58D3-04CA-42E4-AB85-0981E6B1F37B@onosfw.com> <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB089688E5@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> <4CEF2DDD-9AFD-4638-B059-2A7FBE264444@onosfw.com> <887E8BDA-5CCA-4F16-917D-7CD6B5A8386A@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FD26A@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: Normally, I would do a reversed logo (aka white) to go onto darker backgrounds. So, I wouldn?t be overly concerned about that scenario. You?ve gotta keep in mind that going to print is going to be the biggest issue. I typically try to keep things to 2 colors vs. 4. And while I have indicated web-safe colors, we?ll ultimately want a pantone-based color for any collateral that we have produced or business cards. Here?s quick guide to consider: http://www.dcfb.com/Pages/2-color-designs.html Ash > On Sep 16, 2015, at 2:34 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group wrote: > > O.K. #4 could be fine (from the top). To me a bit of read might be more friendly. What about #3 with the darker red from #5. That red seems to print in black and white o.k.. > > Attached in the presentation deck with #4 and #3. > We could also have two versions and ask the rest of the team for their views tomorrow? > > What do you think? > > Regards > Rolf. > > > From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] > Sent: Mittwoch, 16. September 2015 00:19 > To: Prakash Ramchandran > Cc: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Here are some with the green and the orange. > > Ash > > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:02 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: > > From the top or the bottom? > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:00 PM, Prakash Ramchandran > wrote: > > My vote is for #2 of 6 as in logo as well monogram they will appear as distinct... Thanks Prakash > > Prakash Ramchandran > R&D USA > FutureWei Technologies, Inc > Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com > Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 > Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 > 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA > > > > > From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu ] On Behalf Of Ashlee Young > Sent: Tuesday, September 15, 2015 2:54 PM > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Okay, in hopes of narrowing this further? :) > > > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 1:41 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > > I like the colours from OPNFV and Opendaylight (see below). On your selection that could be close to Dragon Bay DE5725 and Orange Jewel DEA115. > > Style-wise I like the third option the most, perhaps with a different colour (the red would be quite close to VF though ;-)): > > > Are there any other views? > > Regards > Rolf. > > > > > > > > > > From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] > Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 18:38 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Just to get a sense for direction, can you take a look at the following comps and let me know choice of font combinations and/or colors. I?m also including a color palette for you to perhaps choose some other choices for colors. The palette is supposed to be indicative of popular 2015 color families. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > > > > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 8:27 AM, Ashlee Young > wrote: > > Great suggestions! I?ll get a couple more variations out shortly. > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 7:42 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > > Ashlee, > Many thanks for working on the logo matter ? in spite of your overload! If we had the logo we might be able to move forward with the web-site quickly. Very much appreciated. > > Below please find my comments and suggestions. Please view this as constructive support rather than criticism. I am sure there will be lots of different views! > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > Here is my feedback > - I like the principle design idea around centring on the O E and C > - If we want to improve I would change some of the following matters > ? Colour selection is a bit hard: perhaps a bit less black, more light and friendly colours, see OPNFV & opendaylight below > ? We could play with the colours also in the word Open Edge Computing and give Edge the same colour as the E bars in the logo. > ? The design elements have rather hard corners and shapes. Some more round edges may be more in vogue > ? Shorten the middle bar of the E on the right a bit further to avoid the one-ways street association > - The question is how that would work / look like with the name ?Open Edge Computing? > - Perhaps reduce the size of the logo in relation to the Letters OpenEdgeComputing > > Attached, please find a first attempt to put the logo on slides. > > > > > > > > From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] > Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 00:02 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > > > > > > > On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: > > Hi Rolf, > > I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) > > I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > Sent from my iPhone > > On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > > Dear all, > Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. > - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. > - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) > - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. > - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up > - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? > > Any comments or suggestions? > > In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). > ? Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. > > What do you think? > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > <20150904_165221.jpg> > > > Rolf Schuster > Head of Partner InnovationCentres > Architecture & Research > Vodafone Group Services GmbH > Mobile: +491722360098 > Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com > > Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, > D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 > Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff > vodafone.com? > > This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. > > > > > <20150904_165221.jpg> > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync > > > > > > > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150916/2a54834b/attachment-0001.html From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Thu Sep 17 04:44:34 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Thu, 17 Sep 2015 08:44:34 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week --> Call NOT cancelled TODAY Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FE3C0@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call later on today - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure Some of you might have received cancellation messages. This is just because I have updated the invite with the latest oec-sync list to ensure that Ashlee is also invited ;-) Also, I updated the meeting number as proposed by Chase. I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 3. September 2015 18:23 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Thanks for the constructive call today. Here are the action items. I uploaded the meeting slides as well as the Open Edge Computing Overview slides to our file repository (link again below). @Ashlee, are you receiving these mails by now? Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from Progress call 3rd September 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 14 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack summit AND OPNFV Summit 2. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) 3. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 17 Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 4. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 4 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 5. (Kiriong, until 5 Sept) Meeting with Vedams on Monday, 7 September, Meeting on OpenStack roadmap on Monday, 14 September (with Yun-Chao) 6. (Kiryong, until 5 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student 7. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) License discussion for Open Edge Initiative --> at Technical Program Call on 14 Sept? 8. (Yun-Chao, until 17 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting 9. (Yun-Chao and Rolf, 14 Sept) put together a proposal for membership structure + web-site + new partner outreach 10. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 11. Info: Cloudlet Class applicatin demonstration session on 1 December 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All welcome! Link to repository: https://owncloud.cmusatyalab.org/owncloud/public.php?service=files&t=c9f5bf1c36948d874459dea2fa50e57a _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 2. September 2015 21:50 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-09-03 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 1. September 2015 22:54 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and - please have a look at the action items below from our last call and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. Kind regards Rolf. Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 21. August 2015 16:38 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions... Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. Many thanks Rolf. << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx >> Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. - Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) --> DONE 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. Ideas: address verticals. 'Crowdsourcing' the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. --> Draft deck to be distributed 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. --> Has that happened? 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. 7. All: 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug - end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal --> Proposal from Satya under way... _____________________________________________ From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 Importance: High Hi there, Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well - We went through all agenda points - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. Any questions, please let me know. Best regards Guenter << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. Rolf. ______________________________ Dear all, As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas - Outreach Program Progress - Technical Program Progress - MEC Requirement Progress and go through the attached action item list. Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. Kind regards Rolf. Email from last meeting << Attachments: Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) >> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150917/a5199a04/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.presentationml.presentation Size: 1036631 bytes Desc: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150917/a5199a04/attachment-0001.bin From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Thu Sep 17 13:22:24 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Thu, 17 Sep 2015 17:22:24 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FE51C@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> Thanks for the constructive call today. Here are the action items. I uploaded the meeting slides to our file repository (link again below). Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from Progress call 17 September 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 25 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit 2. (Ashlee, until 25 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) 3. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 17 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie will send a draft of a OEC PoC proposal document the group. Satya and Kiryong support that process. Perhaps first E2E demo at Mobile World Congress in Barcelon 2016? 4. (Kiryong, until 23 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student 5. (Yun-Chao, until 25 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting? Check with Guenter if he is there as well. 6. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 7. (all, until 1 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 8. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 21 Sept) Finalise the draft blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 21 Sept. Ashlee & Prakash to send examples of "good" blueprints to Kiryong, Rolf and Satya asap. 9. (Ashlee, 21 Sept) send two final logo versions, prepare an early version of the webpage to be reviewed in Technical Program Call on Monday 21 Sept. Link to repository: https://owncloud.cmusatyalab.org/owncloud/public.php?service=files&t=c9f5bf1c36948d874459dea2fa50e57a _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 2. September 2015 21:50 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-09-03 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 1. September 2015 22:54 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and - please have a look at the action items below from our last call and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. Kind regards Rolf. Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 21. August 2015 16:38 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions... Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. Many thanks Rolf. << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx >> Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. - Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) --> DONE 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. Ideas: address verticals. 'Crowdsourcing' the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. --> Draft deck to be distributed 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. --> Has that happened? 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. 7. All: 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug - end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal --> Proposal from Satya under way... _____________________________________________ From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 Importance: High Hi there, Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well - We went through all agenda points - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. Any questions, please let me know. Best regards Guenter << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. Rolf. ______________________________ Dear all, As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas - Outreach Program Progress - Technical Program Progress - MEC Requirement Progress and go through the attached action item list. Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. Kind regards Rolf. Email from last meeting << Attachments: Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) >> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150917/f4f22005/attachment-0001.html From ashlee at onosfw.com Mon Sep 21 10:16:48 2015 From: ashlee at onosfw.com (Ashlee Young) Date: Mon, 21 Sep 2015 07:16:48 -0700 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <86706B47-D635-4BD4-8A16-EA3F14F67CA3@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FCD97@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <266F58D3-04CA-42E4-AB85-0981E6B1F37B@onosfw.com> <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB089688E5@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> <4CEF2DDD-9AFD-4638-B059-2A7FBE264444@onosfw.com> <887E8BDA-5CCA-4F16-917D-7CD6B5A8386A@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FD26A@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <13082FB1-4B7B-4170-B075-F18E9FAE1FBA@onosfw.com> Okay, I don?t know what I was thinking with trying to do a bunch of website iterations. Let?s try this instead. I?ve taken the two final candidates from last week and placed different backgrounds behind them. Now, obviously some of the colors will wash out completely. But I still want you to consider the background color. This is what everything is going to sit on top of? e.g., text, graphics, etc. If there?s a general color direction that you like, but what you see isn?t quite it, just let me know. Thanks, Ash > On Sep 16, 2015, at 3:47 PM, Ashlee Young wrote: > > Normally, I would do a reversed logo (aka white) to go onto darker backgrounds. So, I wouldn?t be overly concerned about that scenario. You?ve gotta keep in mind that going to print is going to be the biggest issue. I typically try to keep things to 2 colors vs. 4. And while I have indicated web-safe colors, we?ll ultimately want a pantone-based color for any collateral that we have produced or business cards. > > Here?s quick guide to consider: http://www.dcfb.com/Pages/2-color-designs.html > > Ash > > >> On Sep 16, 2015, at 2:34 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: >> >> O.K. #4 could be fine (from the top). To me a bit of read might be more friendly. What about #3 with the darker red from #5. That red seems to print in black and white o.k.. >> >> Attached in the presentation deck with #4 and #3. >> We could also have two versions and ask the rest of the team for their views tomorrow? >> >> What do you think? >> >> Regards >> Rolf. >> >> >> From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] >> Sent: Mittwoch, 16. September 2015 00:19 >> To: Prakash Ramchandran >> Cc: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu >> Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program >> >> Here are some with the green and the orange. >> >> Ash >> >> >> >> On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:02 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: >> >> From the top or the bottom? >> >> >> On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:00 PM, Prakash Ramchandran > wrote: >> >> My vote is for #2 of 6 as in logo as well monogram they will appear as distinct... Thanks Prakash >> >> Prakash Ramchandran >> R&D USA >> FutureWei Technologies, Inc >> Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com >> Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 >> Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 >> 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA >> >> >> >> >> From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu ] On Behalf Of Ashlee Young >> Sent: Tuesday, September 15, 2015 2:54 PM >> To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group >> Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu >> Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program >> >> Okay, in hopes of narrowing this further? :) >> >> >> >> >> On Sep 15, 2015, at 1:41 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: >> >> I like the colours from OPNFV and Opendaylight (see below). On your selection that could be close to Dragon Bay DE5725 and Orange Jewel DEA115. >> >> Style-wise I like the third option the most, perhaps with a different colour (the red would be quite close to VF though ;-)): >> >> >> Are there any other views? >> >> Regards >> Rolf. >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] >> Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 18:38 >> To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group >> Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu >> Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program >> >> Just to get a sense for direction, can you take a look at the following comps and let me know choice of font combinations and/or colors. I?m also including a color palette for you to perhaps choose some other choices for colors. The palette is supposed to be indicative of popular 2015 color families. >> >> Thanks, >> >> Ash >> >> >> >> >> >> >> On Sep 15, 2015, at 8:27 AM, Ashlee Young > wrote: >> >> Great suggestions! I?ll get a couple more variations out shortly. >> >> >> On Sep 15, 2015, at 7:42 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: >> >> Ashlee, >> Many thanks for working on the logo matter ? in spite of your overload! If we had the logo we might be able to move forward with the web-site quickly. Very much appreciated. >> >> Below please find my comments and suggestions. Please view this as constructive support rather than criticism. I am sure there will be lots of different views! >> >> Kind regards >> Rolf. >> >> >> Here is my feedback >> - I like the principle design idea around centring on the O E and C >> - If we want to improve I would change some of the following matters >> ? Colour selection is a bit hard: perhaps a bit less black, more light and friendly colours, see OPNFV & opendaylight below >> ? We could play with the colours also in the word Open Edge Computing and give Edge the same colour as the E bars in the logo. >> ? The design elements have rather hard corners and shapes. Some more round edges may be more in vogue >> ? Shorten the middle bar of the E on the right a bit further to avoid the one-ways street association >> - The question is how that would work / look like with the name ?Open Edge Computing? >> - Perhaps reduce the size of the logo in relation to the Letters OpenEdgeComputing >> >> Attached, please find a first attempt to put the logo on slides. >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] >> Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 00:02 >> To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group >> Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu >> Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program >> >> Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. >> >> Thanks, >> >> Ash >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: >> >> Hi Rolf, >> >> I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) >> >> I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. >> >> Thanks, >> >> Ash >> >> Sent from my iPhone >> >> On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: >> >> Dear all, >> Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. >> - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. >> - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) >> - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. >> - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up >> - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? >> >> Any comments or suggestions? >> >> In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). >> ? Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. >> >> What do you think? >> >> Kind regards >> Rolf. >> >> >> <20150904_165221.jpg> >> >> >> Rolf Schuster >> Head of Partner InnovationCentres >> Architecture & Research >> Vodafone Group Services GmbH >> Mobile: +491722360098 >> Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com >> >> Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, >> D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 >> Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff >> vodafone.com? >> >> This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. >> >> >> >> >> <20150904_165221.jpg> >> _______________________________________________ >> oe-sync mailing list >> oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu >> https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync >> >> >> >> >> >> >> > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150921/1ba4926d/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: background_comps.png Type: image/png Size: 805792 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150921/1ba4926d/attachment-0001.png From ashlee at onosfw.com Mon Sep 21 11:01:07 2015 From: ashlee at onosfw.com (Ashlee Young) Date: Mon, 21 Sep 2015 08:01:07 -0700 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: <13082FB1-4B7B-4170-B075-F18E9FAE1FBA@onosfw.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <86706B47-D635-4BD4-8A16-EA3F14F67CA3@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FCD97@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <266F58D3-04CA-42E4-AB85-0981E6B1F37B@onosfw.com> <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB089688E5@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> <4CEF2DDD-9AFD-4638-B059-2A7FBE264444@onosfw.com> <887E8BDA-5CCA-4F16-917D-7CD6B5A8386A@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FD26A@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <13082FB1-4B7B-4170-B075-F18E9FAE1FBA@onosfw.com> Message-ID: <94BCA5A9-99BB-464B-953E-D1D7ECD0F4FF@onosfw.com> BTW, the 2nd background from the top is the current default background. I?ve generated some comps on how the background looks with the logos and their ?reversed? variations. > On Sep 21, 2015, at 7:16 AM, Ashlee Young wrote: > > Okay, I don?t know what I was thinking with trying to do a bunch of website iterations. Let?s try this instead. I?ve taken the two final candidates from last week and placed different backgrounds behind them. Now, obviously some of the colors will wash out completely. But I still want you to consider the background color. This is what everything is going to sit on top of? e.g., text, graphics, etc. > > If there?s a general color direction that you like, but what you see isn?t quite it, just let me know. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > > > >> On Sep 16, 2015, at 3:47 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: >> >> Normally, I would do a reversed logo (aka white) to go onto darker backgrounds. So, I wouldn?t be overly concerned about that scenario. You?ve gotta keep in mind that going to print is going to be the biggest issue. I typically try to keep things to 2 colors vs. 4. And while I have indicated web-safe colors, we?ll ultimately want a pantone-based color for any collateral that we have produced or business cards. >> >> Here?s quick guide to consider: http://www.dcfb.com/Pages/2-color-designs.html >> >> Ash >> >> >>> On Sep 16, 2015, at 2:34 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: >>> >>> O.K. #4 could be fine (from the top). To me a bit of read might be more friendly. What about #3 with the darker red from #5. That red seems to print in black and white o.k.. >>> >>> Attached in the presentation deck with #4 and #3. >>> We could also have two versions and ask the rest of the team for their views tomorrow? >>> >>> What do you think? >>> >>> Regards >>> Rolf. >>> >>> >>> From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] >>> Sent: Mittwoch, 16. September 2015 00:19 >>> To: Prakash Ramchandran >>> Cc: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu >>> Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program >>> >>> Here are some with the green and the orange. >>> >>> Ash >>> >>> >>> >>> On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:02 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: >>> >>> From the top or the bottom? >>> >>> >>> On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:00 PM, Prakash Ramchandran > wrote: >>> >>> My vote is for #2 of 6 as in logo as well monogram they will appear as distinct... Thanks Prakash >>> >>> Prakash Ramchandran >>> R&D USA >>> FutureWei Technologies, Inc >>> Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com >>> Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 >>> Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 >>> 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu ] On Behalf Of Ashlee Young >>> Sent: Tuesday, September 15, 2015 2:54 PM >>> To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group >>> Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu >>> Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program >>> >>> Okay, in hopes of narrowing this further? :) >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> On Sep 15, 2015, at 1:41 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: >>> >>> I like the colours from OPNFV and Opendaylight (see below). On your selection that could be close to Dragon Bay DE5725 and Orange Jewel DEA115. >>> >>> Style-wise I like the third option the most, perhaps with a different colour (the red would be quite close to VF though ;-)): >>> >>> >>> Are there any other views? >>> >>> Regards >>> Rolf. >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] >>> Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 18:38 >>> To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group >>> Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu >>> Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program >>> >>> Just to get a sense for direction, can you take a look at the following comps and let me know choice of font combinations and/or colors. I?m also including a color palette for you to perhaps choose some other choices for colors. The palette is supposed to be indicative of popular 2015 color families. >>> >>> Thanks, >>> >>> Ash >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> On Sep 15, 2015, at 8:27 AM, Ashlee Young > wrote: >>> >>> Great suggestions! I?ll get a couple more variations out shortly. >>> >>> >>> On Sep 15, 2015, at 7:42 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: >>> >>> Ashlee, >>> Many thanks for working on the logo matter ? in spite of your overload! If we had the logo we might be able to move forward with the web-site quickly. Very much appreciated. >>> >>> Below please find my comments and suggestions. Please view this as constructive support rather than criticism. I am sure there will be lots of different views! >>> >>> Kind regards >>> Rolf. >>> >>> >>> Here is my feedback >>> - I like the principle design idea around centring on the O E and C >>> - If we want to improve I would change some of the following matters >>> ? Colour selection is a bit hard: perhaps a bit less black, more light and friendly colours, see OPNFV & opendaylight below >>> ? We could play with the colours also in the word Open Edge Computing and give Edge the same colour as the E bars in the logo. >>> ? The design elements have rather hard corners and shapes. Some more round edges may be more in vogue >>> ? Shorten the middle bar of the E on the right a bit further to avoid the one-ways street association >>> - The question is how that would work / look like with the name ?Open Edge Computing? >>> - Perhaps reduce the size of the logo in relation to the Letters OpenEdgeComputing >>> >>> Attached, please find a first attempt to put the logo on slides. >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] >>> Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 00:02 >>> To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group >>> Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu >>> Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program >>> >>> Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. >>> >>> Thanks, >>> >>> Ash >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: >>> >>> Hi Rolf, >>> >>> I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) >>> >>> I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. >>> >>> Thanks, >>> >>> Ash >>> >>> Sent from my iPhone >>> >>> On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: >>> >>> Dear all, >>> Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. >>> - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. >>> - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) >>> - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. >>> - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up >>> - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? >>> >>> Any comments or suggestions? >>> >>> In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). >>> ? Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. >>> >>> What do you think? >>> >>> Kind regards >>> Rolf. >>> >>> >>> <20150904_165221.jpg> >>> >>> >>> Rolf Schuster >>> Head of Partner InnovationCentres >>> Architecture & Research >>> Vodafone Group Services GmbH >>> Mobile: +491722360098 >>> Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com >>> >>> Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, >>> D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 >>> Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff >>> vodafone.com? >>> >>> This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> <20150904_165221.jpg> >>> _______________________________________________ >>> oe-sync mailing list >>> oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu >>> https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >> > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150921/c11e691f/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: reversed_background_comps.png Type: image/png Size: 275593 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150921/c11e691f/attachment-0001.png From Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com Mon Sep 21 11:23:55 2015 From: Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com (Prakash Ramchandran) Date: Mon, 21 Sep 2015 15:23:55 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: <94BCA5A9-99BB-464B-953E-D1D7ECD0F4FF@onosfw.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <86706B47-D635-4BD4-8A16-EA3F14F67CA3@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FCD97@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <266F58D3-04CA-42E4-AB85-0981E6B1F37B@onosfw.com> <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB089688E5@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> <4CEF2DDD-9AFD-4638-B059-2A7FBE264444@onosfw.com> <887E8BDA-5CCA-4F16-917D-7CD6B5A8386A@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FD26A@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <13082FB1-4B7B-4170-B075-F18E9FAE1FBA@onosfw.com> <94BCA5A9-99BB-464B-953E-D1D7ECD0F4FF@onosfw.com> Message-ID: <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB0896A026@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> 2nd from top looks great, +1 for it -Thanks Prakash Prakash Ramchandran [logo_huawei] R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Monday, September 21, 2015 8:01 AM To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: Prakash Ramchandran; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program BTW, the 2nd background from the top is the current default background. I?ve generated some comps on how the background looks with the logos and their ?reversed? variations. [cid:0AF79358-0927-48F7-BA22-AB433C20FAAD at hsd1.ca.comcast.net.] On Sep 21, 2015, at 7:16 AM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Okay, I don?t know what I was thinking with trying to do a bunch of website iterations. Let?s try this instead. I?ve taken the two final candidates from last week and placed different backgrounds behind them. Now, obviously some of the colors will wash out completely. But I still want you to consider the background color. This is what everything is going to sit on top of? e.g., text, graphics, etc. If there?s a general color direction that you like, but what you see isn?t quite it, just let me know. Thanks, Ash On Sep 16, 2015, at 3:47 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Normally, I would do a reversed logo (aka white) to go onto darker backgrounds. So, I wouldn?t be overly concerned about that scenario. You?ve gotta keep in mind that going to print is going to be the biggest issue. I typically try to keep things to 2 colors vs. 4. And while I have indicated web-safe colors, we?ll ultimately want a pantone-based color for any collateral that we have produced or business cards. Here?s quick guide to consider: http://www.dcfb.com/Pages/2-color-designs.html Ash On Sep 16, 2015, at 2:34 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: O.K. #4 could be fine (from the top). To me a bit of read might be more friendly. What about #3 with the darker red from #5. That red seems to print in black and white o.k.. Attached in the presentation deck with #4 and #3. We could also have two versions and ask the rest of the team for their views tomorrow? What do you think? Regards Rolf. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Mittwoch, 16. September 2015 00:19 To: Prakash Ramchandran Cc: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Here are some with the green and the orange. Ash On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:02 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: From the top or the bottom? On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:00 PM, Prakash Ramchandran > wrote: My vote is for #2 of 6 as in logo as well monogram they will appear as distinct... Thanks Prakash Prakash Ramchandran R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Ashlee Young Sent: Tuesday, September 15, 2015 2:54 PM To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Okay, in hopes of narrowing this further? :) On Sep 15, 2015, at 1:41 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: I like the colours from OPNFV and Opendaylight (see below). On your selection that could be close to Dragon Bay DE5725 and Orange Jewel DEA115. Style-wise I like the third option the most, perhaps with a different colour (the red would be quite close to VF though ;-)): Are there any other views? Regards Rolf. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 18:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Just to get a sense for direction, can you take a look at the following comps and let me know choice of font combinations and/or colors. I?m also including a color palette for you to perhaps choose some other choices for colors. The palette is supposed to be indicative of popular 2015 color families. Thanks, Ash On Sep 15, 2015, at 8:27 AM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Great suggestions! I?ll get a couple more variations out shortly. On Sep 15, 2015, at 7:42 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: Ashlee, Many thanks for working on the logo matter ? in spite of your overload! If we had the logo we might be able to move forward with the web-site quickly. Very much appreciated. Below please find my comments and suggestions. Please view this as constructive support rather than criticism. I am sure there will be lots of different views! Kind regards Rolf. Here is my feedback - I like the principle design idea around centring on the O E and C - If we want to improve I would change some of the following matters --> Colour selection is a bit hard: perhaps a bit less black, more light and friendly colours, see OPNFV & opendaylight below --> We could play with the colours also in the word Open Edge Computing and give Edge the same colour as the E bars in the logo. --> The design elements have rather hard corners and shapes. Some more round edges may be more in vogue --> Shorten the middle bar of the E on the right a bit further to avoid the one-ways street association - The question is how that would work / look like with the name ?Open Edge Computing? - Perhaps reduce the size of the logo in relation to the Letters OpenEdgeComputing Attached, please find a first attempt to put the logo on slides. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 00:02 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. Thanks, Ash On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Hi Rolf, I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. Thanks, Ash Sent from my iPhone On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: Dear all, Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? Any comments or suggestions? In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). --> Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. What do you think? Kind regards Rolf. <20150904_165221.jpg> Rolf Schuster Head of Partner InnovationCentres Architecture & Research Vodafone Group Services GmbH Mobile: +491722360098 Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff vodafone.com This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. <20150904_165221.jpg> _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150921/66833c54/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image001.png Type: image/png Size: 3243 bytes Desc: image001.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150921/66833c54/attachment-0002.png -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image004.png Type: image/png Size: 204896 bytes Desc: image004.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150921/66833c54/attachment-0003.png From Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com Mon Sep 21 11:27:06 2015 From: Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com (Prakash Ramchandran) Date: Mon, 21 Sep 2015 15:27:06 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: <13082FB1-4B7B-4170-B075-F18E9FAE1FBA@onosfw.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <86706B47-D635-4BD4-8A16-EA3F14F67CA3@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FCD97@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <266F58D3-04CA-42E4-AB85-0981E6B1F37B@onosfw.com> <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB089688E5@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> <4CEF2DDD-9AFD-4638-B059-2A7FBE264444@onosfw.com> <887E8BDA-5CCA-4F16-917D-7CD6B5A8386A@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FD26A@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <13082FB1-4B7B-4170-B075-F18E9FAE1FBA@onosfw.com> Message-ID: <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB0896A038@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> 1,7,13 from top are +1 from my side...Thanks Prakash Prakash Ramchandran [logo_huawei] R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Monday, September 21, 2015 7:17 AM To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: Prakash Ramchandran; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Okay, I don?t know what I was thinking with trying to do a bunch of website iterations. Let?s try this instead. I?ve taken the two final candidates from last week and placed different backgrounds behind them. Now, obviously some of the colors will wash out completely. But I still want you to consider the background color. This is what everything is going to sit on top of? e.g., text, graphics, etc. If there?s a general color direction that you like, but what you see isn?t quite it, just let me know. Thanks, Ash [cid:image002.png at 01D0F447.4B270C50] On Sep 16, 2015, at 3:47 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Normally, I would do a reversed logo (aka white) to go onto darker backgrounds. So, I wouldn?t be overly concerned about that scenario. You?ve gotta keep in mind that going to print is going to be the biggest issue. I typically try to keep things to 2 colors vs. 4. And while I have indicated web-safe colors, we?ll ultimately want a pantone-based color for any collateral that we have produced or business cards. Here?s quick guide to consider: http://www.dcfb.com/Pages/2-color-designs.html Ash On Sep 16, 2015, at 2:34 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: O.K. #4 could be fine (from the top). To me a bit of read might be more friendly. What about #3 with the darker red from #5. That red seems to print in black and white o.k.. Attached in the presentation deck with #4 and #3. We could also have two versions and ask the rest of the team for their views tomorrow? What do you think? Regards Rolf. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Mittwoch, 16. September 2015 00:19 To: Prakash Ramchandran Cc: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Here are some with the green and the orange. Ash On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:02 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: From the top or the bottom? On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:00 PM, Prakash Ramchandran > wrote: My vote is for #2 of 6 as in logo as well monogram they will appear as distinct... Thanks Prakash Prakash Ramchandran R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Ashlee Young Sent: Tuesday, September 15, 2015 2:54 PM To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Okay, in hopes of narrowing this further? :) On Sep 15, 2015, at 1:41 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: I like the colours from OPNFV and Opendaylight (see below). On your selection that could be close to Dragon Bay DE5725 and Orange Jewel DEA115. Style-wise I like the third option the most, perhaps with a different colour (the red would be quite close to VF though ;-)): Are there any other views? Regards Rolf. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 18:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Just to get a sense for direction, can you take a look at the following comps and let me know choice of font combinations and/or colors. I?m also including a color palette for you to perhaps choose some other choices for colors. The palette is supposed to be indicative of popular 2015 color families. Thanks, Ash On Sep 15, 2015, at 8:27 AM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Great suggestions! I?ll get a couple more variations out shortly. On Sep 15, 2015, at 7:42 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: Ashlee, Many thanks for working on the logo matter ? in spite of your overload! If we had the logo we might be able to move forward with the web-site quickly. Very much appreciated. Below please find my comments and suggestions. Please view this as constructive support rather than criticism. I am sure there will be lots of different views! Kind regards Rolf. Here is my feedback - I like the principle design idea around centring on the O E and C - If we want to improve I would change some of the following matters --> Colour selection is a bit hard: perhaps a bit less black, more light and friendly colours, see OPNFV & opendaylight below --> We could play with the colours also in the word Open Edge Computing and give Edge the same colour as the E bars in the logo. --> The design elements have rather hard corners and shapes. Some more round edges may be more in vogue --> Shorten the middle bar of the E on the right a bit further to avoid the one-ways street association - The question is how that would work / look like with the name ?Open Edge Computing? - Perhaps reduce the size of the logo in relation to the Letters OpenEdgeComputing Attached, please find a first attempt to put the logo on slides. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 00:02 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. Thanks, Ash On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Hi Rolf, I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. Thanks, Ash Sent from my iPhone On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: Dear all, Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? Any comments or suggestions? In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). --> Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. What do you think? Kind regards Rolf. <20150904_165221.jpg> Rolf Schuster Head of Partner InnovationCentres Architecture & Research Vodafone Group Services GmbH Mobile: +491722360098 Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff vodafone.com This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. <20150904_165221.jpg> _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150921/49a37d7e/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image001.png Type: image/png Size: 3243 bytes Desc: image001.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150921/49a37d7e/attachment-0002.png -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image002.png Type: image/png Size: 592907 bytes Desc: image002.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150921/49a37d7e/attachment-0003.png From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Mon Sep 21 12:06:42 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Mon, 21 Sep 2015 16:06:42 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: <13082FB1-4B7B-4170-B075-F18E9FAE1FBA@onosfw.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <86706B47-D635-4BD4-8A16-EA3F14F67CA3@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FCD97@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <266F58D3-04CA-42E4-AB85-0981E6B1F37B@onosfw.com> <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB089688E5@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> <4CEF2DDD-9AFD-4638-B059-2A7FBE264444@onosfw.com> <887E8BDA-5CCA-4F16-917D-7CD6B5A8386A@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FD26A@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <13082FB1-4B7B-4170-B075-F18E9FAE1FBA@onosfw.com> Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890305D66@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Ashlee, I looked around a little bit. All similar sites have mainly a white background (OPNFV, OPENSTACK, OPENDAYLIGHT). It might be best to stick to white as the background colour? If so I would still vote for the first from the top, perhaps with the orange a bit darker for the printing? Kind regards Rolf. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Montag, 21. September 2015 16:17 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: Prakash Ramchandran; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Okay, I don?t know what I was thinking with trying to do a bunch of website iterations. Let?s try this instead. I?ve taken the two final candidates from last week and placed different backgrounds behind them. Now, obviously some of the colors will wash out completely. But I still want you to consider the background color. This is what everything is going to sit on top of? e.g., text, graphics, etc. If there?s a general color direction that you like, but what you see isn?t quite it, just let me know. Thanks, Ash [cid:image001.png at 01D0F498.4428B830] On Sep 16, 2015, at 3:47 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Normally, I would do a reversed logo (aka white) to go onto darker backgrounds. So, I wouldn?t be overly concerned about that scenario. You?ve gotta keep in mind that going to print is going to be the biggest issue. I typically try to keep things to 2 colors vs. 4. And while I have indicated web-safe colors, we?ll ultimately want a pantone-based color for any collateral that we have produced or business cards. Here?s quick guide to consider: http://www.dcfb.com/Pages/2-color-designs.html Ash On Sep 16, 2015, at 2:34 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: O.K. #4 could be fine (from the top). To me a bit of read might be more friendly. What about #3 with the darker red from #5. That red seems to print in black and white o.k.. Attached in the presentation deck with #4 and #3. We could also have two versions and ask the rest of the team for their views tomorrow? What do you think? Regards Rolf. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Mittwoch, 16. September 2015 00:19 To: Prakash Ramchandran Cc: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Here are some with the green and the orange. Ash On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:02 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: From the top or the bottom? On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:00 PM, Prakash Ramchandran > wrote: My vote is for #2 of 6 as in logo as well monogram they will appear as distinct... Thanks Prakash Prakash Ramchandran R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Ashlee Young Sent: Tuesday, September 15, 2015 2:54 PM To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Okay, in hopes of narrowing this further? :) On Sep 15, 2015, at 1:41 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: I like the colours from OPNFV and Opendaylight (see below). On your selection that could be close to Dragon Bay DE5725 and Orange Jewel DEA115. Style-wise I like the third option the most, perhaps with a different colour (the red would be quite close to VF though ;-)): Are there any other views? Regards Rolf. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 18:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Just to get a sense for direction, can you take a look at the following comps and let me know choice of font combinations and/or colors. I?m also including a color palette for you to perhaps choose some other choices for colors. The palette is supposed to be indicative of popular 2015 color families. Thanks, Ash On Sep 15, 2015, at 8:27 AM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Great suggestions! I?ll get a couple more variations out shortly. On Sep 15, 2015, at 7:42 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: Ashlee, Many thanks for working on the logo matter ? in spite of your overload! If we had the logo we might be able to move forward with the web-site quickly. Very much appreciated. Below please find my comments and suggestions. Please view this as constructive support rather than criticism. I am sure there will be lots of different views! Kind regards Rolf. Here is my feedback - I like the principle design idea around centring on the O E and C - If we want to improve I would change some of the following matters --> Colour selection is a bit hard: perhaps a bit less black, more light and friendly colours, see OPNFV & opendaylight below --> We could play with the colours also in the word Open Edge Computing and give Edge the same colour as the E bars in the logo. --> The design elements have rather hard corners and shapes. Some more round edges may be more in vogue --> Shorten the middle bar of the E on the right a bit further to avoid the one-ways street association - The question is how that would work / look like with the name ?Open Edge Computing? - Perhaps reduce the size of the logo in relation to the Letters OpenEdgeComputing Attached, please find a first attempt to put the logo on slides. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 00:02 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. Thanks, Ash On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Hi Rolf, I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. Thanks, Ash Sent from my iPhone On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: Dear all, Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? Any comments or suggestions? In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). --> Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. What do you think? Kind regards Rolf. <20150904_165221.jpg> Rolf Schuster Head of Partner InnovationCentres Architecture & Research Vodafone Group Services GmbH Mobile: +491722360098 Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff vodafone.com This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. <20150904_165221.jpg> _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150921/99be4afb/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image001.png Type: image/png Size: 595310 bytes Desc: image001.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150921/99be4afb/attachment-0001.png From ashlee at onosfw.com Mon Sep 21 12:12:45 2015 From: ashlee at onosfw.com (Ashlee Young) Date: Mon, 21 Sep 2015 09:12:45 -0700 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890305D66@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <86706B47-D635-4BD4-8A16-EA3F14F67CA3@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FCD97@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <266F58D3-04CA-42E4-AB85-0981E6B1F37B@onosfw.com> <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB089688E5@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> <4CEF2DDD-9AFD-4638-B059-2A7FBE264444@onosfw.com> <887E8BDA-5CCA-4F16-917D-7CD6B5A8386A@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FD26A@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <13082FB1-4B7B-4170-B075-F18E9FAE1FBA@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890305D66@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: How?s this darker orange? Ash > On Sep 21, 2015, at 9:06 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group wrote: > > Ashlee, > I looked around a little bit. All similar sites have mainly a white background (OPNFV, OPENSTACK, OPENDAYLIGHT). It might be best to stick to white as the background colour? If so I would still vote for the first from the top, perhaps with the orange a bit darker for the printing? > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] > Sent: Montag, 21. September 2015 16:17 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: Prakash Ramchandran; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Okay, I don?t know what I was thinking with trying to do a bunch of website iterations. Let?s try this instead. I?ve taken the two final candidates from last week and placed different backgrounds behind them. Now, obviously some of the colors will wash out completely. But I still want you to consider the background color. This is what everything is going to sit on top of? e.g., text, graphics, etc. > > If there?s a general color direction that you like, but what you see isn?t quite it, just let me know. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > > > > On Sep 16, 2015, at 3:47 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: > > Normally, I would do a reversed logo (aka white) to go onto darker backgrounds. So, I wouldn?t be overly concerned about that scenario. You?ve gotta keep in mind that going to print is going to be the biggest issue. I typically try to keep things to 2 colors vs. 4. And while I have indicated web-safe colors, we?ll ultimately want a pantone-based color for any collateral that we have produced or business cards. > > Here?s quick guide to consider: http://www.dcfb.com/Pages/2-color-designs.html > > Ash > > > On Sep 16, 2015, at 2:34 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > > O.K. #4 could be fine (from the top). To me a bit of read might be more friendly. What about #3 with the darker red from #5. That red seems to print in black and white o.k.. > > Attached in the presentation deck with #4 and #3. > We could also have two versions and ask the rest of the team for their views tomorrow? > > What do you think? > > Regards > Rolf. > > > From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] > Sent: Mittwoch, 16. September 2015 00:19 > To: Prakash Ramchandran > Cc: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Here are some with the green and the orange. > > Ash > > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:02 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: > > From the top or the bottom? > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:00 PM, Prakash Ramchandran > wrote: > > My vote is for #2 of 6 as in logo as well monogram they will appear as distinct... Thanks Prakash > > Prakash Ramchandran > R&D USA > FutureWei Technologies, Inc > Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com > Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 > Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 > 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA > > > > > From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu ] On Behalf Of Ashlee Young > Sent: Tuesday, September 15, 2015 2:54 PM > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Okay, in hopes of narrowing this further? :) > > > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 1:41 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > > I like the colours from OPNFV and Opendaylight (see below). On your selection that could be close to Dragon Bay DE5725 and Orange Jewel DEA115. > > Style-wise I like the third option the most, perhaps with a different colour (the red would be quite close to VF though ;-)): > > > Are there any other views? > > Regards > Rolf. > > > > > > > > > > From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] > Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 18:38 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Just to get a sense for direction, can you take a look at the following comps and let me know choice of font combinations and/or colors. I?m also including a color palette for you to perhaps choose some other choices for colors. The palette is supposed to be indicative of popular 2015 color families. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > > > > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 8:27 AM, Ashlee Young > wrote: > > Great suggestions! I?ll get a couple more variations out shortly. > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 7:42 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > > Ashlee, > Many thanks for working on the logo matter ? in spite of your overload! If we had the logo we might be able to move forward with the web-site quickly. Very much appreciated. > > Below please find my comments and suggestions. Please view this as constructive support rather than criticism. I am sure there will be lots of different views! > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > Here is my feedback > - I like the principle design idea around centring on the O E and C > - If we want to improve I would change some of the following matters > ? Colour selection is a bit hard: perhaps a bit less black, more light and friendly colours, see OPNFV & opendaylight below > ? We could play with the colours also in the word Open Edge Computing and give Edge the same colour as the E bars in the logo. > ? The design elements have rather hard corners and shapes. Some more round edges may be more in vogue > ? Shorten the middle bar of the E on the right a bit further to avoid the one-ways street association > - The question is how that would work / look like with the name ?Open Edge Computing? > - Perhaps reduce the size of the logo in relation to the Letters OpenEdgeComputing > > Attached, please find a first attempt to put the logo on slides. > > > > > > > > From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] > Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 00:02 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > > > > > > > On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: > > Hi Rolf, > > I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) > > I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > Sent from my iPhone > > On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > > Dear all, > Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. > - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. > - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) > - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. > - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up > - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? > > Any comments or suggestions? > > In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). > ? Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. > > What do you think? > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > <20150904_165221.jpg> > > > Rolf Schuster > Head of Partner InnovationCentres > Architecture & Research > Vodafone Group Services GmbH > Mobile: +491722360098 > Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com > > Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, > D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 > Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff > vodafone.com? > > This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. > > > > > <20150904_165221.jpg> > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync > > > > > > > > > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150921/c5c88ef8/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: logo11_gr_or.png Type: image/png Size: 40679 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150921/c5c88ef8/attachment-0001.png From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Mon Sep 21 12:18:06 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Mon, 21 Sep 2015 16:18:06 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <86706B47-D635-4BD4-8A16-EA3F14F67CA3@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FCD97@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <266F58D3-04CA-42E4-AB85-0981E6B1F37B@onosfw.com> <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB089688E5@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> <4CEF2DDD-9AFD-4638-B059-2A7FBE264444@onosfw.com> <887E8BDA-5CCA-4F16-917D-7CD6B5A8386A@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FD26A@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <13082FB1-4B7B-4170-B075-F18E9FAE1FBA@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890305D66@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890305D86@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> That is better for those situations where people have a gray-scale print / copy. Rolf. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Montag, 21. September 2015 18:13 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program How?s this darker orange? Ash [cid:image001.png at 01D0F499.DC86F4B0] On Sep 21, 2015, at 9:06 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: Ashlee, I looked around a little bit. All similar sites have mainly a white background (OPNFV, OPENSTACK, OPENDAYLIGHT). It might be best to stick to white as the background colour? If so I would still vote for the first from the top, perhaps with the orange a bit darker for the printing? Kind regards Rolf. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Montag, 21. September 2015 16:17 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: Prakash Ramchandran; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Okay, I don?t know what I was thinking with trying to do a bunch of website iterations. Let?s try this instead. I?ve taken the two final candidates from last week and placed different backgrounds behind them. Now, obviously some of the colors will wash out completely. But I still want you to consider the background color. This is what everything is going to sit on top of? e.g., text, graphics, etc. If there?s a general color direction that you like, but what you see isn?t quite it, just let me know. Thanks, Ash On Sep 16, 2015, at 3:47 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Normally, I would do a reversed logo (aka white) to go onto darker backgrounds. So, I wouldn?t be overly concerned about that scenario. You?ve gotta keep in mind that going to print is going to be the biggest issue. I typically try to keep things to 2 colors vs. 4. And while I have indicated web-safe colors, we?ll ultimately want a pantone-based color for any collateral that we have produced or business cards. Here?s quick guide to consider: http://www.dcfb.com/Pages/2-color-designs.html Ash On Sep 16, 2015, at 2:34 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: O.K. #4 could be fine (from the top). To me a bit of read might be more friendly. What about #3 with the darker red from #5. That red seems to print in black and white o.k.. Attached in the presentation deck with #4 and #3. We could also have two versions and ask the rest of the team for their views tomorrow? What do you think? Regards Rolf. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Mittwoch, 16. September 2015 00:19 To: Prakash Ramchandran Cc: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Here are some with the green and the orange. Ash On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:02 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: From the top or the bottom? On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:00 PM, Prakash Ramchandran > wrote: My vote is for #2 of 6 as in logo as well monogram they will appear as distinct... Thanks Prakash Prakash Ramchandran R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Ashlee Young Sent: Tuesday, September 15, 2015 2:54 PM To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Okay, in hopes of narrowing this further? :) On Sep 15, 2015, at 1:41 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: I like the colours from OPNFV and Opendaylight (see below). On your selection that could be close to Dragon Bay DE5725 and Orange Jewel DEA115. Style-wise I like the third option the most, perhaps with a different colour (the red would be quite close to VF though ;-)): Are there any other views? Regards Rolf. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 18:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Just to get a sense for direction, can you take a look at the following comps and let me know choice of font combinations and/or colors. I?m also including a color palette for you to perhaps choose some other choices for colors. The palette is supposed to be indicative of popular 2015 color families. Thanks, Ash On Sep 15, 2015, at 8:27 AM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Great suggestions! I?ll get a couple more variations out shortly. On Sep 15, 2015, at 7:42 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: Ashlee, Many thanks for working on the logo matter ? in spite of your overload! If we had the logo we might be able to move forward with the web-site quickly. Very much appreciated. Below please find my comments and suggestions. Please view this as constructive support rather than criticism. I am sure there will be lots of different views! Kind regards Rolf. Here is my feedback - I like the principle design idea around centring on the O E and C - If we want to improve I would change some of the following matters --> Colour selection is a bit hard: perhaps a bit less black, more light and friendly colours, see OPNFV & opendaylight below --> We could play with the colours also in the word Open Edge Computing and give Edge the same colour as the E bars in the logo. --> The design elements have rather hard corners and shapes. Some more round edges may be more in vogue --> Shorten the middle bar of the E on the right a bit further to avoid the one-ways street association - The question is how that would work / look like with the name ?Open Edge Computing? - Perhaps reduce the size of the logo in relation to the Letters OpenEdgeComputing Attached, please find a first attempt to put the logo on slides. From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com] Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 00:02 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. Thanks, Ash On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: Hi Rolf, I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. Thanks, Ash Sent from my iPhone On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: Dear all, Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? Any comments or suggestions? In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). --> Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. What do you think? Kind regards Rolf. <20150904_165221.jpg> Rolf Schuster Head of Partner InnovationCentres Architecture & Research Vodafone Group Services GmbH Mobile: +491722360098 Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff vodafone.com This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. <20150904_165221.jpg> _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150921/e07ac9d6/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image001.png Type: image/png Size: 36425 bytes Desc: image001.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150921/e07ac9d6/attachment-0001.png From ashlee at onosfw.com Mon Sep 21 12:19:20 2015 From: ashlee at onosfw.com (Ashlee Young) Date: Mon, 21 Sep 2015 09:19:20 -0700 Subject: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program In-Reply-To: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890305D66@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8832AA86D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <7603B710-8285-4223-94F8-7EDE46067428@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FAB55@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <86706B47-D635-4BD4-8A16-EA3F14F67CA3@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FCD97@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <266F58D3-04CA-42E4-AB85-0981E6B1F37B@onosfw.com> <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB089688E5@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> <4CEF2DDD-9AFD-4638-B059-2A7FBE264444@onosfw.com> <887E8BDA-5CCA-4F16-917D-7CD6B5A8386A@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8902FD26A@VOEXM22W.internal.vodafone.com> <13082FB1-4B7B-4170-B075-F18E9FAE1FBA@onosfw.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890305D66@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: So, does it look like we have a working candidate? barring any issues that might come up? Thanks, Ash > On Sep 21, 2015, at 9:06 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group wrote: > > Ashlee, > I looked around a little bit. All similar sites have mainly a white background (OPNFV, OPENSTACK, OPENDAYLIGHT). It might be best to stick to white as the background colour? If so I would still vote for the first from the top, perhaps with the orange a bit darker for the printing? > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] > Sent: Montag, 21. September 2015 16:17 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: Prakash Ramchandran; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Okay, I don?t know what I was thinking with trying to do a bunch of website iterations. Let?s try this instead. I?ve taken the two final candidates from last week and placed different backgrounds behind them. Now, obviously some of the colors will wash out completely. But I still want you to consider the background color. This is what everything is going to sit on top of? e.g., text, graphics, etc. > > If there?s a general color direction that you like, but what you see isn?t quite it, just let me know. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > > > > On Sep 16, 2015, at 3:47 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: > > Normally, I would do a reversed logo (aka white) to go onto darker backgrounds. So, I wouldn?t be overly concerned about that scenario. You?ve gotta keep in mind that going to print is going to be the biggest issue. I typically try to keep things to 2 colors vs. 4. And while I have indicated web-safe colors, we?ll ultimately want a pantone-based color for any collateral that we have produced or business cards. > > Here?s quick guide to consider: http://www.dcfb.com/Pages/2-color-designs.html > > Ash > > > On Sep 16, 2015, at 2:34 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > > O.K. #4 could be fine (from the top). To me a bit of read might be more friendly. What about #3 with the darker red from #5. That red seems to print in black and white o.k.. > > Attached in the presentation deck with #4 and #3. > We could also have two versions and ask the rest of the team for their views tomorrow? > > What do you think? > > Regards > Rolf. > > > From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] > Sent: Mittwoch, 16. September 2015 00:19 > To: Prakash Ramchandran > Cc: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Here are some with the green and the orange. > > Ash > > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:02 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: > > From the top or the bottom? > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 3:00 PM, Prakash Ramchandran > wrote: > > My vote is for #2 of 6 as in logo as well monogram they will appear as distinct... Thanks Prakash > > Prakash Ramchandran > R&D USA > FutureWei Technologies, Inc > Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com > Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 > Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 > 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA > > > > > From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu ] On Behalf Of Ashlee Young > Sent: Tuesday, September 15, 2015 2:54 PM > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Okay, in hopes of narrowing this further? :) > > > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 1:41 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > > I like the colours from OPNFV and Opendaylight (see below). On your selection that could be close to Dragon Bay DE5725 and Orange Jewel DEA115. > > Style-wise I like the third option the most, perhaps with a different colour (the red would be quite close to VF though ;-)): > > > Are there any other views? > > Regards > Rolf. > > > > > > > > > > From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] > Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 18:38 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Just to get a sense for direction, can you take a look at the following comps and let me know choice of font combinations and/or colors. I?m also including a color palette for you to perhaps choose some other choices for colors. The palette is supposed to be indicative of popular 2015 color families. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > > > > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 8:27 AM, Ashlee Young > wrote: > > Great suggestions! I?ll get a couple more variations out shortly. > > > On Sep 15, 2015, at 7:42 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > > Ashlee, > Many thanks for working on the logo matter ? in spite of your overload! If we had the logo we might be able to move forward with the web-site quickly. Very much appreciated. > > Below please find my comments and suggestions. Please view this as constructive support rather than criticism. I am sure there will be lots of different views! > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > Here is my feedback > - I like the principle design idea around centring on the O E and C > - If we want to improve I would change some of the following matters > ? Colour selection is a bit hard: perhaps a bit less black, more light and friendly colours, see OPNFV & opendaylight below > ? We could play with the colours also in the word Open Edge Computing and give Edge the same colour as the E bars in the logo. > ? The design elements have rather hard corners and shapes. Some more round edges may be more in vogue > ? Shorten the middle bar of the E on the right a bit further to avoid the one-ways street association > - The question is how that would work / look like with the name ?Open Edge Computing? > - Perhaps reduce the size of the logo in relation to the Letters OpenEdgeComputing > > Attached, please find a first attempt to put the logo on slides. > > > > > > > > From: Ashlee Young [mailto:ashlee at onosfw.com ] > Sent: Dienstag, 15. September 2015 00:02 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Cc: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] Discussion on Outreach Program > > Not sure how this works for folks as a first draft logo. Please feel free to provide feedback. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > > > > > > > On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Ashlee Young > wrote: > > Hi Rolf, > > I have a logo to share. I've also been laying down content onto pages for the site. It's just takin longer than I expected due to changes in OPNFV, last week, that were sucking the life out of me :) > > I think you'll like the layout. But massaging the content is not trivial. It's time consuming. > > Thanks, > > Ash > > Sent from my iPhone > > On Sep 14, 2015, at 1:15 PM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > wrote: > > Dear all, > Here is a quick summary of the discussion between Yun-Chao and myself regarding the outreach direction. > - We agree in principle that the Open Edge Initiative should target the platform providers (like OpenStack) AS WELL AS the application providers (like augmented reality tech providers). The initiative will coordinate the implementation of the requirements from the application providers by the platform providers and the service providers. This will give it a unique scope and target. > - The initiative will eventually need a paid membership scheme. There should be a small board say of 9 persons, three from the application providers, 3 from the platform / infrastructure providers and 3 from the service providers / operators (see attached picture for details) > - New members have to provide relevant value (not just money) to become a member. We actively reach out to relevant companies ? right now without an offer for membership. In case we find companies who are willing to contribute, we will decide on a case by case basis. > - eventually we will need an upstream development toolset. However, they are relatively expensive to set-up > - eventually, we will have to build a sandbox infrastructure for developers to work. Also we will need a ?test and compliancy lab? > > Any comments or suggestions? > > In order to achieve that we will need a simple web-page asap. I think we could put together the content relatively quickly. However, we need a bit of marketing support from people who can create a nice look and feel (including logo). > ? Has anybody access to marketing resources? Temporary availability, remote location and part-time working should all be fine. > > What do you think? > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > <20150904_165221.jpg> > > > Rolf Schuster > Head of Partner InnovationCentres > Architecture & Research > Vodafone Group Services GmbH > Mobile: +491722360098 > Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com > > Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, > D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 > Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff > vodafone.com? > > This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. > > > > > <20150904_165221.jpg> > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync > > > > > > > > > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150921/ff424120/attachment-0001.html From valerie.j.young at intel.com Mon Sep 21 19:42:40 2015 From: valerie.j.young at intel.com (Young, Valerie J) Date: Mon, 21 Sep 2015 23:42:40 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call Message-ID: <96EFD7465592EA4A9CCEAAB849F4DFF6A44A9EA1@ORSMSX105.amr.corp.intel.com> Hi All, Attached is the start of the MEC PoC proposal. Please add/comment. Thanks, Best regards, valerie -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group [mailto:Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com] Sent: Tuesday, August 25, 2015 2:17 AM To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call When: Thursday, September 17, 2015 4:00 PM-5:30 PM (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: WebEx Call - Meeting link and voice dial-in details below (please use toll phone dial-in and NOT VoIP) Dear all, As agreed here is the invite for our bi-weekly progress call on Thursdays. Please distribute your deliverables / documents for that call to the participants latest on Wednesday before the call (best until noon EDT). Looking forward to discuss progress with you. Kind regards Rolf. Dial-in Details for bi-weekly Progress Call --> please use phone dial-in and NOT VoIP (to ensure acceptable voice quality) --> please use toll phone numbers outside of US (link below) to avoid additional cost for CMU the host of the WebEx session Host: Mahadev Satyanarayanan ?Meeting number: 737 875 986 Meeting password: oesync? Audio connection: ? +1-415-655-0002 US Global Call-In Numbers ? Access code: 737 865 028 Meeting Link? << File: ATT00001.txt >> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150921/682d07d6/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: MEC and Cloudlets PoC Proposal.docx Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.wordprocessingml.document Size: 92881 bytes Desc: MEC and Cloudlets PoC Proposal.docx Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150921/682d07d6/attachment-0001.bin From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Tue Sep 22 06:04:16 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Tue, 22 Sep 2015 10:04:16 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Canceled: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC89030613E@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, As agreed here is the invite for our bi-weekly progress call on Thursdays. Please distribute your deliverables / documents for that call to the participants latest on Wednesday before the call (best until noon EDT). Looking forward to discuss progress with you. Kind regards Rolf. Dial-in Details for bi-weekly Progress Call --> please use phone dial-in and NOT VoIP (to ensure acceptable voice quality) --> please use toll phone numbers outside of US (link below) to avoid additional cost for CMU the host of the WebEx session Open Edge Computing ?Bi-Weekly Sync ?Every 2 weeks on Thursdays Host: Mahadev Satyanarayanan ? Meeting number: 737 865 028 Meeting password: oesync? Audio connection: +1-415-655-0002 US Global Call-In Numbers ? Access code: 737 865 028 Meeting Link? -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150922/73db4fdd/attachment.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: not available Type: text/calendar Size: 3628 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150922/73db4fdd/attachment.bin From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Tue Sep 22 06:09:30 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Tue, 22 Sep 2015 10:09:30 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Cancellation of Progress Call and new invites... Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890306168@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, As discussed I have cancelled the weekly Progress Call as the recent change of the meeting time did not get to everybody (Outlook problem). I will now send a proper new invite. Additional, as agree yesterday we shift the Progress Call on 1 October as quite a few participants are not available. The call will now take place on Monday 5 October at the beginning of the weekly technical call. I hope that makes sense to all of you... Kind regards Rolf. [http://www.vodafone.com/content/dam/global_email_signature/sigroundel.png] Rolf Schuster Head of Partner Innovation Centres Architecture & Research Vodafone Group Services GmbH Mobile: +491722360098 Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff vodafone.com This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150922/1cab91cd/attachment.html From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Fri Sep 25 08:16:14 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2015 12:16:14 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing - program, initiative presentation, FAQ Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC89030A814@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, Attached, please find the final OEC-Overview deck I will present at the MEC Congress in London on Tuesday next week. I have changed our agreed OEC-Initiative slide deck slightly... - to reflect our recent decision to strengthen the engagement with application service providers - to adapt it to the situation that all the basics have already been covered by Satya and others before my talk. Please have a look at the deck and let me know your comments and changes ideally today (submission deadline). Please let me know if that is too tight for you. Furthermore, please be aware that we managed to squeeze in two more sessions into the congress (final program attached): - an "Operator Synchronisation session on Edge Computing" just to exchanging ideas on pre-commercial strategy, business direction and activities (led by me, 1st day, 16:05 UK) - a "Technology Deep Dive" on Cloudlet (led by Satya, 2nd day 16:15 UK) Last not least, just to try to align on the most important questions we will be asked during the event, I have put together two questions and (my) answers below. Also here your comments are welcome... (ideally also until today cob). Many thanks for your feedback and continuous support! Kind regards Rolf. Here are two key questions many people will ask us during and my version of the answers. Also here your comments are welcome... Is the OEC Initiative competing with ETSI MEC? No, the OEC Initiatiave is complementing the valuable work of ETSI MEC. It will reach out to the Application Service Providers to get their requirements and it will drive an open reference platform into the IT industry. All specifications and activities will be closely aligned with ETSI MEC. What plans does OEI have regarding the future shape of the initiative? The OEC Initiative will an initiative that is open to three groups of members: Application Service Providers, Infrastructure Providers and Services Providers. All three groups will be represented in the governance of the initiative. The initiative itself will be incorporated as an own legal entity funded by membership fees. [http://www.vodafone.com/content/dam/global_email_signature/sigroundel.png] Rolf Schuster Head of Partner Innovation Centres Architecture & Research Vodafone Group Services GmbH Mobile: +491722360098 Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff vodafone.com This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150925/8f548e1f/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview for MEC Congress 0-8 short.pptx Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.presentationml.presentation Size: 649368 bytes Desc: Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview for MEC Congress 0-8 short.pptx Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150925/8f548e1f/attachment-0002.bin -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: Mobile Edge Computing Congress Agenda for event guide 24 Sept.docx Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.wordprocessingml.document Size: 995843 bytes Desc: Mobile Edge Computing Congress Agenda for event guide 24 Sept.docx Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20150925/8f548e1f/attachment-0003.bin From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Mon Oct 5 06:18:08 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Mon, 5 Oct 2015 10:18:08 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC89031B04A@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, Today we will have a shortened progress call in the beginning of the weekly call of the technical team. Hence, we will just address a few matters: - Action items from last call (see below and attachment for details) - Brief summary of MEC Congress in London last week - Status and next steps regarding Nova Blueprint Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from 17 September: 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 25 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit 2. (Ashlee, until 25 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) 3. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 17 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie will send a draft of a OEC PoC proposal document the group. Satya and Kiryong support that process. Perhaps first E2E demo at Mobile World Congress in Barcelon 2016? 4. (Kiryong, until 23 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student 5. (Yun-Chao, until 25 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting? Check with Guenter if he is there as well. 6. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 7. (all, until 1 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 8. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 21 Sept) Finalise the draft blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 21 Sept. Ashlee & Prakash to send examples of "good" blueprints to Kiryong, Rolf and Satya asap. 9. (Ashlee, 21 Sept) send two final logo versions, prepare an early version of the webpage to be reviewed in Technical Program Call on Monday 21 Sept. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 17. September 2015 10:45 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week --> Call NOT cancelled TODAY Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call later on today - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure Some of you might have received cancellation messages. This is just because I have updated the invite with the latest oec-sync list to ensure that Ashlee is also invited ;-) Also, I updated the meeting number as proposed by Chase. I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 3. September 2015 18:23 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Thanks for the constructive call today. Here are the action items. I uploaded the meeting slides as well as the Open Edge Computing Overview slides to our file repository (link again below). @Ashlee, are you receiving these mails by now? Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from Progress call 3rd September 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 14 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack summit AND OPNFV Summit 2. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) 3. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 17 Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 4. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 4 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 5. (Kiriong, until 5 Sept) Meeting with Vedams on Monday, 7 September, Meeting on OpenStack roadmap on Monday, 14 September (with Yun-Chao) 6. (Kiryong, until 5 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student 7. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) License discussion for Open Edge Initiative --> at Technical Program Call on 14 Sept? 8. (Yun-Chao, until 17 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting 9. (Yun-Chao and Rolf, 14 Sept) put together a proposal for membership structure + web-site + new partner outreach 10. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 11. Info: Cloudlet Class applicatin demonstration session on 1 December 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All welcome! Link to repository: https://owncloud.cmusatyalab.org/owncloud/public.php?service=files&t=c9f5bf1c36948d874459dea2fa50e57a _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 2. September 2015 21:50 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-09-03 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 1. September 2015 22:54 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and - please have a look at the action items below from our last call and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. Kind regards Rolf. Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 21. August 2015 16:38 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions... Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. Many thanks Rolf. << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx >> Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. - Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) --> DONE 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. Ideas: address verticals. 'Crowdsourcing' the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. --> Draft deck to be distributed 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. --> Has that happened? 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. 7. All: 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug - end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal --> Proposal from Satya under way... _____________________________________________ From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 Importance: High Hi there, Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well - We went through all agenda points - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. Any questions, please let me know. Best regards Guenter << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. Rolf. ______________________________ Dear all, As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas - Outreach Program Progress - Technical Program Progress - MEC Requirement Progress and go through the attached action item list. Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. Kind regards Rolf. Email from last meeting << Attachments: Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) >> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151005/01d48a8c/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call with actions.pptx Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.presentationml.presentation Size: 1128744 bytes Desc: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call with actions.pptx Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151005/01d48a8c/attachment-0001.bin From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Tue Oct 6 05:39:42 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Tue, 6 Oct 2015 09:39:42 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC89031BD2A@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, Thanks for the constructive discussion yesterday. Please find the action items from the call below. Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from 6 October: 1. (Prakash, until 15 Oct) push for OEC code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit. 2. (Prakash supported by Valerie, Guenter, Kiryong, 9 Oct) Prakash to organise this week to finalise the MEC PoC proposal to be submitted at the MEC meeting next week. Valerie to send material on Intel technology that may be used for the PoC. 3. (Kiryong, until ?) Describe rational behind QEMU modifications. Upgrade QEMU-modifications to current QEMU version. 4. (Yun-Chao, Guenter until Nov) continue to liaise with GSMA and monitor their task force work on edge computing. 5. (Rolf, Guenter until Nov) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 6. (all, until 15 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 7. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 11 Oct) Finalise the blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 11 Oct. Prakash to organise a call on that matter this week. 8. (all, 15 Oct) send key material, text snippets for the OEC web page to Ashley. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Montag, 5. Oktober 2015 12:18 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Dear all, Today we will have a shortened progress call in the beginning of the weekly call of the technical team. Hence, we will just address a few matters: - Action items from last call (see below and attachment for details) - Brief summary of MEC Congress in London last week - Status and next steps regarding Nova Blueprint Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from 17 September: 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 25 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit 2. (Ashlee, until 25 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) 3. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 17 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie will send a draft of a OEC PoC proposal document the group. Satya and Kiryong support that process. Perhaps first E2E demo at Mobile World Congress in Barcelon 2016? 4. (Kiryong, until 23 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student 5. (Yun-Chao, until 25 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting? Check with Guenter if he is there as well. 6. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 7. (all, until 1 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 8. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 21 Sept) Finalise the draft blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 21 Sept. Ashlee & Prakash to send examples of "good" blueprints to Kiryong, Rolf and Satya asap. 9. (Ashlee, 21 Sept) send two final logo versions, prepare an early version of the webpage to be reviewed in Technical Program Call on Monday 21 Sept. << File: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call with actions.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 17. September 2015 10:45 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week --> Call NOT cancelled TODAY Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call later on today - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure Some of you might have received cancellation messages. This is just because I have updated the invite with the latest oec-sync list to ensure that Ashlee is also invited ;-) Also, I updated the meeting number as proposed by Chase. I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 3. September 2015 18:23 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Thanks for the constructive call today. Here are the action items. I uploaded the meeting slides as well as the Open Edge Computing Overview slides to our file repository (link again below). @Ashlee, are you receiving these mails by now? Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from Progress call 3rd September 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 14 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack summit AND OPNFV Summit 2. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) 3. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 17 Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 4. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 4 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 5. (Kiriong, until 5 Sept) Meeting with Vedams on Monday, 7 September, Meeting on OpenStack roadmap on Monday, 14 September (with Yun-Chao) 6. (Kiryong, until 5 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student 7. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) License discussion for Open Edge Initiative --> at Technical Program Call on 14 Sept? 8. (Yun-Chao, until 17 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting 9. (Yun-Chao and Rolf, 14 Sept) put together a proposal for membership structure + web-site + new partner outreach 10. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 11. Info: Cloudlet Class applicatin demonstration session on 1 December 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All welcome! Link to repository: https://owncloud.cmusatyalab.org/owncloud/public.php?service=files&t=c9f5bf1c36948d874459dea2fa50e57a _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 2. September 2015 21:50 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-09-03 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 1. September 2015 22:54 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and - please have a look at the action items below from our last call and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. Kind regards Rolf. Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 21. August 2015 16:38 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions... Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. Many thanks Rolf. << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx >> Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. - Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) --> DONE 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. Ideas: address verticals. 'Crowdsourcing' the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. --> Draft deck to be distributed 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. --> Has that happened? 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. 7. All: 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug - end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal --> Proposal from Satya under way... _____________________________________________ From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 Importance: High Hi there, Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well - We went through all agenda points - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. Any questions, please let me know. Best regards Guenter << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. Rolf. ______________________________ Dear all, As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas - Outreach Program Progress - Technical Program Progress - MEC Requirement Progress and go through the attached action item list. Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. Kind regards Rolf. Email from last meeting << Attachments: Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) >> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/8974d0bd/attachment-0001.html From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Tue Oct 6 07:54:44 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Tue, 6 Oct 2015 11:54:44 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] FW: Join Ford, Intel, AT&T, SK Telecom and key players to explore MEC and IoT in co-located workshops In-Reply-To: <3nRnH52hSCz1CGL8@mail03.vodafone.com> References: <3nRnH52hSCz1CGL8@mail03.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC89031BF49@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, Just to avoid confusion, Guenter has sent a link for a different MEC event in California (?Mobile Edge Computing ? Focus Day?, 30 Nov ? 3 Dec): http://carriernetworkvirtualization.com/mec-focus-day/ The MEC event I was referring to is called ?Designing and Deploying Mobile Edge Computing?, 9-10 Nov organised by IWPC at San Jose with Intel as a host (see below for details). I believe Satya will try to make himself available as a speaker at that event. Details see below and here: http://www.iwpc.org/workshops/2015/2015-11-intel/MEC-agenda.html Additional, I am planning to speak the the IoT event 11-12 Nov also organised by IWPC at the same location in San Jose that involves a lot of automotive manufacturers. Details see below and here: http://www.iwpc.org/workshops/2015/2015-11-Ford/agenda.html There are just too many events I guess? Kind regards Rolf. From: IWPC - Tom Watson [mailto:iwpc-team2 at iwpc.net] Sent: Donnerstag, 1. Oktober 2015 23:12 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Subject: Join Ford, Intel, AT&T, SK Telecom and key players to explore MEC and IoT in co-located workshops [Please enable images for a better experience.] [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/icon_online-version.gif] Web Version [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/icon_unsubscribe.gif] Unsubscribe [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/icon_forward.gif] Change Subscription Details [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/top-link_bottom-border.gif] [IWPC] Co-Located Workshop Notice November 9-13, 2015 TWO CO-LOCATED WORKSHOPS [wsdarkblue] Designing and Deploying Mobile Edge Computing Internet of Things Exploring Opportunities, Radio Access and Transport Network Requirements, Benefits, and Trade-offs Exploring Market Drivers, Sensor Technology Innovation, and Future Network Architecture Demands for Vertical Market Use-Cases Hosted by: [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_workshops/intel-logo-150px.jpg] Keynote by: [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos/Ford%20GoFurtherLogo1.jpg] November 9-10, 2015 November 10-13, 2015 [Agenda] [http://www.iwpc.org/Workshop_Folders/12_10_TTER_ATT/images/register.jpg] [Agenda] [http://www.iwpc.org/Workshop_Folders/12_10_TTER_ATT/images/register.jpg] [long banner] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/att_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/calidmv_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/ethertronics_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/ford-new.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/huawei_agenda%5b1%5d.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/ibm_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/Logos_agenda/intel_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/interdigital_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/juniper.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/KOC.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/microsoft_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/nokia_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos/OnLab.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_workshops/PNNL_Color_Logo1.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/prisma_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/Saguna.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/scripps_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/sequans_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/sktelecom_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/sony_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/ul%20verification.JPG] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/ZTE_logo.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/spacer_content.gif] [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/spacer_content.gif] Where: Questions? Registration: Double Tree by Hilton San Jose, CA, USA MORE HOTEL INFO >> Please Contact: Graham Carter Technical Consultant, IWPC +1 (215) 293-9000 gc at iwpc.org Each Event Limited to 100 seats First Registered, First Served! No Press. No Analysts. No Consultants. No 3rd Party Sales Reps. Attendance: Attendance is open to ALL IWPC Members Attendance for Non-Members? Please contact the IWPC for details. [registernow] [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/horizontal-line.gif] [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/footer-top-border.gif] IWPC - International Wireless Industry Consortium 2003 S. Easton Road, Suite 200 Doylestown, PA 18901 TEL: +1 (215) 293-9000 Website: www.iwpc.org IWPC respects your online time & Internet privacy. Unsubscribe | Change Your Subscription Details Click to send me no mailings concerning these workshops only. ? Copyright 2015 IWPC, Inc. All rights Reserved. Privacy Policy [Request IWPC Membership Info.] Request IWPC Membership Information [Follow us on Twitter!] Follow us on Twitter! [LinkedIn] IWPC LinkedIn Group [LinkedIn] Like us on Facebook! [Follow us on Twitter!] Subscribe to the IWPC RSS Feed! [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/spacer_top-links.gif] [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/spacer_top-links.gif] [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/spacer_top-links.gif] [Please enable images for a better experience.] Sent to:rolf.schuster at vodafone.com If you prefer not to receive future e-mails of this type, click here Sent By: IWPC 2003 S. Easton Road Doylestown Pennsylvania 18901 United States [http://www.Swiftpage5.com/images/powerdby.gif] To view as a web page click here. [http://www.Swiftpage5.com/images/Fwd2Friend.gif] -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/d30b08e4/attachment-0001.html From valerie.j.young at intel.com Tue Oct 6 08:36:24 2015 From: valerie.j.young at intel.com (Young, Valerie J) Date: Tue, 6 Oct 2015 12:36:24 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] FW: Join Ford, Intel, AT&T, SK Telecom and key players to explore MEC and IoT in co-located workshops In-Reply-To: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC89031BF49@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <3nRnH52hSCz1CGL8@mail03.vodafone.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC89031BF49@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <96EFD7465592EA4A9CCEAAB849F4DFF6A75F47CF@ORSMSX105.amr.corp.intel.com> Hi Rolf, all, Caroline and I will be at the MEC IWPC event, Nov 9-10 Thanks Best regards, valerie From: oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Tuesday, October 06, 2015 4:55 AM To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: Chan, Caroline Subject: [oe-sync] FW: Join Ford, Intel, AT&T, SK Telecom and key players to explore MEC and IoT in co-located workshops Dear all, Just to avoid confusion, Guenter has sent a link for a different MEC event in California (?Mobile Edge Computing ? Focus Day?, 30 Nov ? 3 Dec): http://carriernetworkvirtualization.com/mec-focus-day/ The MEC event I was referring to is called ?Designing and Deploying Mobile Edge Computing?, 9-10 Nov organised by IWPC at San Jose with Intel as a host (see below for details). I believe Satya will try to make himself available as a speaker at that event. Details see below and here: http://www.iwpc.org/workshops/2015/2015-11-intel/MEC-agenda.html Additional, I am planning to speak the the IoT event 11-12 Nov also organised by IWPC at the same location in San Jose that involves a lot of automotive manufacturers. Details see below and here: http://www.iwpc.org/workshops/2015/2015-11-Ford/agenda.html There are just too many events I guess? Kind regards Rolf. From: IWPC - Tom Watson [mailto:iwpc-team2 at iwpc.net] Sent: Donnerstag, 1. Oktober 2015 23:12 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Subject: Join Ford, Intel, AT&T, SK Telecom and key players to explore MEC and IoT in co-located workshops [Image removed by sender. Please enable images for a better experience.] [Image removed by sender.] Web Version [Image removed by sender.] Unsubscribe [Image removed by sender.] Change Subscription Details [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender. IWPC] Co-Located Workshop Notice November 9-13, 2015 TWO CO-LOCATED WORKSHOPS [Image removed by sender. wsdarkblue] Designing and Deploying Mobile Edge Computing Internet of Things Exploring Opportunities, Radio Access and Transport Network Requirements, Benefits, and Trade-offs Exploring Market Drivers, Sensor Technology Innovation, and Future Network Architecture Demands for Vertical Market Use-Cases Hosted by: [Image removed by sender.] Keynote by: [Image removed by sender.] November 9-10, 2015 November 10-13, 2015 [Image removed by sender. Agenda] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender. Agenda] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender. long banner] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] Where: Questions? Registration: Double Tree by Hilton San Jose, CA, USA MORE HOTEL INFO >> Please Contact: Graham Carter Technical Consultant, IWPC +1 (215) 293-9000 gc at iwpc.org Each Event Limited to 100 seats First Registered, First Served! No Press. No Analysts. No Consultants. No 3rd Party Sales Reps. Attendance: Attendance is open to ALL IWPC Members Attendance for Non-Members? Please contact the IWPC for details. [Image removed by sender. registernow] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] IWPC - International Wireless Industry Consortium 2003 S. Easton Road, Suite 200 Doylestown, PA 18901 TEL: +1 (215) 293-9000 Website: www.iwpc.org IWPC respects your online time & Internet privacy. Unsubscribe | Change Your Subscription Details Click to send me no mailings concerning these workshops only. ? Copyright 2015 IWPC, Inc. All rights Reserved. Privacy Policy [Image removed by sender. Request IWPC Membership Info.] Request IWPC Membership Information [Image removed by sender. Follow us on Twitter!] Follow us on Twitter! [Image removed by sender. LinkedIn] IWPC LinkedIn Group [Image removed by sender. LinkedIn] Like us on Facebook! [Image removed by sender. Follow us on Twitter!] Subscribe to the IWPC RSS Feed! [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender.] [Image removed by sender. Please enable images for a better experience.] Sent to:rolf.schuster at vodafone.com If you prefer not to receive future e-mails of this type, click here Sent By: IWPC 2003 S. Easton Road Doylestown Pennsylvania 18901 United States [Image removed by sender.] To view as a web page click here. [Image removed by sender.] -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: ~WRD007.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 823 bytes Desc: ~WRD007.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0041.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image001.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 334 bytes Desc: image001.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0042.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image002.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 444 bytes Desc: image002.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0043.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image003.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 332 bytes Desc: image003.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0044.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image004.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 335 bytes Desc: image004.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0045.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image005.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 334 bytes Desc: image005.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0046.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image006.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 388 bytes Desc: image006.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0047.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image007.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 388 bytes Desc: image007.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0048.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image008.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 545 bytes Desc: image008.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0049.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image009.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 429 bytes Desc: image009.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0050.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image010.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 517 bytes Desc: image010.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0051.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image011.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 390 bytes Desc: image011.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0052.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image012.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 470 bytes Desc: image012.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0053.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image013.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 381 bytes Desc: image013.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0054.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image014.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 377 bytes Desc: image014.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0055.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image015.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 416 bytes Desc: image015.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0056.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image016.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 368 bytes Desc: image016.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0057.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image017.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 399 bytes Desc: image017.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0058.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image018.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 392 bytes Desc: image018.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0059.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image019.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 354 bytes Desc: image019.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0060.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image020.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 388 bytes Desc: image020.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0061.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image021.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 444 bytes Desc: image021.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0062.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image022.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 377 bytes Desc: image022.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0063.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image023.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 365 bytes Desc: image023.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0064.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image024.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 444 bytes Desc: image024.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0065.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image025.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 439 bytes Desc: image025.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0066.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image026.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 377 bytes Desc: image026.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0067.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image027.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 388 bytes Desc: image027.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0068.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image028.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 410 bytes Desc: image028.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0069.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image029.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 388 bytes Desc: image029.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0070.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image030.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 386 bytes Desc: image030.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0071.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image031.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 380 bytes Desc: image031.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0072.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image032.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 336 bytes Desc: image032.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0073.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image033.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 388 bytes Desc: image033.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0074.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image034.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 421 bytes Desc: image034.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0075.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image035.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 444 bytes Desc: image035.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0076.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image036.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 500 bytes Desc: image036.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0077.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image037.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 335 bytes Desc: image037.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0078.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image038.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 332 bytes Desc: image038.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0079.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image039.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 336 bytes Desc: image039.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0080.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image040.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 332 bytes Desc: image040.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/9a2d0eb6/attachment-0081.jpg From Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com Tue Oct 6 14:01:45 2015 From: Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com (Prakash Ramchandran) Date: Tue, 6 Oct 2015 18:01:45 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] FW: Join Ford, Intel, AT&T, SK Telecom and key players to explore MEC and IoT in co-located workshops In-Reply-To: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC89031BF49@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <3nRnH52hSCz1CGL8@mail03.vodafone.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC89031BF49@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB0896ECC3@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> FYI: We have a conflict here between IWPC Nov 9-10 & and OPNFV summit in SF in Nov.9-12 http://events.linuxfoundation.org/events/opnfv-summit Prakash Ramchandran [logo_huawei] R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Tuesday, October 06, 2015 4:55 AM To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: caroline.chan at intel.com Subject: [oe-sync] FW: Join Ford, Intel, AT&T, SK Telecom and key players to explore MEC and IoT in co-located workshops Dear all, Just to avoid confusion, Guenter has sent a link for a different MEC event in California (?Mobile Edge Computing ? Focus Day?, 30 Nov ? 3 Dec): http://carriernetworkvirtualization.com/mec-focus-day/ The MEC event I was referring to is called ?Designing and Deploying Mobile Edge Computing?, 9-10 Nov organised by IWPC at San Jose with Intel as a host (see below for details). I believe Satya will try to make himself available as a speaker at that event. Details see below and here: http://www.iwpc.org/workshops/2015/2015-11-intel/MEC-agenda.html Additional, I am planning to speak the the IoT event 11-12 Nov also organised by IWPC at the same location in San Jose that involves a lot of automotive manufacturers. Details see below and here: http://www.iwpc.org/workshops/2015/2015-11-Ford/agenda.html There are just too many events I guess? Kind regards Rolf. From: IWPC - Tom Watson [mailto:iwpc-team2 at iwpc.net] Sent: Donnerstag, 1. Oktober 2015 23:12 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Subject: Join Ford, Intel, AT&T, SK Telecom and key players to explore MEC and IoT in co-located workshops [Please enable images for a better experience.] [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/icon_online-version.gif] Web Version [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/icon_unsubscribe.gif] Unsubscribe [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/icon_forward.gif] Change Subscription Details [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/top-link_bottom-border.gif] [IWPC] Co-Located Workshop Notice November 9-13, 2015 TWO CO-LOCATED WORKSHOPS [wsdarkblue] Designing and Deploying Mobile Edge Computing Internet of Things Exploring Opportunities, Radio Access and Transport Network Requirements, Benefits, and Trade-offs Exploring Market Drivers, Sensor Technology Innovation, and Future Network Architecture Demands for Vertical Market Use-Cases Hosted by: [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_workshops/intel-logo-150px.jpg] Keynote by: [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos/Ford%20GoFurtherLogo1.jpg] November 9-10, 2015 November 10-13, 2015 [Agenda] [http://www.iwpc.org/Workshop_Folders/12_10_TTER_ATT/images/register.jpg] [Agenda] [http://www.iwpc.org/Workshop_Folders/12_10_TTER_ATT/images/register.jpg] [long banner] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/att_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/calidmv_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/ethertronics_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/ford-new.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/huawei_agenda%5b1%5d.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/ibm_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/Logos_agenda/intel_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/interdigital_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/juniper.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/KOC.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/microsoft_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/nokia_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos/OnLab.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_workshops/PNNL_Color_Logo1.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/prisma_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/Saguna.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/scripps_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/sequans_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/sktelecom_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/sony_agenda.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/ul%20verification.JPG] [http://www.iwpc.org/images/logos_agenda/ZTE_logo.jpg] [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/spacer_content.gif] [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/spacer_content.gif] Where: Questions? Registration: Double Tree by Hilton San Jose, CA, USA MORE HOTEL INFO >> Please Contact: Graham Carter Technical Consultant, IWPC +1 (215) 293-9000 gc at iwpc.org Each Event Limited to 100 seats First Registered, First Served! No Press. No Analysts. No Consultants. No 3rd Party Sales Reps. Attendance: Attendance is open to ALL IWPC Members Attendance for Non-Members? Please contact the IWPC for details. [registernow] [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/horizontal-line.gif] [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/footer-top-border.gif] IWPC - International Wireless Industry Consortium 2003 S. Easton Road, Suite 200 Doylestown, PA 18901 TEL: +1 (215) 293-9000 Website: www.iwpc.org IWPC respects your online time & Internet privacy. Unsubscribe | Change Your Subscription Details Click to send me no mailings concerning these workshops only. ? Copyright 2015 IWPC, Inc. All rights Reserved. Privacy Policy [Request IWPC Membership Info.] Request IWPC Membership Information [Follow us on Twitter!] Follow us on Twitter! [LinkedIn] IWPC LinkedIn Group [LinkedIn] Like us on Facebook! [Follow us on Twitter!] Subscribe to the IWPC RSS Feed! [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/spacer_top-links.gif] [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/spacer_top-links.gif] [http://www.iwpc.org/email/digest/images/spacer_top-links.gif] [Please enable images for a better experience.] Sent to:rolf.schuster at vodafone.com If you prefer not to receive future e-mails of this type, click here Sent By: IWPC 2003 S. Easton Road Doylestown Pennsylvania 18901 United States [http://www.Swiftpage5.com/images/powerdby.gif] To view as a web page click here. [http://www.Swiftpage5.com/images/Fwd2Friend.gif] -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/b98bf932/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image001.png Type: image/png Size: 3243 bytes Desc: image001.png Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151006/b98bf932/attachment-0001.png From krha at cmu.edu Tue Oct 6 16:36:33 2015 From: krha at cmu.edu (Kiryong Ha) Date: Tue, 6 Oct 2015 16:36:33 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] Descriptions for the animations at http://openedgecomputing.org/proto/ Message-ID: Hi Ashlee, I wrote descriptions for the videos at http://openedgecomputing.org/proto/ site. It's wordy, so you may want to rephrase it. Thanks. Description 1. Bringing the processing closer to the user - In mobile context, interactive as well as resource-intensive apps are emerging. e.g. Apple Siri, Google Now. - These apps are too expensive to run entirely on a mobile device, so they are usually partitioned into a front-end mobile app and a back-end server program. - And we use today's cloud like Amazon AWS to host the backend server program. - However, today cloud infrastructure is suboptimal place because of high latency and low bandwidth between a mobile device and associated cloud server. - The animation shows how Cloudlet can improve the performance of those application by bringing the cloud closer to the user 2. Discover=> Provision=> Handoff - (Nothing to add more here) 3. Live Performance Comparison - We compare the performance of fluid application which simulate liquid sloshing in a big container. Using accelerometer readings from a mobile device, it physically models the motion of imaginary fluids with which the user can interact. - The mobile app transmit accelerometer data and all compute-intensive simulation is done at the back-end server. - Here we use exactly same back-end server program but one is running at cloudlet and the other is running at Amazon West server. - The video clearly shows performance difference between two cases in terms of responsiveness. 4. Background: VM Synthesis - (I think it is too detail to show it at the front page). -- Kiryong From ashlee at openedgecomputing.org Wed Oct 7 12:51:40 2015 From: ashlee at openedgecomputing.org (Ashlee Young) Date: Wed, 7 Oct 2015 09:51:40 -0700 Subject: [oe-sync] Descriptions for the animations at http://openedgecomputing.org/proto/ In-Reply-To: References: Message-ID: <64A4BCB8-2D2E-46EC-BDA5-4F6E88324756@openedgecomputing.org> Thanks, Kiryong! > On Oct 6, 2015, at 1:36 PM, Kiryong Ha wrote: > > Hi Ashlee, > > I wrote descriptions for the videos at > http://openedgecomputing.org/proto/ site. It's wordy, so you may want > to rephrase it. Thanks. > > > Description > 1. Bringing the processing closer to the user > - In mobile context, interactive as well as resource-intensive apps > are emerging. e.g. Apple Siri, Google Now. > - These apps are too expensive to run entirely on a mobile device, so > they are usually partitioned into a front-end mobile app and a > back-end server program. > - And we use today's cloud like Amazon AWS to host the backend server program. > - However, today cloud infrastructure is suboptimal place because of > high latency and low bandwidth between a mobile device and associated > cloud server. > - The animation shows how Cloudlet can improve the performance of > those application by bringing the cloud closer to the user > > 2. Discover=> Provision=> Handoff > - (Nothing to add more here) > > 3. Live Performance Comparison > - We compare the performance of fluid application which simulate > liquid sloshing in a big container. Using accelerometer readings from > a mobile device, it physically models the motion of imaginary fluids > with which the user can interact. > - The mobile app transmit accelerometer data and all compute-intensive > simulation is done at the back-end server. > - Here we use exactly same back-end server program but one is running > at cloudlet and the other is running at Amazon West server. > - The video clearly shows performance difference between two cases in > terms of responsiveness. > > 4. Background: VM Synthesis > - (I think it is too detail to show it at the front page). > > > -- > Kiryong From Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com Fri Oct 9 09:00:56 2015 From: Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com (Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group) Date: Fri, 9 Oct 2015 13:00:56 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] FW: OpenEdgeComputing - Website Feedback In-Reply-To: <4F3238FEFDD86944891D86A900BDC7960B80A6CE@VOEXM03W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <4F3238FEFDD86944891D86A900BDC7960B80A6CE@VOEXM03W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A699761@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Hi Ashlee, all, Here some comments from me and Marco to help improve the OEC website. >From me: * I like the logo. Just great! * We need a crisp elevator pitch for the first page that explains what this website is all about, I think all agree, just need to text snippets. I'll give it a thought. * The open edge computing vision image to the right needs polishing. One of us could do.... * I wonder whether the black background is good in the area found by scrolling down. Wouldn't white work better, as the picture were all designed to work on white background? * The menu link "About OEC" currently leads to content that explains motivation, vision, technology. I wonder, whether people expect to find information about "the organisation" or "the initiative", i.e. who is part of it, why was it set up, since when in existence etc. We could have a section that explains who we are, the goals of OEC. Here some proposed bullet items: Who we are: Carnegie Mellon University pioneered early work on Cloudlets for cloud computing at the edge. Various research partners got exposure to this work. In summer 2015, a few parties joined efforts to accelerate and leverage this research under the banner of Open Edge Computing. For now these are CMU, Intel, Huawei and Vodafone. Main goals: * Leveraging Cloudlets as enabling technology. * Driving the necessary technology and technology improvements as derived from various use cases that involve low latency and computation at the edge (e.g. extensions to OpenStack, KVM, QEMU). * Driving prototyping of applications that leverage edge cloud computing, pushing the boundaries and demonstrating benefits. * Driving the eco system development for Open Edge Computing. In particular socialising the concept of Open Edge Computing and benefits with the IT and application software industry. * Engaging with target service industries/sectors through demonstrators and joint projects. * Engaging with the relevant developer communities, seeking feedback and driving acceptance of edge cloud computing. * Synchronising work with other efforts incl. ETSI ISG MEC and OPNFV. So far my bits. Below ideas + thoughts from Marco with his Picasso-style of illustration attached ;-) >From Marco: This are my thoughts on the OEC website and possible feedback to take to Ashley for its improvements. [cid:image003.jpg at 01D100FD.C4BE3260] As far As web design goes (see the sections A, B, C scribbled on top of above picture): * Spacing: o Section A could have smaller height. Navigation links on top right should be closer to A's bottom section than top of page. o Spacing in section B should be a lot smaller. This in combination with the previous point will create valuable space for information placeholders (mentioned further below). * Colour scheme should be more neutral. Using the colours of the OEC logo can be maintained for the relevant areas. I'd try: o Section A with white background o Dynamic information area should have a maximum of 2 colours (alternating). For this we can use both colours found on OEC logo. o Section C should have white background * Section C would have more space has per initial spacing recommendations: o I advise a division into 3 column sections within section C; o Social Networks links should be placed together (vertically on top of each other, see attachment for example) and on the far right; o Should include a short description about OpenEdgeComputing; o Should have a Latest News/Events (possible link to Blog or Twitter widget) feed, to be placed centrally. * Areas below the initial visible screen should be scrollable and reached through navigation on the Dynamic pane. o Should follow a business/direct language showing the value proposition for Edge Computing in a 'pitch' format: Example is attached. o Technical language/terms such as: Handoff, Offload, VM, etc should be avoided and only placed on the pages that further detail the mechanisms of Edge Computing. * Top Menu should include relevant links to: Home; About OEC; Developers; Discussion/Forums; Resources; Contact Us; * Section below C should have the relevant value proposition in non-technical terms: o An example of possible approach in terms of language and message is in the attachment. * Couldn't come up with a better key catch-phrase then: "A Cloud so close, you'll feel it's Yours." END -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151009/e7704ce8/attachment-0001.html -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image003.jpg Type: image/jpeg Size: 16724 bytes Desc: image003.jpg Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151009/e7704ce8/attachment-0001.jpg -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: OEC_Website_template.pdf Type: application/pdf Size: 196827 bytes Desc: OEC_Website_template.pdf Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151009/e7704ce8/attachment-0001.pdf From ashlee at openedgecomputing.org Fri Oct 9 09:36:03 2015 From: ashlee at openedgecomputing.org (Ashlee Young) Date: Fri, 9 Oct 2015 06:36:03 -0700 Subject: [oe-sync] FW: OpenEdgeComputing - Website Feedback In-Reply-To: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A699761@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <4F3238FEFDD86944891D86A900BDC7960B80A6CE@VOEXM03W.internal.vodafone.com> <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A699761@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: Hi Guenter and Marco, Thanks for the feedback. I will see what I can do :) With respect to the black background, the issue I ran into was that the hover text in the menu are white and I can?t seem to find where that is set. It doesn?t matter what I change in the CSS, I couldn?t get the values to change at all. I even went so far as to change ALL white values in ALL stylesheets to black and I couldn?t get the hover color to change. I then tried the same thing in the javascripts. It?s like voodoo magic or something. But I do agree with you and will take another look, perhaps see if I can get some outside help from the creator of the template. Best, Ash -Ash > On Oct 9, 2015, at 6:00 AM, Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group wrote: > > Hi Ashlee, all, > > Here some comments from me and Marco to help improve the OEC website. > From me: > ? I like the logo. Just great! > ? We need a crisp elevator pitch for the first page that explains what this website is all about, I think all agree, just need to text snippets. I?ll give it a thought. > ? The open edge computing vision image to the right needs polishing. One of us could do?. > ? I wonder whether the black background is good in the area found by scrolling down. Wouldn?t white work better, as the picture were all designed to work on white background? > ? The menu link ?About OEC? currently leads to content that explains motivation, vision, technology. I wonder, whether people expect to find information about ?the organisation? or ?the initiative?, i.e. who is part of it, why was it set up, since when in existence etc. > We could have a section that explains who we are, the goals of OEC. Here some proposed bullet items: > > Who we are: > Carnegie Mellon University pioneered early work on Cloudlets for cloud computing at the edge. Various research partners got exposure to this work. > In summer 2015, a few parties joined efforts to accelerate and leverage this research under the banner of Open Edge Computing. For now these are CMU, Intel, Huawei and Vodafone. > > Main goals: > ? Leveraging Cloudlets as enabling technology. > ? Driving the necessary technology and technology improvements as derived from various use cases that involve low latency and computation at the edge (e.g. extensions to OpenStack, KVM, QEMU). > ? Driving prototyping of applications that leverage edge cloud computing, pushing the boundaries and demonstrating benefits. > ? Driving the eco system development for Open Edge Computing. In particular socialising the concept of Open Edge Computing and benefits with the IT and application software industry. > ? Engaging with target service industries/sectors through demonstrators and joint projects. > ? Engaging with the relevant developer communities, seeking feedback and driving acceptance of edge cloud computing. > ? Synchronising work with other efforts incl. ETSI ISG MEC and OPNFV. > > So far my bits. Below ideas + thoughts from Marco with his Picasso-style of illustration attached ;-) > > From Marco: > > This are my thoughts on the OEC website and possible feedback to take to Ashley for its improvements. > > > As far As web design goes (see the sections A, B, C scribbled on top of above picture): > ? Spacing: > o Section A could have smaller height. Navigation links on top right should be closer to A?s bottom section than top of page. > o Spacing in section B should be a lot smaller. This in combination with the previous point will create valuable space for information placeholders (mentioned further below). > ? Colour scheme should be more neutral. Using the colours of the OEC logo can be maintained for the relevant areas. > I?d try: > o Section A with white background > o Dynamic information area should have a maximum of 2 colours (alternating). For this we can use both colours found on OEC logo. > o Section C should have white background > ? Section C would have more space has per initial spacing recommendations: > o I advise a division into 3 column sections within section C; > o Social Networks links should be placed together (vertically on top of each other, see attachment for example) and on the far right; > o Should include a short description about OpenEdgeComputing; > o Should have a Latest News/Events (possible link to Blog or Twitter widget) feed, to be placed centrally. > ? Areas below the initial visible screen should be scrollable and reached through navigation on the Dynamic pane. > o Should follow a business/direct language showing the value proposition for Edge Computing in a ?pitch? format: Example is attached. > o Technical language/terms such as: Handoff, Offload, VM, etc should be avoided and only placed on the pages that further detail the mechanisms of Edge Computing. > ? Top Menu should include relevant links to: Home; About OEC; Developers; Discussion/Forums; Resources; Contact Us; > ? Section below C should have the relevant value proposition in non-technical terms: > o An example of possible approach in terms of language and message is in the attachment. > ? Couldn?t come up with a better key catch-phrase then: ?A Cloud so close, you?ll feel it?s Yours.? > > END > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151009/47feb9b4/attachment-0001.html From satya at cs.cmu.edu Mon Oct 12 13:27:23 2015 From: satya at cs.cmu.edu (Mahadev Satyanarayanan) Date: Mon, 12 Oct 2015 13:27:23 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] New PoC description Message-ID: <201510121327.23418.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Hi everyone, Because of my travel to MEC, Vodafone Newbury, SOSP, etc. over the past few weeks, I have not been participating in the discussion of the draft PoC that Valerie had sent out. Late last week, I finally had a chance to read the draft PoC and some of the comments in the discussion threads. Here are my thoughts: 1. Using augmented reality (AR) as the basic application to show off the value of low latency and cloudlets is an excellent idea. Kudos to Valerie for proposing this. 2. The specific AR approach being proposed seems to require significant site customization (e.g. adding CMU-specific content, etc.). This means that it is not easily portable to another site. You will need site-specific content for the demo to be meaningful at the new site. 3. The timeline seems too aggressive. Virtually all the implementation work will be done by the CMU team, and I know in depth how is already on everyone's plate. Generating custom content takes time, even if it is already available and only has to be repackaged. Using Valerie's PoC as a starting point, I have created a description of a new PoC. In some ways this more aggressive (functionally) than the original PoC. At the same time, it is less agressive timewise and content-wise. Please review and share your comments. One clarification: I am proposing this as a PoC for the Open Edge Computing initiative. Whether this is also a PoC for MEC is something that Vodafone, Huawei and Intel should decide. I don't know if this timeline is acceptable for the MEC PoC. Also, I recall that a decision about MEC PoCs has to be made very soon. Not sure if this is already too late for consideration. If it is attractive as a MEC PoC also, then I will delighted that we can get a two-fer. Cheers -- Satya -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: cloudlet-augmented-reality-poc.pdf Type: application/pdf Size: 17543 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151012/df072152/attachment.pdf From Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com Tue Oct 13 06:32:47 2015 From: Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com (Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group) Date: Tue, 13 Oct 2015 10:32:47 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] New PoC description In-Reply-To: <201510121327.23418.satya@cs.cmu.edu> References: <201510121327.23418.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Message-ID: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A69DDF2@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Hi all, My take: if you look at the requirements section, I think that makes good sense. In order to maximise the value from a PoC, being able to show it to an audience without special device requirements and special network coverage and having portability of the PoC is mind are good points. Also, being able to compare the 2 situations (computation at edge versus fully in cloud) should help any audience to more easily understand the true benefit. Fine with those aspects. How this can fit into the ETSI MEC framework: Valerie, can you share your thoughts on this? Br Guenter -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Mahadev Satyanarayanan Sent: 12 October 2015 18:27 To: Weekly open-edge sync Subject: [oe-sync] New PoC description Hi everyone, Because of my travel to MEC, Vodafone Newbury, SOSP, etc. over the past few weeks, I have not been participating in the discussion of the draft PoC that Valerie had sent out. Late last week, I finally had a chance to read the draft PoC and some of the comments in the discussion threads. Here are my thoughts: 1. Using augmented reality (AR) as the basic application to show off the value of low latency and cloudlets is an excellent idea. Kudos to Valerie for proposing this. 2. The specific AR approach being proposed seems to require significant site customization (e.g. adding CMU-specific content, etc.). This means that it is not easily portable to another site. You will need site-specific content for the demo to be meaningful at the new site. 3. The timeline seems too aggressive. Virtually all the implementation work will be done by the CMU team, and I know in depth how is already on everyone's plate. Generating custom content takes time, even if it is already available and only has to be repackaged. Using Valerie's PoC as a starting point, I have created a description of a new PoC. In some ways this more aggressive (functionally) than the original PoC. At the same time, it is less agressive timewise and content-wise. Please review and share your comments. One clarification: I am proposing this as a PoC for the Open Edge Computing initiative. Whether this is also a PoC for MEC is something that Vodafone, Huawei and Intel should decide. I don't know if this timeline is acceptable for the MEC PoC. Also, I recall that a decision about MEC PoCs has to be made very soon. Not sure if this is already too late for consideration. If it is attractive as a MEC PoC also, then I will delighted that we can get a two-fer. Cheers -- Satya From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Tue Oct 13 08:37:34 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Tue, 13 Oct 2015 12:37:34 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] New PoC description In-Reply-To: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A69DDF2@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <201510121327.23418.satya@cs.cmu.edu> <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A69DDF2@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890321490@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> I am fine with the PoC proposal. The key thing for me is to demonstrate the improvement of customer experience through Edge Computing live - rather that with videos. And be able to compare it directly with a backend cloud solution. Also it is good that we can have multiple instances of the demo and show it at fairs, conferences and meeting rooms anywhere on the planet... Yes, the timeline is quite long, however, I guess Satya has to squeeze that into the schedule of his students... @Valerie, Yun Chao and Adrian, are you still able to bring that PoC proposal on the MEC PoC list? Just as another channel to market? This would be great! All the best Rolf. -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+rolf.schuster=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+rolf.schuster=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 13. Oktober 2015 12:33 To: Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Weekly open-edge sync Subject: Re: [oe-sync] New PoC description Hi all, My take: if you look at the requirements section, I think that makes good sense. In order to maximise the value from a PoC, being able to show it to an audience without special device requirements and special network coverage and having portability of the PoC is mind are good points. Also, being able to compare the 2 situations (computation at edge versus fully in cloud) should help any audience to more easily understand the true benefit. Fine with those aspects. How this can fit into the ETSI MEC framework: Valerie, can you share your thoughts on this? Br Guenter -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Mahadev Satyanarayanan Sent: 12 October 2015 18:27 To: Weekly open-edge sync Subject: [oe-sync] New PoC description Hi everyone, Because of my travel to MEC, Vodafone Newbury, SOSP, etc. over the past few weeks, I have not been participating in the discussion of the draft PoC that Valerie had sent out. Late last week, I finally had a chance to read the draft PoC and some of the comments in the discussion threads. Here are my thoughts: 1. Using augmented reality (AR) as the basic application to show off the value of low latency and cloudlets is an excellent idea. Kudos to Valerie for proposing this. 2. The specific AR approach being proposed seems to require significant site customization (e.g. adding CMU-specific content, etc.). This means that it is not easily portable to another site. You will need site-specific content for the demo to be meaningful at the new site. 3. The timeline seems too aggressive. Virtually all the implementation work will be done by the CMU team, and I know in depth how is already on everyone's plate. Generating custom content takes time, even if it is already available and only has to be repackaged. Using Valerie's PoC as a starting point, I have created a description of a new PoC. In some ways this more aggressive (functionally) than the original PoC. At the same time, it is less agressive timewise and content-wise. Please review and share your comments. One clarification: I am proposing this as a PoC for the Open Edge Computing initiative. Whether this is also a PoC for MEC is something that Vodafone, Huawei and Intel should decide. I don't know if this timeline is acceptable for the MEC PoC. Also, I recall that a decision about MEC PoCs has to be made very soon. Not sure if this is already too late for consideration. If it is attractive as a MEC PoC also, then I will delighted that we can get a two-fer. Cheers -- Satya _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: cloudlet-augmented-reality-poc final.pdf Type: application/pdf Size: 17625 bytes Desc: cloudlet-augmented-reality-poc final.pdf Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151013/01cab648/attachment-0001.pdf From valerie.j.young at intel.com Tue Oct 13 11:19:37 2015 From: valerie.j.young at intel.com (Young, Valerie J) Date: Tue, 13 Oct 2015 15:19:37 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] New PoC description In-Reply-To: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890321490@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <201510121327.23418.satya@cs.cmu.edu> <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A69DDF2@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890321490@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <96EFD7465592EA4A9CCEAAB849F4DFF6A7619BC1@ORSMSX105.amr.corp.intel.com> This is great work, folks. The proposal is a great proposal, however, it needs a strong tie into or relative to MEC, for the MEC community to be interested. We also have to utilize the PoC template (Word doc) for the MEC proposal as per the standard. It would be helpful to share the word version of the doc, and I can cut and paste to have a revised PoC version. >From MEC perspective, the computer vision software needs to have the MEC server at the edge of the network and this is how we should articulate the tie to MEC, correct? MEC hardware is available (standard server) with virtualized environment and the routing for the individual consumer's cloudlet is available in the NEV Sdk. Thus once the consumer requests the app, the consumer request will get routed. Perhaps I am missing something with cloudlets. However, from the above perspective, the work that would need to be done is the work already being done by the CMU team, except for the augmented reality app Satya is describing, which I was hoping his students were already implementing. :) For MEC, Openstack is a framework for management. The cloudlet utilizes openstack and rest api's to get deployed on the MEC server. This is my understanding, am I missing something here as I am not involved in the technical discussions? Because MEC is becoming a standard for edge computing, my assumption is we would want cloudlets to influence the MEC standard, so cloudlets are part of the standard, correct? Should we have a meeting to discuss? Thanks, Best regards, valerie -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Tuesday, October 13, 2015 5:38 AM To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group ; Mahadev Satyanarayanan ; Weekly open-edge sync ; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group Subject: Re: [oe-sync] New PoC description I am fine with the PoC proposal. The key thing for me is to demonstrate the improvement of customer experience through Edge Computing live - rather that with videos. And be able to compare it directly with a backend cloud solution. Also it is good that we can have multiple instances of the demo and show it at fairs, conferences and meeting rooms anywhere on the planet... Yes, the timeline is quite long, however, I guess Satya has to squeeze that into the schedule of his students... @Valerie, Yun Chao and Adrian, are you still able to bring that PoC proposal on the MEC PoC list? Just as another channel to market? This would be great! All the best Rolf. -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+rolf.schuster=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+rolf.schuster=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 13. Oktober 2015 12:33 To: Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Weekly open-edge sync Subject: Re: [oe-sync] New PoC description Hi all, My take: if you look at the requirements section, I think that makes good sense. In order to maximise the value from a PoC, being able to show it to an audience without special device requirements and special network coverage and having portability of the PoC is mind are good points. Also, being able to compare the 2 situations (computation at edge versus fully in cloud) should help any audience to more easily understand the true benefit. Fine with those aspects. How this can fit into the ETSI MEC framework: Valerie, can you share your thoughts on this? Br Guenter -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Mahadev Satyanarayanan Sent: 12 October 2015 18:27 To: Weekly open-edge sync Subject: [oe-sync] New PoC description Hi everyone, Because of my travel to MEC, Vodafone Newbury, SOSP, etc. over the past few weeks, I have not been participating in the discussion of the draft PoC that Valerie had sent out. Late last week, I finally had a chance to read the draft PoC and some of the comments in the discussion threads. Here are my thoughts: 1. Using augmented reality (AR) as the basic application to show off the value of low latency and cloudlets is an excellent idea. Kudos to Valerie for proposing this. 2. The specific AR approach being proposed seems to require significant site customization (e.g. adding CMU-specific content, etc.). This means that it is not easily portable to another site. You will need site-specific content for the demo to be meaningful at the new site. 3. The timeline seems too aggressive. Virtually all the implementation work will be done by the CMU team, and I know in depth how is already on everyone's plate. Generating custom content takes time, even if it is already available and only has to be repackaged. Using Valerie's PoC as a starting point, I have created a description of a new PoC. In some ways this more aggressive (functionally) than the original PoC. At the same time, it is less agressive timewise and content-wise. Please review and share your comments. One clarification: I am proposing this as a PoC for the Open Edge Computing initiative. Whether this is also a PoC for MEC is something that Vodafone, Huawei and Intel should decide. I don't know if this timeline is acceptable for the MEC PoC. Also, I recall that a decision about MEC PoCs has to be made very soon. Not sure if this is already too late for consideration. If it is attractive as a MEC PoC also, then I will delighted that we can get a two-fer. Cheers -- Satya _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync From satya at cs.cmu.edu Tue Oct 13 11:36:11 2015 From: satya at cs.cmu.edu (Mahadev Satyanarayanan) Date: Tue, 13 Oct 2015 11:36:11 -0400 Subject: [oe-sync] New PoC description In-Reply-To: <96EFD7465592EA4A9CCEAAB849F4DFF6A7619BC1@ORSMSX105.amr.corp.intel.com> References: <201510121327.23418.satya@cs.cmu.edu> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890321490@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <96EFD7465592EA4A9CCEAAB849F4DFF6A7619BC1@ORSMSX105.amr.corp.intel.com> Message-ID: <201510131136.11594.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Hi Valerie, Here is the Word version. -- Satya On Tuesday 13 October 2015 11:19:37 Young, Valerie J wrote: > This is great work, folks. The proposal is a great proposal, however, it needs a strong tie into or relative to MEC, for the MEC community to be interested. We also have to utilize the PoC template (Word doc) for the MEC proposal as per the standard. It would be helpful to share the word version of the doc, and I can cut and paste to have a revised PoC version. > > >From MEC perspective, the computer vision software needs to have the MEC server at the edge of the network and this is how we should articulate the tie to MEC, correct? MEC hardware is available (standard server) with virtualized environment and the routing for the individual consumer's cloudlet is available in the NEV Sdk. Thus once the consumer requests the app, the consumer request will get routed. Perhaps I am missing something with cloudlets. However, from the above perspective, the work that would need to be done is the work already being done by the CMU team, except for the augmented reality app Satya is describing, which I was hoping his students were already implementing. :) > > For MEC, Openstack is a framework for management. The cloudlet utilizes openstack and rest api's to get deployed on the MEC server. This is my understanding, am I missing something here as I am not involved in the technical discussions? > > Because MEC is becoming a standard for edge computing, my assumption is we would want cloudlets to influence the MEC standard, so cloudlets are part of the standard, correct? > > Should we have a meeting to discuss? > > Thanks, > Best regards, > valerie > > > > -----Original Message----- > From: oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Tuesday, October 13, 2015 5:38 AM > To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group ; Mahadev Satyanarayanan ; Weekly open-edge sync ; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] New PoC description > > I am fine with the PoC proposal. The key thing for me is to demonstrate the improvement of customer experience through Edge Computing live - rather that with videos. And be able to compare it directly with a backend cloud solution. Also it is good that we can have multiple instances of the demo and show it at fairs, conferences and meeting rooms anywhere on the planet... > > Yes, the timeline is quite long, however, I guess Satya has to squeeze that into the schedule of his students... > > @Valerie, Yun Chao and Adrian, are you still able to bring that PoC proposal on the MEC PoC list? Just as another channel to market? This would be great! > > All the best > Rolf. > > -----Original Message----- > From: oe-sync-bounces+rolf.schuster=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+rolf.schuster=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group > Sent: Dienstag, 13. Oktober 2015 12:33 > To: Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Weekly open-edge sync > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] New PoC description > > Hi all, > > My take: if you look at the requirements section, I think that makes good sense. In order to maximise the value from a PoC, being able to show it to an audience without special device requirements and special network coverage and having portability of the PoC is mind are good points. Also, being able to compare the 2 situations (computation at edge versus fully in cloud) should help any audience to more easily understand the true benefit. Fine with those aspects. > How this can fit into the ETSI MEC framework: Valerie, can you share your thoughts on this? > Br > Guenter > > -----Original Message----- > From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Mahadev Satyanarayanan > Sent: 12 October 2015 18:27 > To: Weekly open-edge sync > Subject: [oe-sync] New PoC description > > Hi everyone, > Because of my travel to MEC, Vodafone Newbury, SOSP, etc. over the past few weeks, I have not been participating in the discussion of the draft > PoC that Valerie had sent out. Late last week, I finally had a chance > to read the draft PoC and some of the comments in the discussion > threads. Here are my thoughts: > > 1. Using augmented reality (AR) as the basic application to show off the value of low latency and cloudlets is an excellent idea. Kudos to Valerie > for proposing this. > > 2. The specific AR approach being proposed seems to require significant > site customization (e.g. adding CMU-specific content, etc.). This means > that it is not easily portable to another site. You will need site-specific content for the demo to be meaningful at the new site. > > 3. The timeline seems too aggressive. Virtually all the implementation > work will be done by the CMU team, and I know in depth how is already > on everyone's plate. Generating custom content takes time, even if it > is already available and only has to be repackaged. > > Using Valerie's PoC as a starting point, I have created a description of a > new PoC. In some ways this more aggressive (functionally) than the > original PoC. At the same time, it is less agressive timewise and content-wise. > > Please review and share your comments. One clarification: I am proposing > this as a PoC for the Open Edge Computing initiative. Whether this is also > a PoC for MEC is something that Vodafone, Huawei and Intel should decide. > I don't know if this timeline is acceptable for the MEC PoC. Also, I recall that a decision about MEC PoCs has to be made very soon. Not sure > if this is already too late for consideration. If it is attractive as a MEC PoC > also, then I will delighted that we can get a two-fer. > > Cheers > -- Satya > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync > -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: cloudlet-augmented-reality-poc.doc Type: application/msword Size: 39424 bytes Desc: not available Url : http://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/pipermail/oe-sync/attachments/20151013/ae356d64/attachment-0001.doc From valerie.j.young at intel.com Tue Oct 13 12:13:26 2015 From: valerie.j.young at intel.com (Young, Valerie J) Date: Tue, 13 Oct 2015 16:13:26 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] New PoC description In-Reply-To: <201510131136.11594.satya@cs.cmu.edu> References: <201510121327.23418.satya@cs.cmu.edu> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890321490@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <96EFD7465592EA4A9CCEAAB849F4DFF6A7619BC1@ORSMSX105.amr.corp.intel.com> <201510131136.11594.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Message-ID: <96EFD7465592EA4A9CCEAAB849F4DFF6A7619E9F@ORSMSX105.amr.corp.intel.com> Excellent. Thanks, I will modify poc proposal and send out. Thank you very much! -----Original Message----- From: Mahadev Satyanarayanan [mailto:satya at cs.cmu.edu] Sent: Tuesday, October 13, 2015 8:36 AM To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: Young, Valerie J ; Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group ; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group ; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group Subject: Re: [oe-sync] New PoC description Hi Valerie, Here is the Word version. -- Satya On Tuesday 13 October 2015 11:19:37 Young, Valerie J wrote: > This is great work, folks. The proposal is a great proposal, however, it needs a strong tie into or relative to MEC, for the MEC community to be interested. We also have to utilize the PoC template (Word doc) for the MEC proposal as per the standard. It would be helpful to share the word version of the doc, and I can cut and paste to have a revised PoC version. > > >From MEC perspective, the computer vision software needs to have the MEC server at the edge of the network and this is how we should articulate the tie to MEC, correct? MEC hardware is available (standard server) with virtualized environment and the routing for the individual consumer's cloudlet is available in the NEV Sdk. Thus once the consumer requests the app, the consumer request will get routed. Perhaps I am missing something with cloudlets. However, from the above perspective, the work that would need to be done is the work already being done by the CMU team, except for the augmented reality app Satya is describing, which I was hoping his students were already implementing. :) > > For MEC, Openstack is a framework for management. The cloudlet utilizes openstack and rest api's to get deployed on the MEC server. This is my understanding, am I missing something here as I am not involved in the technical discussions? > > Because MEC is becoming a standard for edge computing, my assumption is we would want cloudlets to influence the MEC standard, so cloudlets are part of the standard, correct? > > Should we have a meeting to discuss? > > Thanks, > Best regards, > valerie > > > > -----Original Message----- > From: oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Tuesday, October 13, 2015 5:38 AM > To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group ; Mahadev Satyanarayanan ; Weekly open-edge sync ; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] New PoC description > > I am fine with the PoC proposal. The key thing for me is to demonstrate the improvement of customer experience through Edge Computing live - rather that with videos. And be able to compare it directly with a backend cloud solution. Also it is good that we can have multiple instances of the demo and show it at fairs, conferences and meeting rooms anywhere on the planet... > > Yes, the timeline is quite long, however, I guess Satya has to squeeze that into the schedule of his students... > > @Valerie, Yun Chao and Adrian, are you still able to bring that PoC proposal on the MEC PoC list? Just as another channel to market? This would be great! > > All the best > Rolf. > > -----Original Message----- > From: oe-sync-bounces+rolf.schuster=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+rolf.schuster=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group > Sent: Dienstag, 13. Oktober 2015 12:33 > To: Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Weekly open-edge sync > Subject: Re: [oe-sync] New PoC description > > Hi all, > > My take: if you look at the requirements section, I think that makes good sense. In order to maximise the value from a PoC, being able to show it to an audience without special device requirements and special network coverage and having portability of the PoC is mind are good points. Also, being able to compare the 2 situations (computation at edge versus fully in cloud) should help any audience to more easily understand the true benefit. Fine with those aspects. > How this can fit into the ETSI MEC framework: Valerie, can you share your thoughts on this? > Br > Guenter > > -----Original Message----- > From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Mahadev Satyanarayanan > Sent: 12 October 2015 18:27 > To: Weekly open-edge sync > Subject: [oe-sync] New PoC description > > Hi everyone, > Because of my travel to MEC, Vodafone Newbury, SOSP, etc. over the past few weeks, I have not been participating in the discussion of the draft > PoC that Valerie had sent out. Late last week, I finally had a chance > to read the draft PoC and some of the comments in the discussion > threads. Here are my thoughts: > > 1. Using augmented reality (AR) as the basic application to show off the value of low latency and cloudlets is an excellent idea. Kudos to Valerie > for proposing this. > > 2. The specific AR approach being proposed seems to require significant > site customization (e.g. adding CMU-specific content, etc.). This means > that it is not easily portable to another site. You will need site-specific content for the demo to be meaningful at the new site. > > 3. The timeline seems too aggressive. Virtually all the implementation > work will be done by the CMU team, and I know in depth how is already > on everyone's plate. Generating custom content takes time, even if it > is already available and only has to be repackaged. > > Using Valerie's PoC as a starting point, I have created a description of a > new PoC. In some ways this more aggressive (functionally) than the > original PoC. At the same time, it is less agressive timewise and content-wise. > > Please review and share your comments. One clarification: I am proposing > this as a PoC for the Open Edge Computing initiative. Whether this is also > a PoC for MEC is something that Vodafone, Huawei and Intel should decide. > I don't know if this timeline is acceptable for the MEC PoC. Also, I recall that a decision about MEC PoCs has to be made very soon. Not sure > if this is already too late for consideration. If it is attractive as a MEC PoC > also, then I will delighted that we can get a two-fer. > > Cheers > -- Satya > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync > From Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com Tue Oct 13 14:05:39 2015 From: Prakash.Ramchandran at huawei.com (Prakash Ramchandran) Date: Tue, 13 Oct 2015 18:05:39 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] New PoC description In-Reply-To: <96EFD7465592EA4A9CCEAAB849F4DFF6A7619BC1@ORSMSX105.amr.corp.intel.com> References: <201510121327.23418.satya@cs.cmu.edu> <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A69DDF2@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890321490@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> <96EFD7465592EA4A9CCEAAB849F4DFF6A7619BC1@ORSMSX105.amr.corp.intel.com> Message-ID: <9EEDA58530A1BE4B882CE7556620A5FB08972496@SJCEML701-CHM.china.huawei.com> My inputs to the PoC proposal... I have noted few things and working on it still to get some clarity...refer Note1,2,3, 4 below... Thanks Prakash Prakash Ramchandran R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchandran at huawei.com Work:? +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+prakash.ramchandran=huawei.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Young, Valerie J Sent: Tuesday, October 13, 2015 8:20 AM To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Weekly open-edge sync; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group Subject: Re: [oe-sync] New PoC description This is great work, folks. The proposal is a great proposal, however, it needs a strong tie into or relative to MEC, for the MEC community to be interested. We also have to utilize the PoC template (Word doc) for the MEC proposal as per the standard. It would be helpful to share the word version of the doc, and I can cut and paste to have a revised PoC version. >From MEC perspective, the computer vision software needs to have the MEC server at the edge of the network and this is how we should articulate the tie to MEC, correct? MEC hardware is available (standard server) with virtualized environment and the routing for the individual consumer's cloudlet is available in the NEV Sdk. Thus once the consumer requests the app, the consumer request will get routed. Perhaps I am missing something with cloudlets. However, from the above perspective, the work that would need to be done is the work already being done by the CMU team, except for the augmented reality app Satya is describing, which I was hoping his students were already implementing. :) Note 1.I see several software for Computer Vision but where is Gabriel Image Stack is that an image library or a Computer Vision Software library? http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~cil/v-source.html Note 2.I have asked for a copy of NEV SDK from Intel to evaluate what it does at Edge to qualify for use with MEC server and how it will work with the Cloudlet API at had based on OpenStack. For MEC, Openstack is a framework for management. The cloudlet utilizes openstack and rest api's to get deployed on the MEC server. This is my understanding, am I missing something here as I am not involved in the technical discussions? Note 3.Once we evaluate the above Questions we will know how these Platform APIs can co-exist with CLoudlet API. Because MEC is becoming a standard for edge computing, my assumption is we would want cloudlets to influence the MEC standard, so cloudlets are part of the standard, correct? Note 4. Once we have some more clarity we will answer that. Should we have a meeting to discuss? Thanks, Best regards, valerie -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+valerie.j.young=intel.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Tuesday, October 13, 2015 5:38 AM To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group ; Mahadev Satyanarayanan ; Weekly open-edge sync ; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group Subject: Re: [oe-sync] New PoC description I am fine with the PoC proposal. The key thing for me is to demonstrate the improvement of customer experience through Edge Computing live - rather that with videos. And be able to compare it directly with a backend cloud solution. Also it is good that we can have multiple instances of the demo and show it at fairs, conferences and meeting rooms anywhere on the planet... Yes, the timeline is quite long, however, I guess Satya has to squeeze that into the schedule of his students... @Valerie, Yun Chao and Adrian, are you still able to bring that PoC proposal on the MEC PoC list? Just as another channel to market? This would be great! All the best Rolf. -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+rolf.schuster=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+rolf.schuster=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 13. Oktober 2015 12:33 To: Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Weekly open-edge sync Subject: Re: [oe-sync] New PoC description Hi all, My take: if you look at the requirements section, I think that makes good sense. In order to maximise the value from a PoC, being able to show it to an audience without special device requirements and special network coverage and having portability of the PoC is mind are good points. Also, being able to compare the 2 situations (computation at edge versus fully in cloud) should help any audience to more easily understand the true benefit. Fine with those aspects. How this can fit into the ETSI MEC framework: Valerie, can you share your thoughts on this? Br Guenter -----Original Message----- From: oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Mahadev Satyanarayanan Sent: 12 October 2015 18:27 To: Weekly open-edge sync Subject: [oe-sync] New PoC description Hi everyone, Because of my travel to MEC, Vodafone Newbury, SOSP, etc. over the past few weeks, I have not been participating in the discussion of the draft PoC that Valerie had sent out. Late last week, I finally had a chance to read the draft PoC and some of the comments in the discussion threads. Here are my thoughts: 1. Using augmented reality (AR) as the basic application to show off the value of low latency and cloudlets is an excellent idea. Kudos to Valerie for proposing this. 2. The specific AR approach being proposed seems to require significant site customization (e.g. adding CMU-specific content, etc.). This means that it is not easily portable to another site. You will need site-specific content for the demo to be meaningful at the new site. 3. The timeline seems too aggressive. Virtually all the implementation work will be done by the CMU team, and I know in depth how is already on everyone's plate. Generating custom content takes time, even if it is already available and only has to be repackaged. Using Valerie's PoC as a starting point, I have created a description of a new PoC. In some ways this more aggressive (functionally) than the original PoC. At the same time, it is less agressive timewise and content-wise. Please review and share your comments. One clarification: I am proposing this as a PoC for the Open Edge Computing initiative. Whether this is also a PoC for MEC is something that Vodafone, Huawei and Intel should decide. I don't know if this timeline is acceptable for the MEC PoC. Also, I recall that a decision about MEC PoCs has to be made very soon. Not sure if this is already too late for consideration. If it is attractive as a MEC PoC also, then I will delighted that we can get a two-fer. Cheers -- Satya _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync _______________________________________________ oe-sync mailing list oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Tue Nov 3 17:27:39 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Tue, 3 Nov 2015 22:27:39 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Deck for IWPC IoT & Automotive Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890362DA2@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, As discussed, I uploaded my slides for the IWPC IoT & Automotive conference next week to our cloud server. Please find the link below. The name of the file is "2015-11-11 Open Edge Computing - IWPC Conference IoT Automotive .pptx" Comments welcome... @Wenlu, I added our windscreen augmented reality use case. Let?s see what feedback we get. Kind regards Rolf. https://owncloud.cmusatyalab.org/owncloud/public.php?service=files&t=558bd32044fd2546fcf54b155d1b68d6 [http://www.vodafone.com/content/dam/global_email_signature/sigroundel.png] Rolf Schuster Head of Partner Innovation Centres Architecture & Research Vodafone Group Services GmbH Mobile: +491722360098 Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff vodafone.com This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Wed Nov 11 09:29:12 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Wed, 11 Nov 2015 14:29:12 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call tomorrow Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890372ADF@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, Just as a gentle reminder, we will hold our bi-weekly progress call tomorrow. May I assume that you can all join that call? We have to agree on the way forward after all the events and changes... Here are some of the topics we will address: - Technical Program update including QEMU, network issue (Kiryong) - Own OpenStack Cloudlet Module - resources (including Vedams), work plan and next steps (Prakash, Kiryong) - Outreach Program update (Rolf, Satya) - Web page etc. (all) Yun-Chao, Prakash and Ashlee, will you be able to join - in spite of the OPNFV Summit? We can try to cover the topics relevant for you within the first hour? Kind regards Rolf. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 15. Oktober 2015 11:58 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Dear all, Below please find the action items from our last call we will go through during our call later on today. Here are some of the topics we will address: - PoC Attached, please find the PoC document Satya has put together and Valerie is trying to position within the MEC PoC framework this week. - Blueprint @Prakash / Kiryong / Ashlee, could you please share the link to the blueprint? May I assume that has been finalised by now (due until 11 Oct)? Should we sync that with other friendly Openstack experts? - Test plan Does it make sense to address that? As we make this more widely available it would be good to see the test results. - Web page @Yun Chao, Valerie and Adrian, as you are the the MEC F2F meeting, are you going to be able to join the progress call today at 16:00 CEST? Looking forward to talk to you. Kind regards Rolf. __________________________________________________________ Action Items from 6 October: 1. (Prakash, until 15 Oct) push for OEC code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit. 2. (Prakash supported by Valerie, Guenter, Kiryong, 9 Oct) Prakash to organise this week to finalise the MEC PoC proposal to be submitted at the MEC meeting next week. Valerie to send material on Intel technology that may be used for the PoC. 3. (Kiryong, until ?) Describe rational behind QEMU modifications. Upgrade QEMU-modifications to current QEMU version. 4. (Yun-Chao, Guenter until Nov) continue to liaise with GSMA and monitor their task force work on edge computing. 5. (Rolf, Guenter until Nov) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 6. (all, until 15 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 7. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 11 Oct) Finalise the blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 11 Oct. Prakash to organise a call on that matter this week. 8. (all, 15 Oct) send key material, text snippets for the OEC web page to Ashley. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 6. Oktober 2015 11:40 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Dear all, Thanks for the constructive discussion yesterday. Please find the action items from the call below. Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from 6 October: 1. (Prakash, until 15 Oct) push for OEC code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit. 2. (Prakash supported by Valerie, Guenter, Kiryong, 9 Oct) Prakash to organise this week to finalise the MEC PoC proposal to be submitted at the MEC meeting next week. Valerie to send material on Intel technology that may be used for the PoC. 3. (Kiryong, until ?) Describe rational behind QEMU modifications. Upgrade QEMU-modifications to current QEMU version. 4. (Yun-Chao, Guenter until Nov) continue to liaise with GSMA and monitor their task force work on edge computing. 5. (Rolf, Guenter until Nov) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 6. (all, until 15 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 7. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 11 Oct) Finalise the blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 11 Oct. Prakash to organise a call on that matter this week. 8. (all, 15 Oct) send key material, text snippets for the OEC web page to Ashley. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Montag, 5. Oktober 2015 12:18 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Dear all, Today we will have a shortened progress call in the beginning of the weekly call of the technical team. Hence, we will just address a few matters: - Action items from last call (see below and attachment for details) - Brief summary of MEC Congress in London last week - Status and next steps regarding Nova Blueprint Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from 17 September: 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 25 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit 2. (Ashlee, until 25 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) 3. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 17 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie will send a draft of a OEC PoC proposal document the group. Satya and Kiryong support that process. Perhaps first E2E demo at Mobile World Congress in Barcelon 2016? 4. (Kiryong, until 23 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student 5. (Yun-Chao, until 25 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting? Check with Guenter if he is there as well. 6. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 7. (all, until 1 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 8. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 21 Sept) Finalise the draft blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 21 Sept. Ashlee & Prakash to send examples of "good" blueprints to Kiryong, Rolf and Satya asap. 9. (Ashlee, 21 Sept) send two final logo versions, prepare an early version of the webpage to be reviewed in Technical Program Call on Monday 21 Sept. << File: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call with actions.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 17. September 2015 10:45 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week --> Call NOT cancelled TODAY Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call later on today - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure Some of you might have received cancellation messages. This is just because I have updated the invite with the latest oec-sync list to ensure that Ashlee is also invited ;-) Also, I updated the meeting number as proposed by Chase. I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 3. September 2015 18:23 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Thanks for the constructive call today. Here are the action items. I uploaded the meeting slides as well as the Open Edge Computing Overview slides to our file repository (link again below). @Ashlee, are you receiving these mails by now? Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from Progress call 3rd September 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 14 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack summit AND OPNFV Summit 2. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) 3. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 17 Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 4. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 4 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 5. (Kiriong, until 5 Sept) Meeting with Vedams on Monday, 7 September, Meeting on OpenStack roadmap on Monday, 14 September (with Yun-Chao) 6. (Kiryong, until 5 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student 7. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) License discussion for Open Edge Initiative --> at Technical Program Call on 14 Sept? 8. (Yun-Chao, until 17 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting 9. (Yun-Chao and Rolf, 14 Sept) put together a proposal for membership structure + web-site + new partner outreach 10. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 11. Info: Cloudlet Class applicatin demonstration session on 1 December 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All welcome! Link to repository: https://owncloud.cmusatyalab.org/owncloud/public.php?service=files&t=c9f5bf1c36948d874459dea2fa50e57a _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 2. September 2015 21:50 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-09-03 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 1. September 2015 22:54 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and - please have a look at the action items below from our last call and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. Kind regards Rolf. Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 21. August 2015 16:38 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions... Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. Many thanks Rolf. << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx >> Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. - Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) --> DONE 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. Ideas: address verticals. 'Crowdsourcing' the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. --> Draft deck to be distributed 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. --> Has that happened? 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. 7. All: 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug - end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal --> Proposal from Satya under way... _____________________________________________ From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 Importance: High Hi there, Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well - We went through all agenda points - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. Any questions, please let me know. Best regards Guenter << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. Rolf. ______________________________ Dear all, As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas - Outreach Program Progress - Technical Program Progress - MEC Requirement Progress and go through the attached action item list. Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. Kind regards Rolf. Email from last meeting << Attachments: Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) >> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From yunchao.hu at huawei.com Wed Nov 11 13:00:44 2015 From: yunchao.hu at huawei.com (yunchao hu) Date: Wed, 11 Nov 2015 18:00:44 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call tomorrow In-Reply-To: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890372ADF@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890372ADF@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: Hi all, I will be able to attend. Yun Chao Sent from my iPhone On 11 nov. 2015, at 06:30, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group via oe-sync > wrote: Dear all, Just as a gentle reminder, we will hold our bi-weekly progress call tomorrow. May I assume that you can all join that call? We have to agree on the way forward after all the events and changes? Here are some of the topics we will address: - Technical Program update including QEMU, network issue (Kiryong) - Own OpenStack Cloudlet Module ? resources (including Vedams), work plan and next steps (Prakash, Kiryong) - Outreach Program update (Rolf, Satya) - Web page etc. (all) Yun-Chao, Prakash and Ashlee, will you be able to join ? in spite of the OPNFV Summit? We can try to cover the topics relevant for you within the first hour? Kind regards Rolf. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 15. Oktober 2015 11:58 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Dear all, Below please find the action items from our last call we will go through during our call later on today. Here are some of the topics we will address: - PoC Attached, please find the PoC document Satya has put together and Valerie is trying to position within the MEC PoC framework this week. - Blueprint @Prakash / Kiryong / Ashlee, could you please share the link to the blueprint? May I assume that has been finalised by now (due until 11 Oct)? Should we sync that with other friendly Openstack experts? - Test plan Does it make sense to address that? As we make this more widely available it would be good to see the test results. - Web page @Yun Chao, Valerie and Adrian, as you are the the MEC F2F meeting, are you going to be able to join the progress call today at 16:00 CEST? Looking forward to talk to you. Kind regards Rolf. __________________________________________________________ Action Items from 6 October: 1. (Prakash, until 15 Oct) push for OEC code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit. 2. (Prakash supported by Valerie, Guenter, Kiryong, 9 Oct) Prakash to organise this week to finalise the MEC PoC proposal to be submitted at the MEC meeting next week. Valerie to send material on Intel technology that may be used for the PoC. 3. (Kiryong, until ?) Describe rational behind QEMU modifications. Upgrade QEMU-modifications to current QEMU version. 4. (Yun-Chao, Guenter until Nov) continue to liaise with GSMA and monitor their task force work on edge computing. 5. (Rolf, Guenter until Nov) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 6. (all, until 15 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 7. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 11 Oct) Finalise the blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 11 Oct. Prakash to organise a call on that matter this week. 8. (all, 15 Oct) send key material, text snippets for the OEC web page to Ashley. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 6. Oktober 2015 11:40 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Dear all, Thanks for the constructive discussion yesterday. Please find the action items from the call below. Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from 6 October: 1. (Prakash, until 15 Oct) push for OEC code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit. 2. (Prakash supported by Valerie, Guenter, Kiryong, 9 Oct) Prakash to organise this week to finalise the MEC PoC proposal to be submitted at the MEC meeting next week. Valerie to send material on Intel technology that may be used for the PoC. 3. (Kiryong, until ?) Describe rational behind QEMU modifications. Upgrade QEMU-modifications to current QEMU version. 4. (Yun-Chao, Guenter until Nov) continue to liaise with GSMA and monitor their task force work on edge computing. 5. (Rolf, Guenter until Nov) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 6. (all, until 15 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 7. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 11 Oct) Finalise the blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 11 Oct. Prakash to organise a call on that matter this week. 8. (all, 15 Oct) send key material, text snippets for the OEC web page to Ashley. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Montag, 5. Oktober 2015 12:18 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Dear all, Today we will have a shortened progress call in the beginning of the weekly call of the technical team. Hence, we will just address a few matters: - Action items from last call (see below and attachment for details) - Brief summary of MEC Congress in London last week - Status and next steps regarding Nova Blueprint Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from 17 September: 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 25 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit 2. (Ashlee, until 25 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) 3. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 17 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie will send a draft of a OEC PoC proposal document the group. Satya and Kiryong support that process. Perhaps first E2E demo at Mobile World Congress in Barcelon 2016? 4. (Kiryong, until 23 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student 5. (Yun-Chao, until 25 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting? Check with Guenter if he is there as well. 6. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 7. (all, until 1 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 8. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 21 Sept) Finalise the draft blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 21 Sept. Ashlee & Prakash to send examples of ?good? blueprints to Kiryong, Rolf and Satya asap. 9. (Ashlee, 21 Sept) send two final logo versions, prepare an early version of the webpage to be reviewed in Technical Program Call on Monday 21 Sept. << File: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call with actions.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 17. September 2015 10:45 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week --> Call NOT cancelled TODAY Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call later on today - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure Some of you might have received cancellation messages. This is just because I have updated the invite with the latest oec-sync list to ensure that Ashlee is also invited ;-) Also, I updated the meeting number as proposed by Chase. I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 3. September 2015 18:23 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Thanks for the constructive call today. Here are the action items. I uploaded the meeting slides as well as the Open Edge Computing Overview slides to our file repository (link again below). @Ashlee, are you receiving these mails by now? Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from Progress call 3rd September 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 14 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack summit AND OPNFV Summit 2. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) 3. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 17 Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 4. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 4 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 5. (Kiriong, until 5 Sept) Meeting with Vedams on Monday, 7 September, Meeting on OpenStack roadmap on Monday, 14 September (with Yun-Chao) 6. (Kiryong, until 5 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student 7. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) License discussion for Open Edge Initiative --> at Technical Program Call on 14 Sept? 8. (Yun-Chao, until 17 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting 9. (Yun-Chao and Rolf, 14 Sept) put together a proposal for membership structure + web-site + new partner outreach 10. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 11. Info: Cloudlet Class applicatin demonstration session on 1 December 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All welcome! Link to repository: https://owncloud.cmusatyalab.org/owncloud/public.php?service=files&t=c9f5bf1c36948d874459dea2fa50e57a _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 2. September 2015 21:50 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-09-03 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 1. September 2015 22:54 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, * please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and * please have a look at the action items below from our last call and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. Kind regards Rolf. Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing * (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. * (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. * (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 1. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 2. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 3. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 4. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 21. August 2015 16:38 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions? Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. Many thanks Rolf. << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx >> Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing * (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. * (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. * (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 1. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 2. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 3. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 4. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, * please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. * Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) --> DONE 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. Ideas: address verticals. ?Crowdsourcing? the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. --> Draft deck to be distributed 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. --> Has that happened? 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. 7. All: 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug ? end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal --> Proposal from Satya under way? _____________________________________________ From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 Importance: High Hi there, Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well - We went through all agenda points - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. Any questions, please let me know. Best regards Guenter << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. Rolf. ______________________________ Dear all, As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas * Outreach Program Progress * Technical Program Progress * MEC Requirement Progress and go through the attached action item list. Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. Kind regards Rolf. Email from last meeting << Attachments: Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) >> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Thu Nov 12 11:59:51 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2015 16:59:51 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today -> action items Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC89037638D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, Thanks for the constructive progress call today. Here are the action items: - (Kiryong) Meeting with Ashlee / on QEMU (next week Monday?) - (Kiryong, Rolf) ensure that there is feedback from Ante - (Prakash) talk to Vedams to --> position Kiryong as the technical project lead for the two Vedams resources --> ensure resources from Vedams until May 2016 - (Guenter) set-up a meeting on the networking problem with Kiryong Huawei experts - (Rolf) send a reminder to Chris Pudney regarding the power save problem - (Rolf) clarify with Valerie if we have to integrate with Intel SDK in the separate module we will create within the openstack community - (Rolf and Ashlee) progress the web-page etc. - (Rolf) move the next progress call (Thanksgiving in the US) Just to let everybody know, it was not possible to set-up the F2F meeting for Nov 30- Dec 1st (Valerie and Yun-Chao had other commitments). Still everybody is encouraged to come to CMU for the student project demonstrations on December 1st in the afternoon. Kind regards Rolf. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 11. November 2015 15:29 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call tomorrow Dear all, Just as a gentle reminder, we will hold our bi-weekly progress call tomorrow. May I assume that you can all join that call? We have to agree on the way forward after all the events and changes... Here are some of the topics we will address: - Technical Program update including QEMU, network issue (Kiryong) - Own OpenStack Cloudlet Module - resources (including Vedams), work plan and next steps (Prakash, Kiryong) - Outreach Program update (Rolf, Satya) - Web page etc. (all) Yun-Chao, Prakash and Ashlee, will you be able to join - in spite of the OPNFV Summit? We can try to cover the topics relevant for you within the first hour? Kind regards Rolf. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 15. Oktober 2015 11:58 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Dear all, Below please find the action items from our last call we will go through during our call later on today. Here are some of the topics we will address: - PoC Attached, please find the PoC document Satya has put together and Valerie is trying to position within the MEC PoC framework this week. - Blueprint @Prakash / Kiryong / Ashlee, could you please share the link to the blueprint? May I assume that has been finalised by now (due until 11 Oct)? Should we sync that with other friendly Openstack experts? - Test plan Does it make sense to address that? As we make this more widely available it would be good to see the test results. - Web page @Yun Chao, Valerie and Adrian, as you are the the MEC F2F meeting, are you going to be able to join the progress call today at 16:00 CEST? Looking forward to talk to you. Kind regards Rolf. __________________________________________________________ Action Items from 6 October: 1. (Prakash, until 15 Oct) push for OEC code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit. 2. (Prakash supported by Valerie, Guenter, Kiryong, 9 Oct) Prakash to organise this week to finalise the MEC PoC proposal to be submitted at the MEC meeting next week. Valerie to send material on Intel technology that may be used for the PoC. 3. (Kiryong, until ?) Describe rational behind QEMU modifications. Upgrade QEMU-modifications to current QEMU version. 4. (Yun-Chao, Guenter until Nov) continue to liaise with GSMA and monitor their task force work on edge computing. 5. (Rolf, Guenter until Nov) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 6. (all, until 15 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 7. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 11 Oct) Finalise the blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 11 Oct. Prakash to organise a call on that matter this week. 8. (all, 15 Oct) send key material, text snippets for the OEC web page to Ashley. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 6. Oktober 2015 11:40 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Dear all, Thanks for the constructive discussion yesterday. Please find the action items from the call below. Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from 6 October: 1. (Prakash, until 15 Oct) push for OEC code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit. 2. (Prakash supported by Valerie, Guenter, Kiryong, 9 Oct) Prakash to organise this week to finalise the MEC PoC proposal to be submitted at the MEC meeting next week. Valerie to send material on Intel technology that may be used for the PoC. 3. (Kiryong, until ?) Describe rational behind QEMU modifications. Upgrade QEMU-modifications to current QEMU version. 4. (Yun-Chao, Guenter until Nov) continue to liaise with GSMA and monitor their task force work on edge computing. 5. (Rolf, Guenter until Nov) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 6. (all, until 15 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 7. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 11 Oct) Finalise the blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 11 Oct. Prakash to organise a call on that matter this week. 8. (all, 15 Oct) send key material, text snippets for the OEC web page to Ashley. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Montag, 5. Oktober 2015 12:18 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Dear all, Today we will have a shortened progress call in the beginning of the weekly call of the technical team. Hence, we will just address a few matters: - Action items from last call (see below and attachment for details) - Brief summary of MEC Congress in London last week - Status and next steps regarding Nova Blueprint Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from 17 September: 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 25 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit 2. (Ashlee, until 25 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) 3. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 17 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie will send a draft of a OEC PoC proposal document the group. Satya and Kiryong support that process. Perhaps first E2E demo at Mobile World Congress in Barcelon 2016? 4. (Kiryong, until 23 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student 5. (Yun-Chao, until 25 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting? Check with Guenter if he is there as well. 6. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 7. (all, until 1 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 8. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 21 Sept) Finalise the draft blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 21 Sept. Ashlee & Prakash to send examples of "good" blueprints to Kiryong, Rolf and Satya asap. 9. (Ashlee, 21 Sept) send two final logo versions, prepare an early version of the webpage to be reviewed in Technical Program Call on Monday 21 Sept. << File: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call with actions.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 17. September 2015 10:45 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week --> Call NOT cancelled TODAY Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call later on today - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure Some of you might have received cancellation messages. This is just because I have updated the invite with the latest oec-sync list to ensure that Ashlee is also invited ;-) Also, I updated the meeting number as proposed by Chase. I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 3. September 2015 18:23 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Thanks for the constructive call today. Here are the action items. I uploaded the meeting slides as well as the Open Edge Computing Overview slides to our file repository (link again below). @Ashlee, are you receiving these mails by now? Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from Progress call 3rd September 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 14 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack summit AND OPNFV Summit 2. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) 3. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 17 Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 4. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 4 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 5. (Kiriong, until 5 Sept) Meeting with Vedams on Monday, 7 September, Meeting on OpenStack roadmap on Monday, 14 September (with Yun-Chao) 6. (Kiryong, until 5 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student 7. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) License discussion for Open Edge Initiative --> at Technical Program Call on 14 Sept? 8. (Yun-Chao, until 17 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting 9. (Yun-Chao and Rolf, 14 Sept) put together a proposal for membership structure + web-site + new partner outreach 10. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 11. Info: Cloudlet Class applicatin demonstration session on 1 December 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All welcome! Link to repository: https://owncloud.cmusatyalab.org/owncloud/public.php?service=files&t=c9f5bf1c36948d874459dea2fa50e57a _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 2. September 2015 21:50 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-09-03 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 1. September 2015 22:54 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and - please have a look at the action items below from our last call and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. Kind regards Rolf. Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 21. August 2015 16:38 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions... Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. Many thanks Rolf. << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx >> Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. - Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) --> DONE 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. Ideas: address verticals. 'Crowdsourcing' the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. --> Draft deck to be distributed 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. --> Has that happened? 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. 7. All: 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug - end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal --> Proposal from Satya under way... _____________________________________________ From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 Importance: High Hi there, Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well - We went through all agenda points - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. Any questions, please let me know. Best regards Guenter << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. Rolf. ______________________________ Dear all, As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas - Outreach Program Progress - Technical Program Progress - MEC Requirement Progress and go through the attached action item list. Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. Kind regards Rolf. Email from last meeting << Attachments: Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) >> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From patrice.hede at huawei.com Mon Nov 16 02:26:59 2015 From: patrice.hede at huawei.com (=?UTF-8?B?UGF0cmljZSBIw6lkw6k=?=) Date: Mon, 16 Nov 2015 08:26:59 +0100 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today -> action items In-Reply-To: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC89037638D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC89037638D@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <56498543.3000000@huawei.com> Hi Rolf, all, I am sorry I could not join the call again ? I was travelling back at the time of the call from Munich where we held a MEC brainstorming meeting to design the architecture ? which was rather successful in the end. I will try to report the status of the progress of MEC in our next call (will it be the 26?). Regards, Patrice Le 12/11/2015 17:59, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group via oe-sync a ?crit : > Dear all, > Thanks for the constructive progress call today. > Here are the action items: > - (Kiryong) Meeting with Ashlee / on QEMU (next week Monday?) > - (Kiryong, Rolf) ensure that there is feedback from Ante > - (Prakash) talk to Vedams to > ? position Kiryong as the technical project lead for the two Vedams > resources > ? ensure resources from Vedams until May 2016 > - (Guenter) set-up a meeting on the networking problem with Kiryong > Huawei experts > - (Rolf) send a reminder to Chris Pudney regarding the power save problem > - (Rolf) clarify with Valerie if we have to integrate with Intel SDK > in the separate module we will create within the openstack community > - (Rolf and Ashlee) progress the web-page etc. > - (Rolf) move the next progress call (Thanksgiving in the US) > Just to let everybody know, it was not possible to set-up the F2F > meeting for Nov 30- Dec 1^st (Valerie and Yun-Chao had other > commitments). Still everybody is encouraged to come to CMU for the > student project demonstrations on December 1^st in the afternoon. > Kind regards > Rolf. > _____________________________________________ > *From:* Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > *Sent:* Mittwoch, 11. November 2015 15:29 > *To:* oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > *Subject:* Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call tomorrow > Dear all, > Just as a gentle reminder, we will hold our bi-weekly progress call > tomorrow. May I assume that you can all join that call? We have to > agree on the way forward after all the events and changes? > Here are some of the topics we will address: > - Technical Program update including QEMU, network issue (Kiryong) > - Own OpenStack Cloudlet Module ? resources (including Vedams), work > plan and next steps (Prakash, Kiryong) > - Outreach Program update (Rolf, Satya) > - Web page etc. (all) > Yun-Chao, Prakash and Ashlee, will you be able to join ? in spite of > the OPNFV Summit? We can try to cover the topics relevant for you > within the first hour? > Kind regards > Rolf. > _____________________________________________ > *From:* Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > *Sent:* Donnerstag, 15. Oktober 2015 11:58 > *To:* _oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu_ > *Subject:* Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today > Dear all, > Below please find the action items from our last call we will go > through during our call later on today. > Here are some of the topics we will address: > - PoC > Attached, please find the PoC document Satya has put together and > Valerie is trying to position within the MEC PoC framework this week. > - Blueprint > @Prakash / Kiryong / Ashlee, could you please share the link to the > blueprint? May I assume that has been finalised by now (due until 11 > Oct)? Should we sync that with other friendly Openstack experts? > - Test plan > Does it make sense to address that? As we make this more widely > available it would be good to see the test results. > - Web page > @Yun Chao, Valerie and Adrian, as you are the the MEC F2F meeting, are > you going to be able to join the progress call today at 16:00 CEST? > Looking forward to talk to you. > Kind regards > Rolf. > __________________________________________________________ > Action Items from 6 October: > > 1. *(Prakash, until 15 Oct) *push for OEC code demo at OpenStack > Summit AND OPNFV Summit. > 2. *(Prakash supported by Valerie, Guenter, Kiryong, 9 Oct) *Prakash > to organise this week to finalise the MEC PoC proposal to be > submitted at the MEC meeting next week. Valerie to send material > on Intel technology that may be used for the PoC. > 3. *(Kiryong, until ?) *Describe rational behind QEMU modifications. > Upgrade QEMU-modifications to current QEMU version.** > 4. *(Yun-Chao, Guenter until Nov) *continue to**liaise with GSMA and > monitor their task force work on edge computing. > 5. *(Rolf, Guenter until Nov) *contact further OEC supporters / > partners for example HP, Canonical etc. > 6. *(all, until 15 Oct) *Cloudlet Class application demonstration > session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can > come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. > 7. *(Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 11 Oct) *Finalise the blueprint and > send the entire group by Monday 11 Oct. Prakash to organise a call > on that matter this week. > 8. *(all, 15 Oct) *send key material, text snippets for the OEC web > page to Ashley. > > _____________________________________________ > *From:* Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > *Sent:* Dienstag, 6. Oktober 2015 11:40 > *To:* _oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu_ > *Subject:* RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today > Dear all, > Thanks for the constructive discussion yesterday. Please find the > action items from the call below. > Kind regards > Rolf. > Action Items from 6 October: > > 1. *(Prakash, until 15 Oct) *push for OEC code demo at OpenStack > Summit AND OPNFV Summit. > 2. *(Prakash supported by Valerie, Guenter, Kiryong, 9 Oct) *Prakash > to organise this week to finalise the MEC PoC proposal to be > submitted at the MEC meeting next week. Valerie to send material > on Intel technology that may be used for the PoC. > 3. *(Kiryong, until ?) *Describe rational behind QEMU modifications. > Upgrade QEMU-modifications to current QEMU version.** > 4. *(Yun-Chao, Guenter until Nov) *continue to**liaise with GSMA and > monitor their task force work on edge computing. > 5. *(Rolf, Guenter until Nov) *contact further OEC supporters / > partners for example HP, Canonical etc. > 6. *(all, until 15 Oct) *Cloudlet Class application demonstration > session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can > come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. > 7. *(Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 11 Oct) *Finalise the blueprint and > send the entire group by Monday 11 Oct. Prakash to organise a call > on that matter this week. > 8. *(all, 15 Oct) *send key material, text snippets for the OEC web > page to Ashley. > > _____________________________________________ > *From:* Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > *Sent:* Montag, 5. Oktober 2015 12:18 > *To:* _oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu_ > *Subject:* Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today > Dear all, > Today we will have a shortened progress call in the beginning of the > weekly call of the technical team. Hence, we will just address a few > matters: > - Action items from last call (see below and attachment for details) > - Brief summary of MEC Congress in London last week > - Status and next steps regarding Nova Blueprint > Kind regards > Rolf. > Action Items from 17 September: > > 1. *(Ashlee, Prakash, until 25 Sept) *push for code demo at OpenStack > Summit AND OPNFV Summit > 2. *(Ashlee, until 25 Sept) *push for board presentation at OpenStack > (with Alan Clark) > 3. *(Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 17 Sept) *MEC PoC platform is a > good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie will send a draft of a > OEC PoC proposal document the group. Satya and Kiryong support > that process. Perhaps first E2E demo at Mobile World Congress in > Barcelon 2016? > 4. *(Kiryong, until 23 Sept) *Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap > with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student > 5. *(Yun-Chao, until 25 Sept) *present Open Edge Computing at > GSMA-Meeting? Check with Guenter if he is there as well. > 6. *(Rolf, 17 Sept) *contact further OEC supporters / partners for > example HP, Canonical etc. > 7. *(all, until 1 Oct) *Cloudlet Class application demonstration > session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can > come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. > 8. *(Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 21 Sept) *Finalise the draft blueprint > and send the entire group by Monday 21 Sept. Ashlee & Prakash to > send examples of ?good? blueprints to Kiryong, Rolf and Satya asap. > 9. *(Ashlee, 21 Sept) *send two final logo versions, prepare an early > version of the webpage to be reviewed in Technical Program Call on > Monday 21 Sept. > > << File: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call with actions.pptx >> > _____________________________________________ > *From:* Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > *Sent:* Donnerstag, 17. September 2015 10:45 > *To:* _oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu_ > *Subject:* RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on > Thursday this week --> Call NOT cancelled TODAY > Dear all, > Attached, please find the material for our call later on today > - Presentation with call agenda and > - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure > Some of you might have received cancellation messages. This is just > because I have updated the invite with the latest oec-sync list to > ensure that Ashlee is also invited ;-) > Also, I updated the meeting number as proposed by Chase. > I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. > Kind regards > Rolf. > << File: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> > _____________________________________________ > *From:* Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > *Sent:* Donnerstag, 3. September 2015 18:23 > *To:* _oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu_ > *Subject:* RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on > Thursday this week > Thanks for the constructive call today. Here are the action items. I > uploaded the meeting slides as well as the Open Edge Computing > Overview slides to our file repository (link again below). > @Ashlee, are you receiving these mails by now? > Kind regards > Rolf. > *Action Items from Progress call 3**^rd **September* > > 1. *(Ashlee, Prakash, until 14 Sept) *push for code demo at OpenStack > summit AND OPNFV Summit > 2. *(Ashlee, until 14 Sept) *push for board presentation at OpenStack > (with Alan Clark) > 3. *(Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 17 Sept) > *describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and > map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) > 4. *(Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 4 Sept) *MEC PoC platform is a > good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a > OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and > Kiryong support that process. > 5. *(Kiriong, until 5 Sept*) Meeting with Vedams on Monday, 7 > September, Meeting on OpenStack roadmap on Monday, 14 September > (with Yun-Chao) > 6. *(Kiryong, until 5 Sept) *Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with > Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student > 7. *(Ashlee, until 14 Sept) *License discussion for Open Edge > Initiative ? at Technical Program Call on 14 Sept? > 8. *(Yun-Chao, until 17 Sept) *present Open Edge Computing at > GSMA-Meeting > 9. *(Yun-Chao and Rolf, 14 Sept) *put together a proposal for > membership structure + web-site + new partner outreach > 10. *(Rolf, 17 Sept) *contact further OEC supporters / partners for > example HP, Canonical etc. > 11. *Info: *Cloudlet Class applicatin demonstration session on 1 > December 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All welcome! > > Link to repository: > _https://owncloud.cmusatyalab.org/owncloud/public.php?service=files&t=c9f5bf1c36948d874459dea2fa50e57a_ > _____________________________________________ > *From:* Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > *Sent:* Mittwoch, 2. September 2015 21:50 > *To:* _oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu_ > *Subject:* RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on > Thursday this week > Dear all, > Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow > - Presentation with call agenda and > - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure > I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. > Kind regards > Rolf. > << File: 2015-09-03 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> > _____________________________________________ > *From:* Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > *Sent:* Dienstag, 1. September 2015 22:54 > *To:* _oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu_ > *Subject:* RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on > Thursday this week > Dear all, > Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, > > * please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by > say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and > * please have a look at the action items below from our last call > and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call > > Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. > Kind regards > Rolf. > Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 > > 1. *(everybody, until Tue 25 Aug)* review the draft OEC Overview deck > provided by Rolf and send him your feedback > 2. *(Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) *push for acceptance of our > presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan > Clark) > 3. *(Prakash, until mid September) *push for acceptance of our > presentation at OPNFV Summit > 4. *(Prakash, until 24 Aug) *gather feedback on our presentation > acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to > create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August > in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) > 5. *(Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) *MEC PoC platform is a good > opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC > proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong > support that process. > 6. *(Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) > *describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and > map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) > 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge > Computing > > * *(Rolf, until 3rd Sept) *will put together a more detailed content > structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator > section etc. > * *(Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) *will select a suitable software > platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names > openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. > * *(Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) *will look into Intel SDK to be included > in the platform and sandbox? > > 8. *(Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) *send contacts to HP that might be > interested in OEC > 9. *(Rolf, until 3rd Sept) *contact further OEC supporters / partners > for example HP, Canonical etc. > 10. *(Rolf, until 3rd Sept) *provide a detailed proposal for partner > engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) > 11. *(Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept)* continue to progress the OEC > Class project > > _____________________________________________ > *From:* Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > *Sent:* Freitag, 21. August 2015 16:38 > *To:* _oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu_ > *Cc:* _ashlee at onosfw.com_ > *Subject:* RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on > Thursday this week > Dear all, > Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. > Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send > your comments and suggestions? > Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please > do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. > Many thanks > Rolf.** > << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx >> > Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 > > 1. *(everybody, until Tue 25 Aug)* review the draft OEC Overview deck > provided by Rolf and send him your feedback > 2. *(Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) *push for acceptance of our > presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan > Clark) > 3. *(Prakash, until mid September) *push for acceptance of our > presentation at OPNFV Summit > 4. *(Prakash, until 24 Aug) *gather feedback on our presentation > acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to > create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August > in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) > 5. *(Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) *MEC PoC platform is a good > opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC > proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong > support that process. > 6. *(Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) > *describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and > map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) > 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge > Computing > > * *(Rolf, until 3rd Sept) *will put together a more detailed content > structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator > section etc. > * *(Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) *will select a suitable software > platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names > openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. > * *(Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) *will look into Intel SDK to be included > in the platform and sandbox? > > 8. *(Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) *send contacts to HP that might be > interested in OEC > 9. *(Rolf, until 3rd Sept) *contact further OEC supporters / partners > for example HP, Canonical etc. > 10. *(Rolf, until 3rd Sept) *provide a detailed proposal for partner > engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) > 11. *(Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept)* continue to progress the OEC > Class project > > _____________________________________________ > *From:* Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > *Sent:* Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 > *To:* _oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu_ > *Cc:* _ashlee at onosfw.com_ > *Subject:* FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on > Thursday this week > Dear all, > Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow > - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions > - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all > partners) > I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. > Kind regards > Rolf. > << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 > Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> > _____________________________________________ > *From:*Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > *Sent:*Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 > *To:*Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; > Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith > (_chasek at cs.cmu.edu_ ); 'Young, Valerie J'; > 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; > _joe.g.cahill at intel.com_ ; Neal, > Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha > (_krha at cmu.edu_ ); _michael.a.kozuch at intel.com_ > > *Subject:*Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday > this week > Dear all, > Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, > > * please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by > say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. > * Please have a look at the action items below (and in the > attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered > during the call > > As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. > Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an > update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in > details. > Kind regards > Rolf. > << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> > Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) > > 1. *Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently > attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) > *?*DONE* > 2. *Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: > business value, addressable market, etc. > Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to > convince other parties. > Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. > Ideas: address verticals. ?Crowdsourcing? the deck step by step, > such that it includes good material for different verticals. > *?*Draft deck to be distributed* > 3. *Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them > *?*need endorsements. > Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a > pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. > Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can > get a presentation at the OS Summit. > *Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this*. Then all engage > your internal stakeholders accordingly. > *?*Has that happened?* > 4. *Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could > be used in our context. > *?*Feedback in call on 20 August 2015?* > 5. *Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo > technical conf calls. > *?*Update durich call on 20 August 2015?* > 6. *Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document > to the list once ready. > *?*The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody.* > 7. *All: > 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from > early/mid Aug ? end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can > code. > 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet > Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is > familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should > have access to servers. > *?*DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks!* > 8. *All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. > Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? > Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test > case to try out the proposal > *?*Proposal from Satya under way?* > > _____________________________________________ > *From:* Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group > *Sent:* Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 > *To:* Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao > hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith > (_chasek at cs.cmu.edu_ ); 'Young, Valerie J'; > 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; > _joe.g.cahill at intel.com_ ; Neal, > Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha > (_krha at cmu.edu_ ); _michael.a.kozuch at intel.com_ > > *Subject:* Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 > July 2015 > *Importance:* High > Hi there, > Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. > - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in > from smartphones worked pretty well > - We went through all agenda points > - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. > call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. > - *New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties.* > - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. > Any questions, please let me know. > Best regards > Guenter > << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> > -----Original Appointment----- > *From:* Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > *Sent:* 11 June 2015 22:31 > *To:* Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, > Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev > Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (_chasek at cs.cmu.edu_ > ); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; > 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; _joe.g.cahill at intel.com_ > ; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, > Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (_krha at cmu.edu_ > ); _michael.a.kozuch at intel.com_ > > *Subject:* Open Edge Computing - Progress Call > *When:* 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, > Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. > *Where:* We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no > VoIP), details below > Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for > application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in > via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. > Rolf. > ______________________________ > Dear all, > As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas > > * Outreach Program Progress > * Technical Program Progress > * MEC Requirement Progress > > and go through the attached action item list. > Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to > you directly from _uMeeting at huawei.com_ > for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather > than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application > sharing (will be attached to this invite). > Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest > that Satya is chairing this call. > Kind regards > Rolf. > Email from last meeting > > << Attachments: > > _Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx_ > (34.5KB) > _Webex call-in information July 16, 2015_ > (11.7KB) > _RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon_ > (9.0MB) > >> > > > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Tue Nov 17 06:54:03 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Tue, 17 Nov 2015 11:54:03 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Rescheduling next OEC Progress Call Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890379073@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, As discussed last week, we have to re-schedule the next progress call on 26 November due to Thanksgiving. Here are two alternatives: Monday, 23 November, 12pm - 1:30pm EDT / 18:00 - 19:30 CET Tuesday, 1 December, 9.30am - 11am EDT / 15:30 - 17:00 CET (this is the day of the student demonstration in Pittsburgh. Those travelling to Pittsburgh could join the call from there) Please let me know until Thursday this week what alternative might work with you. I will then issue the new invite on Friday this week. Cheers Rolf. [http://www.vodafone.com/content/dam/global_email_signature/sigroundel.png] Rolf Schuster Head of Partner Innovation Centres Architecture & Research Vodafone Group Services GmbH Mobile: +491722360098 Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff vodafone.com This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From patrice.hede at huawei.com Tue Nov 17 11:40:51 2015 From: patrice.hede at huawei.com (=?UTF-8?B?UGF0cmljZSBIw6lkw6k=?=) Date: Tue, 17 Nov 2015 17:40:51 +0100 Subject: [oe-sync] Rescheduling next OEC Progress Call In-Reply-To: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890379073@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890379073@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <564B5893.4020401@huawei.com> Hi Rolf, my preference would be for Tuesday 1st December, although I can probably arrange to be here on Monday 23 if that's the preferred date. Regards, Patrice Le 17/11/2015 12:54, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group via oe-sync a ?crit : > Dear all, > As discussed last week, we have to re-schedule the next progress call > on 26 November due to Thanksgiving. > Here are two alternatives: > Monday, 23 November, 12pm ? 1:30pm EDT / 18:00 ? 19:30 CET > Tuesday, 1 December, 9.30am ? 11am EDT / 15:30 ? 17:00 CET (this is > the day of the student demonstration in Pittsburgh. Those travelling > to Pittsburgh could join the call from there) > Please let me know until Thursday this week what alternative might > work with you. I will then issue the new invite on Friday this week. > Cheers > Rolf. > *Rolf Schuster > *HeadofPartnerInnovationCentres > Architecture & Research > Vodafone Group Services GmbH > Mobile: +491722360098 > Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com > > Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, > D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 > Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff > *vodafone.com * > > This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and > may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or > protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual > or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have > received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, > delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its > contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that > transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. > > > > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From padmanabhan.s.pillai at intel.com Tue Nov 17 12:01:05 2015 From: padmanabhan.s.pillai at intel.com (Padmanabhan Pillai) Date: Tue, 17 Nov 2015 12:01:05 -0500 Subject: [oe-sync] Rescheduling next OEC Progress Call In-Reply-To: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890379073@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890379073@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <564B5D51.80004@intel.com> Both of these dates work for me. - Babu On 11/17/2015 06:54 AM, Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group via oe-sync wrote: > Dear all, > As discussed last week, we have to re-schedule the next progress call > on 26 November due to Thanksgiving. > Here are two alternatives: > Monday, 23 November, 12pm ? 1:30pm EDT / 18:00 ? 19:30 CET > Tuesday, 1 December, 9.30am ? 11am EDT / 15:30 ? 17:00 CET (this is > the day of the student demonstration in Pittsburgh. Those travelling > to Pittsburgh could join the call from there) > Please let me know until Thursday this week what alternative might > work with you. I will then issue the new invite on Friday this week. > Cheers > Rolf. > *Rolf Schuster > *HeadofPartnerInnovationCentres > Architecture & Research > Vodafone Group Services GmbH > Mobile: +491722360098 > Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com > > Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, > D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 > Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff > *vodafone.com * > > This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and > may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or > protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual > or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have > received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, > delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its > contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that > transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. > > > > _______________________________________________ > oe-sync mailing list > oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > https://lists.andrew.cmu.edu/mailman/listinfo/oe-sync -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com Wed Nov 18 06:11:07 2015 From: Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com (Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group) Date: Wed, 18 Nov 2015 11:11:07 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Rescheduling next OEC Progress Call In-Reply-To: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890379073@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC890379073@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A723EEC@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Both dates ok. Guenter From: oe-sync [mailto:oe-sync-bounces+guenter.klas=vodafone.com at lists.andrew.cmu.edu] On Behalf Of Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group via oe-sync Sent: 17 November 2015 11:54 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: [oe-sync] Rescheduling next OEC Progress Call Dear all, As discussed last week, we have to re-schedule the next progress call on 26 November due to Thanksgiving. Here are two alternatives: Monday, 23 November, 12pm - 1:30pm EDT / 18:00 - 19:30 CET Tuesday, 1 December, 9.30am - 11am EDT / 15:30 - 17:00 CET (this is the day of the student demonstration in Pittsburgh. Those travelling to Pittsburgh could join the call from there) Please let me know until Thursday this week what alternative might work with you. I will then issue the new invite on Friday this week. Cheers Rolf. [http://www.vodafone.com/content/dam/global_email_signature/sigroundel.png] Rolf Schuster Head of Partner Innovation Centres Architecture & Research Vodafone Group Services GmbH Mobile: +491722360098 Email: rolf.schuster at vodafone.com Vodafone Group Services GmbH, Ferdinand-Braun-Platz 1, D-40549 D?sseldorf Amtsgericht D?sseldorf, HRB 53554 Gesch?ftsf?hrung: Dr. Joachim Peters, Frank Rosenberger, Achim Weusthoff vodafone.com This message and any files or documents attached are confidential and may also be legally privileged, protected from disclosure and/or protected by other legal rules. It is intended only for the individual or entity named. If you are not the named addressee or you have received this email in error, please inform the sender immediately, delete it from your system and do not copy or disclose it or its contents or use it for any purpose. Thank you. Please also note that transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free. -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com Sun Nov 22 16:10:40 2015 From: Guenter.Klas at vodafone.com (Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group) Date: Sun, 22 Nov 2015 21:10:40 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Fog Consortium - in addition to ETSI MEC and Open Edge Computing Message-ID: <47D341CC8B26E84FB8A5F7108884CFD47A729A12@VOEXM01W.internal.vodafone.com> Hi all, You may have noticed from 19 Nov: http://www.openfogconsortium.org/news/ I sat down over the weekend, studied the whole thing and compared it to ETSI MEC and OEC, then wrote up my thoughts in a paper which is available here. http://yucianga.info/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/15-11-22-Fog-computing-and-mobile-edge-cloud-gain-momentum-%E2%80%93-Open-Fog-Consortium-ETSI-MEC-Cloudlets-v1.pdf In case the URL doesn?t work, I can send you the pdf. Looking forward to hearing your thoughts about Open Fog later on. Br Guenter -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Mon Nov 30 05:49:22 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Mon, 30 Nov 2015 10:49:22 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call tomorrow Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8903A71D7@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, As agreed, we will hold our bi-weekly progress call tomorrow. Here are the topics we will address: - Review progress action items (see below) - Update on technical program progress (Kiryong?) - MEC architecture progress (Patrice) - Direction Workshop 11 Dec at CMU: prep discussion (input from Guenter, Satya, Rolf, Yun-Chao?, Valerie?) - Update on Outreach activities (Satya, Rolf) - FogComputingConsortium.org - Update on information (all) - Shift the next Progress Call (many of us are in the plane to the Workshop) Anything else we should address? Looking forward to talk to you. Kind regards Rolf. Here are the action items from 12 November progress call: - (Kiryong) Meeting with Ashlee / on QEMU (next week Monday?) - (Kiryong, Rolf) ensure that there is feedback from Ante - (Prakash) talk to Vedams to --> position Kiryong as the technical project lead for the two Vedams resources --> ensure resources from Vedams until May 2016 - (Guenter) set-up a meeting on the networking problem with Kiryong Huawei experts - (Rolf) send a reminder to Chris Pudney regarding the power save problem - (Rolf) clarify with Valerie if we have to integrate with Intel SDK in the separate module we will create within the openstack community - (Rolf and Ashlee) progress the web-page etc. - (Rolf) move the next progress call (Thanksgiving in the US) _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 12. November 2015 18:00 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today -> action items Dear all, Thanks for the constructive progress call today. Here are the action items: - (Kiryong) Meeting with Ashlee / on QEMU (next week Monday?) - (Kiryong, Rolf) ensure that there is feedback from Ante - (Prakash) talk to Vedams to --> position Kiryong as the technical project lead for the two Vedams resources --> ensure resources from Vedams until May 2016 - (Guenter) set-up a meeting on the networking problem with Kiryong Huawei experts - (Rolf) send a reminder to Chris Pudney regarding the power save problem - (Rolf) clarify with Valerie if we have to integrate with Intel SDK in the separate module we will create within the openstack community - (Rolf and Ashlee) progress the web-page etc. - (Rolf) move the next progress call (Thanksgiving in the US) Just to let everybody know, it was not possible to set-up the F2F meeting for Nov 30- Dec 1st (Valerie and Yun-Chao had other commitments). Still everybody is encouraged to come to CMU for the student project demonstrations on December 1st in the afternoon. Kind regards Rolf. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 11. November 2015 15:29 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call tomorrow Dear all, Just as a gentle reminder, we will hold our bi-weekly progress call tomorrow. May I assume that you can all join that call? We have to agree on the way forward after all the events and changes... Here are some of the topics we will address: - Technical Program update including QEMU, network issue (Kiryong) - Own OpenStack Cloudlet Module - resources (including Vedams), work plan and next steps (Prakash, Kiryong) - Outreach Program update (Rolf, Satya) - Web page etc. (all) Yun-Chao, Prakash and Ashlee, will you be able to join - in spite of the OPNFV Summit? We can try to cover the topics relevant for you within the first hour? Kind regards Rolf. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 15. Oktober 2015 11:58 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Dear all, Below please find the action items from our last call we will go through during our call later on today. Here are some of the topics we will address: - PoC Attached, please find the PoC document Satya has put together and Valerie is trying to position within the MEC PoC framework this week. - Blueprint @Prakash / Kiryong / Ashlee, could you please share the link to the blueprint? May I assume that has been finalised by now (due until 11 Oct)? Should we sync that with other friendly Openstack experts? - Test plan Does it make sense to address that? As we make this more widely available it would be good to see the test results. - Web page @Yun Chao, Valerie and Adrian, as you are the the MEC F2F meeting, are you going to be able to join the progress call today at 16:00 CEST? Looking forward to talk to you. Kind regards Rolf. __________________________________________________________ Action Items from 6 October: 1. (Prakash, until 15 Oct) push for OEC code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit. 2. (Prakash supported by Valerie, Guenter, Kiryong, 9 Oct) Prakash to organise this week to finalise the MEC PoC proposal to be submitted at the MEC meeting next week. Valerie to send material on Intel technology that may be used for the PoC. 3. (Kiryong, until ?) Describe rational behind QEMU modifications. Upgrade QEMU-modifications to current QEMU version. 4. (Yun-Chao, Guenter until Nov) continue to liaise with GSMA and monitor their task force work on edge computing. 5. (Rolf, Guenter until Nov) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 6. (all, until 15 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 7. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 11 Oct) Finalise the blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 11 Oct. Prakash to organise a call on that matter this week. 8. (all, 15 Oct) send key material, text snippets for the OEC web page to Ashley. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 6. Oktober 2015 11:40 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Dear all, Thanks for the constructive discussion yesterday. Please find the action items from the call below. Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from 6 October: 1. (Prakash, until 15 Oct) push for OEC code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit. 2. (Prakash supported by Valerie, Guenter, Kiryong, 9 Oct) Prakash to organise this week to finalise the MEC PoC proposal to be submitted at the MEC meeting next week. Valerie to send material on Intel technology that may be used for the PoC. 3. (Kiryong, until ?) Describe rational behind QEMU modifications. Upgrade QEMU-modifications to current QEMU version. 4. (Yun-Chao, Guenter until Nov) continue to liaise with GSMA and monitor their task force work on edge computing. 5. (Rolf, Guenter until Nov) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 6. (all, until 15 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 7. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 11 Oct) Finalise the blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 11 Oct. Prakash to organise a call on that matter this week. 8. (all, 15 Oct) send key material, text snippets for the OEC web page to Ashley. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Montag, 5. Oktober 2015 12:18 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Dear all, Today we will have a shortened progress call in the beginning of the weekly call of the technical team. Hence, we will just address a few matters: - Action items from last call (see below and attachment for details) - Brief summary of MEC Congress in London last week - Status and next steps regarding Nova Blueprint Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from 17 September: 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 25 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit 2. (Ashlee, until 25 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) 3. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 17 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie will send a draft of a OEC PoC proposal document the group. Satya and Kiryong support that process. Perhaps first E2E demo at Mobile World Congress in Barcelon 2016? 4. (Kiryong, until 23 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student 5. (Yun-Chao, until 25 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting? Check with Guenter if he is there as well. 6. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 7. (all, until 1 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 8. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 21 Sept) Finalise the draft blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 21 Sept. Ashlee & Prakash to send examples of "good" blueprints to Kiryong, Rolf and Satya asap. 9. (Ashlee, 21 Sept) send two final logo versions, prepare an early version of the webpage to be reviewed in Technical Program Call on Monday 21 Sept. << File: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call with actions.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 17. September 2015 10:45 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week --> Call NOT cancelled TODAY Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call later on today - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure Some of you might have received cancellation messages. This is just because I have updated the invite with the latest oec-sync list to ensure that Ashlee is also invited ;-) Also, I updated the meeting number as proposed by Chase. I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 3. September 2015 18:23 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Thanks for the constructive call today. Here are the action items. I uploaded the meeting slides as well as the Open Edge Computing Overview slides to our file repository (link again below). @Ashlee, are you receiving these mails by now? Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from Progress call 3rd September 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 14 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack summit AND OPNFV Summit 2. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) 3. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 17 Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 4. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 4 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 5. (Kiriong, until 5 Sept) Meeting with Vedams on Monday, 7 September, Meeting on OpenStack roadmap on Monday, 14 September (with Yun-Chao) 6. (Kiryong, until 5 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student 7. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) License discussion for Open Edge Initiative --> at Technical Program Call on 14 Sept? 8. (Yun-Chao, until 17 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting 9. (Yun-Chao and Rolf, 14 Sept) put together a proposal for membership structure + web-site + new partner outreach 10. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 11. Info: Cloudlet Class applicatin demonstration session on 1 December 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All welcome! Link to repository: https://owncloud.cmusatyalab.org/owncloud/public.php?service=files&t=c9f5bf1c36948d874459dea2fa50e57a _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 2. September 2015 21:50 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-09-03 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 1. September 2015 22:54 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and - please have a look at the action items below from our last call and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. Kind regards Rolf. Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 21. August 2015 16:38 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions... Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. Many thanks Rolf. << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx >> Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. - Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) --> DONE 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. Ideas: address verticals. 'Crowdsourcing' the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. --> Draft deck to be distributed 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. --> Has that happened? 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. 7. All: 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug - end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal --> Proposal from Satya under way... _____________________________________________ From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 Importance: High Hi there, Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well - We went through all agenda points - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. Any questions, please let me know. Best regards Guenter << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. Rolf. ______________________________ Dear all, As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas - Outreach Program Progress - Technical Program Progress - MEC Requirement Progress and go through the attached action item list. Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. Kind regards Rolf. Email from last meeting << Attachments: Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) >> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From satya at cs.cmu.edu Mon Nov 30 21:31:12 2015 From: satya at cs.cmu.edu (Mahadev Satyanarayanan) Date: Mon, 30 Nov 2015 21:31:12 -0500 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call tomorrow In-Reply-To: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8903A71D7@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> References: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8903A71D7@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Message-ID: <201511302131.12404.satya@cs.cmu.edu> Hi everyone, Following up on Rolf's email, I don't see a Webex meeting reservation for tomorrow. Perhaps we forgot to tell Chase. In any case, I just set up the reservation below. Talk to you at 09:30 EST tomorrow. Cheers -- Satya ------- Webex details -------- Meeting URL: https://cmusatyalab.webex.com/cmusatyalab/j.php?MTID=mb21af7061f91369e06efc08727d1792d Tuesday, December 1, 2015 9:30 am Eastern Standard Time (GMT-05:00) 1 hour 30 minutes Meeting number: 738 288 762 Meeting password: oesync Shared cloud space is at this URL: https://owncloud.cmusatyalab.org/owncloud/index.php/apps/files/?dir=%2Fopen-edge-computing-share ------------------------------------ On Monday 30 November 2015 05:49:22 Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group via oe-sync wrote: > > Dear all, > As agreed, we will hold our bi-weekly progress call tomorrow. > > Here are the topics we will address: > - Review progress action items (see below) > - Update on technical program progress (Kiryong?) > - MEC architecture progress (Patrice) > - Direction Workshop 11 Dec at CMU: prep discussion (input from Guenter, Satya, Rolf, Yun-Chao?, Valerie?) > - Update on Outreach activities (Satya, Rolf) > - FogComputingConsortium.org - Update on information (all) > - Shift the next Progress Call (many of us are in the plane to the Workshop) > > Anything else we should address? > Looking forward to talk to you. > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > Here are the action items from 12 November progress call: > - (Kiryong) Meeting with Ashlee / on QEMU (next week Monday?) > - (Kiryong, Rolf) ensure that there is feedback from Ante > - (Prakash) talk to Vedams to > --> position Kiryong as the technical project lead for the two Vedams resources > --> ensure resources from Vedams until May 2016 > - (Guenter) set-up a meeting on the networking problem with Kiryong Huawei experts > - (Rolf) send a reminder to Chris Pudney regarding the power save problem > - (Rolf) clarify with Valerie if we have to integrate with Intel SDK in the separate module we will create within the openstack community > - (Rolf and Ashlee) progress the web-page etc. > - (Rolf) move the next progress call (Thanksgiving in the US) > > > > _____________________________________________ > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Donnerstag, 12. November 2015 18:00 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today -> action items > > > > Dear all, > Thanks for the constructive progress call today. > Here are the action items: > > - (Kiryong) Meeting with Ashlee / on QEMU (next week Monday?) > - (Kiryong, Rolf) ensure that there is feedback from Ante > - (Prakash) talk to Vedams to > --> position Kiryong as the technical project lead for the two Vedams resources > --> ensure resources from Vedams until May 2016 > - (Guenter) set-up a meeting on the networking problem with Kiryong Huawei experts > - (Rolf) send a reminder to Chris Pudney regarding the power save problem > - (Rolf) clarify with Valerie if we have to integrate with Intel SDK in the separate module we will create within the openstack community > - (Rolf and Ashlee) progress the web-page etc. > - (Rolf) move the next progress call (Thanksgiving in the US) > > Just to let everybody know, it was not possible to set-up the F2F meeting for Nov 30- Dec 1st (Valerie and Yun-Chao had other commitments). Still everybody is encouraged to come to CMU for the student project demonstrations on December 1st in the afternoon. > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > _____________________________________________ > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Mittwoch, 11. November 2015 15:29 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call tomorrow > > > Dear all, > Just as a gentle reminder, we will hold our bi-weekly progress call tomorrow. May I assume that you can all join that call? We have to agree on the way forward after all the events and changes... > > Here are some of the topics we will address: > - Technical Program update including QEMU, network issue (Kiryong) > - Own OpenStack Cloudlet Module - resources (including Vedams), work plan and next steps (Prakash, Kiryong) > - Outreach Program update (Rolf, Satya) > - Web page etc. (all) > > Yun-Chao, Prakash and Ashlee, will you be able to join - in spite of the OPNFV Summit? We can try to cover the topics relevant for you within the first hour? > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > _____________________________________________ > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Donnerstag, 15. Oktober 2015 11:58 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today > > > Dear all, > Below please find the action items from our last call we will go through during our call later on today. > > Here are some of the topics we will address: > - PoC > Attached, please find the PoC document Satya has put together and Valerie is trying to position within the MEC PoC framework this week. > - Blueprint > @Prakash / Kiryong / Ashlee, could you please share the link to the blueprint? May I assume that has been finalised by now (due until 11 Oct)? Should we sync that with other friendly Openstack experts? > - Test plan > Does it make sense to address that? As we make this more widely available it would be good to see the test results. > - Web page > > @Yun Chao, Valerie and Adrian, as you are the the MEC F2F meeting, are you going to be able to join the progress call today at 16:00 CEST? > > Looking forward to talk to you. > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > __________________________________________________________ > > Action Items from 6 October: > 1. (Prakash, until 15 Oct) push for OEC code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit. > 2. (Prakash supported by Valerie, Guenter, Kiryong, 9 Oct) Prakash to organise this week to finalise the MEC PoC proposal to be submitted at the MEC meeting next week. Valerie to send material on Intel technology that may be used for the PoC. > 3. (Kiryong, until ?) Describe rational behind QEMU modifications. Upgrade QEMU-modifications to current QEMU version. > 4. (Yun-Chao, Guenter until Nov) continue to liaise with GSMA and monitor their task force work on edge computing. > 5. (Rolf, Guenter until Nov) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. > 6. (all, until 15 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. > 7. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 11 Oct) Finalise the blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 11 Oct. Prakash to organise a call on that matter this week. > 8. (all, 15 Oct) send key material, text snippets for the OEC web page to Ashley. > > > _____________________________________________ > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Dienstag, 6. Oktober 2015 11:40 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today > > > Dear all, > Thanks for the constructive discussion yesterday. Please find the action items from the call below. > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > Action Items from 6 October: > 1. (Prakash, until 15 Oct) push for OEC code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit. > 2. (Prakash supported by Valerie, Guenter, Kiryong, 9 Oct) Prakash to organise this week to finalise the MEC PoC proposal to be submitted at the MEC meeting next week. Valerie to send material on Intel technology that may be used for the PoC. > 3. (Kiryong, until ?) Describe rational behind QEMU modifications. Upgrade QEMU-modifications to current QEMU version. > 4. (Yun-Chao, Guenter until Nov) continue to liaise with GSMA and monitor their task force work on edge computing. > 5. (Rolf, Guenter until Nov) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. > 6. (all, until 15 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. > 7. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 11 Oct) Finalise the blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 11 Oct. Prakash to organise a call on that matter this week. > 8. (all, 15 Oct) send key material, text snippets for the OEC web page to Ashley. > > > > _____________________________________________ > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Montag, 5. Oktober 2015 12:18 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today > > > Dear all, > Today we will have a shortened progress call in the beginning of the weekly call of the technical team. Hence, we will just address a few matters: > - Action items from last call (see below and attachment for details) > - Brief summary of MEC Congress in London last week > - Status and next steps regarding Nova Blueprint > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > Action Items from 17 September: > 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 25 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit > 2. (Ashlee, until 25 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) > 3. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 17 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie will send a draft of a OEC PoC proposal document the group. Satya and Kiryong support that process. Perhaps first E2E demo at Mobile World Congress in Barcelon 2016? > 4. (Kiryong, until 23 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student > 5. (Yun-Chao, until 25 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting? Check with Guenter if he is there as well. > 6. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. > 7. (all, until 1 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. > 8. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 21 Sept) Finalise the draft blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 21 Sept. Ashlee & Prakash to send examples of "good" blueprints to Kiryong, Rolf and Satya asap. > 9. (Ashlee, 21 Sept) send two final logo versions, prepare an early version of the webpage to be reviewed in Technical Program Call on Monday 21 Sept. > > > > << File: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call with actions.pptx >> > _____________________________________________ > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Donnerstag, 17. September 2015 10:45 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week --> Call NOT cancelled TODAY > > > Dear all, > Attached, please find the material for our call later on today > - Presentation with call agenda and > - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure > > Some of you might have received cancellation messages. This is just because I have updated the invite with the latest oec-sync list to ensure that Ashlee is also invited ;-) > Also, I updated the meeting number as proposed by Chase. > > I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > << File: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> > _____________________________________________ > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Donnerstag, 3. September 2015 18:23 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week > > > Thanks for the constructive call today. Here are the action items. I uploaded the meeting slides as well as the Open Edge Computing Overview slides to our file repository (link again below). > > @Ashlee, are you receiving these mails by now? > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > Action Items from Progress call 3rd September > 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 14 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack summit AND OPNFV Summit > 2. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) > 3. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 17 Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) > 4. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 4 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. > 5. (Kiriong, until 5 Sept) Meeting with Vedams on Monday, 7 September, Meeting on OpenStack roadmap on Monday, 14 September (with Yun-Chao) > 6. (Kiryong, until 5 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student > 7. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) License discussion for Open Edge Initiative --> at Technical Program Call on 14 Sept? > 8. (Yun-Chao, until 17 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting > 9. (Yun-Chao and Rolf, 14 Sept) put together a proposal for membership structure + web-site + new partner outreach > 10. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. > 11. Info: Cloudlet Class applicatin demonstration session on 1 December 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All welcome! > > > Link to repository: > https://owncloud.cmusatyalab.org/owncloud/public.php?service=files&t=c9f5bf1c36948d874459dea2fa50e57a > > _____________________________________________ > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Mittwoch, 2. September 2015 21:50 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week > > > Dear all, > Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow > - Presentation with call agenda and > - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure > > I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > << File: 2015-09-03 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> > > _____________________________________________ > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Dienstag, 1. September 2015 22:54 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week > > > Dear all, > Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, > - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and > - please have a look at the action items below from our last call and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call > Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. > Kind regards > Rolf. > > Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 > > 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback > 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) > 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit > 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) > 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. > 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) > 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing > - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. > - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. > - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? > 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC > 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. > 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) > 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project > > > _____________________________________________ > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Freitag, 21. August 2015 16:38 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com > Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week > > > Dear all, > Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions... > > Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. > > Many thanks > Rolf. > > << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx >> > > Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 > > 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback > 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) > 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit > 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) > 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. > 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) > 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing > - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. > - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. > - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? > 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC > 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. > 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) > 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project > > > > _____________________________________________ > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 > To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu > Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com > Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week > > > Dear all, > Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow > - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions > - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) > > I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 > To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com > Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week > > > Dear all, > Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, > - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. > - Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call > As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> > Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) > 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) > --> DONE > 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. > Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. > Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. > Ideas: address verticals. 'Crowdsourcing' the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. > --> Draft deck to be distributed > 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. > Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. > Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. > Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. > --> Has that happened? > 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. > --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? > 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. > --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? > 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. > --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. > 7. All: > 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug - end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. > 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is > familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. > --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! > 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. > Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? > Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal > --> Proposal from Satya under way... > > _____________________________________________ > From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group > Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com > Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 > Importance: High > > > Hi there, > > Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. > - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well > - We went through all agenda points > - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. > - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. > - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. > Any questions, please let me know. > > Best regards > > Guenter > << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> > > > -----Original Appointment----- > From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group > Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 > To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com > Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call > When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. > Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below > > > Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. > Rolf. > > ______________________________ > > Dear all, > As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas > - Outreach Program Progress > - Technical Program Progress > - MEC Requirement Progress > and go through the attached action item list. > > Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). > > Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. > > Kind regards > Rolf. > > > Email from last meeting > > > << Attachments: > > Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) > Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) > RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) > >> > > From satya at cs.cmu.edu Tue Dec 1 05:59:34 2015 From: satya at cs.cmu.edu (Mahadev Satyanarayanan) Date: Tue, 1 Dec 2015 05:59:34 -0500 Subject: [oe-sync] Fwd: (Forward to others) WebEx meeting invitation: OE Sync Meeting Message-ID: <201512010559.34528.satya@cs.cmu.edu> -------------- next part -------------- An embedded message was scrubbed... From: Mahadev Satyanarayanan Subject: (Forward to others) WebEx meeting invitation: OE Sync Meeting Date: Tue, 1 Dec 2015 02:20:00 +0000 (GMT) Size: 17398 URL: From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Tue Dec 1 09:27:49 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Tue, 1 Dec 2015 14:27:49 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call tomorrow Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8903A83DE@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, Please find the attached material for our discussion in a few minutes. Furthermore, below, please find the Webex dial-in information Satya has distributed earlier already. Kind regards Rolf. Meeting URL: https://cmusatyalab.webex.com/cmusatyalab/j.php?MTID=mb21af7061f91369e06efc08727d1792d Tuesday, December 1, 2015 9:30 am Eastern Standard Time (GMT-05:00) 1 hour 30 minutes Meeting number: 738 288 762 Meeting password: oesync Shared cloud space is at this URL: https://owncloud.cmusatyalab.org/owncloud/index.php/apps/files/?dir=%2Fopen-edge-computing-share ------------------------------------ _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Montag, 30. November 2015 11:49 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call tomorrow Dear all, As agreed, we will hold our bi-weekly progress call tomorrow. Here are the topics we will address: - Review progress action items (see below) - Update on technical program progress (Kiryong?) - MEC architecture progress (Patrice) - Direction Workshop 11 Dec at CMU: prep discussion (input from Guenter, Satya, Rolf, Yun-Chao?, Valerie?) - Update on Outreach activities (Satya, Rolf) - FogComputingConsortium.org - Update on information (all) - Shift the next Progress Call (many of us are in the plane to the Workshop) Anything else we should address? Looking forward to talk to you. Kind regards Rolf. Here are the action items from 12 November progress call: - (Kiryong) Meeting with Ashlee / on QEMU (next week Monday?) - (Kiryong, Rolf) ensure that there is feedback from Ante - (Prakash) talk to Vedams to --> position Kiryong as the technical project lead for the two Vedams resources --> ensure resources from Vedams until May 2016 - (Guenter) set-up a meeting on the networking problem with Kiryong Huawei experts - (Rolf) send a reminder to Chris Pudney regarding the power save problem - (Rolf) clarify with Valerie if we have to integrate with Intel SDK in the separate module we will create within the openstack community - (Rolf and Ashlee) progress the web-page etc. - (Rolf) move the next progress call (Thanksgiving in the US) _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 12. November 2015 18:00 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today -> action items Dear all, Thanks for the constructive progress call today. Here are the action items: - (Kiryong) Meeting with Ashlee / on QEMU (next week Monday?) - (Kiryong, Rolf) ensure that there is feedback from Ante - (Prakash) talk to Vedams to --> position Kiryong as the technical project lead for the two Vedams resources --> ensure resources from Vedams until May 2016 - (Guenter) set-up a meeting on the networking problem with Kiryong Huawei experts - (Rolf) send a reminder to Chris Pudney regarding the power save problem - (Rolf) clarify with Valerie if we have to integrate with Intel SDK in the separate module we will create within the openstack community - (Rolf and Ashlee) progress the web-page etc. - (Rolf) move the next progress call (Thanksgiving in the US) Just to let everybody know, it was not possible to set-up the F2F meeting for Nov 30- Dec 1st (Valerie and Yun-Chao had other commitments). Still everybody is encouraged to come to CMU for the student project demonstrations on December 1st in the afternoon. Kind regards Rolf. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 11. November 2015 15:29 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call tomorrow Dear all, Just as a gentle reminder, we will hold our bi-weekly progress call tomorrow. May I assume that you can all join that call? We have to agree on the way forward after all the events and changes... Here are some of the topics we will address: - Technical Program update including QEMU, network issue (Kiryong) - Own OpenStack Cloudlet Module - resources (including Vedams), work plan and next steps (Prakash, Kiryong) - Outreach Program update (Rolf, Satya) - Web page etc. (all) Yun-Chao, Prakash and Ashlee, will you be able to join - in spite of the OPNFV Summit? We can try to cover the topics relevant for you within the first hour? Kind regards Rolf. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 15. Oktober 2015 11:58 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Dear all, Below please find the action items from our last call we will go through during our call later on today. Here are some of the topics we will address: - PoC Attached, please find the PoC document Satya has put together and Valerie is trying to position within the MEC PoC framework this week. - Blueprint @Prakash / Kiryong / Ashlee, could you please share the link to the blueprint? May I assume that has been finalised by now (due until 11 Oct)? Should we sync that with other friendly Openstack experts? - Test plan Does it make sense to address that? As we make this more widely available it would be good to see the test results. - Web page @Yun Chao, Valerie and Adrian, as you are the the MEC F2F meeting, are you going to be able to join the progress call today at 16:00 CEST? Looking forward to talk to you. Kind regards Rolf. __________________________________________________________ Action Items from 6 October: 1. (Prakash, until 15 Oct) push for OEC code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit. 2. (Prakash supported by Valerie, Guenter, Kiryong, 9 Oct) Prakash to organise this week to finalise the MEC PoC proposal to be submitted at the MEC meeting next week. Valerie to send material on Intel technology that may be used for the PoC. 3. (Kiryong, until ?) Describe rational behind QEMU modifications. Upgrade QEMU-modifications to current QEMU version. 4. (Yun-Chao, Guenter until Nov) continue to liaise with GSMA and monitor their task force work on edge computing. 5. (Rolf, Guenter until Nov) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 6. (all, until 15 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 7. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 11 Oct) Finalise the blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 11 Oct. Prakash to organise a call on that matter this week. 8. (all, 15 Oct) send key material, text snippets for the OEC web page to Ashley. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 6. Oktober 2015 11:40 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Dear all, Thanks for the constructive discussion yesterday. Please find the action items from the call below. Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from 6 October: 1. (Prakash, until 15 Oct) push for OEC code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit. 2. (Prakash supported by Valerie, Guenter, Kiryong, 9 Oct) Prakash to organise this week to finalise the MEC PoC proposal to be submitted at the MEC meeting next week. Valerie to send material on Intel technology that may be used for the PoC. 3. (Kiryong, until ?) Describe rational behind QEMU modifications. Upgrade QEMU-modifications to current QEMU version. 4. (Yun-Chao, Guenter until Nov) continue to liaise with GSMA and monitor their task force work on edge computing. 5. (Rolf, Guenter until Nov) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 6. (all, until 15 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 7. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 11 Oct) Finalise the blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 11 Oct. Prakash to organise a call on that matter this week. 8. (all, 15 Oct) send key material, text snippets for the OEC web page to Ashley. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Montag, 5. Oktober 2015 12:18 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Dear all, Today we will have a shortened progress call in the beginning of the weekly call of the technical team. Hence, we will just address a few matters: - Action items from last call (see below and attachment for details) - Brief summary of MEC Congress in London last week - Status and next steps regarding Nova Blueprint Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from 17 September: 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 25 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit 2. (Ashlee, until 25 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) 3. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 17 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie will send a draft of a OEC PoC proposal document the group. Satya and Kiryong support that process. Perhaps first E2E demo at Mobile World Congress in Barcelon 2016? 4. (Kiryong, until 23 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student 5. (Yun-Chao, until 25 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting? Check with Guenter if he is there as well. 6. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 7. (all, until 1 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 8. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 21 Sept) Finalise the draft blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 21 Sept. Ashlee & Prakash to send examples of "good" blueprints to Kiryong, Rolf and Satya asap. 9. (Ashlee, 21 Sept) send two final logo versions, prepare an early version of the webpage to be reviewed in Technical Program Call on Monday 21 Sept. << File: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call with actions.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 17. September 2015 10:45 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week --> Call NOT cancelled TODAY Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call later on today - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure Some of you might have received cancellation messages. This is just because I have updated the invite with the latest oec-sync list to ensure that Ashlee is also invited ;-) Also, I updated the meeting number as proposed by Chase. I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 3. September 2015 18:23 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Thanks for the constructive call today. Here are the action items. I uploaded the meeting slides as well as the Open Edge Computing Overview slides to our file repository (link again below). @Ashlee, are you receiving these mails by now? Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from Progress call 3rd September 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 14 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack summit AND OPNFV Summit 2. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) 3. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 17 Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 4. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 4 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 5. (Kiriong, until 5 Sept) Meeting with Vedams on Monday, 7 September, Meeting on OpenStack roadmap on Monday, 14 September (with Yun-Chao) 6. (Kiryong, until 5 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student 7. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) License discussion for Open Edge Initiative --> at Technical Program Call on 14 Sept? 8. (Yun-Chao, until 17 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting 9. (Yun-Chao and Rolf, 14 Sept) put together a proposal for membership structure + web-site + new partner outreach 10. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 11. Info: Cloudlet Class applicatin demonstration session on 1 December 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All welcome! Link to repository: https://owncloud.cmusatyalab.org/owncloud/public.php?service=files&t=c9f5bf1c36948d874459dea2fa50e57a _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 2. September 2015 21:50 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-09-03 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 1. September 2015 22:54 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and - please have a look at the action items below from our last call and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. Kind regards Rolf. Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 21. August 2015 16:38 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions... Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. Many thanks Rolf. << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx >> Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. - Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) --> DONE 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. Ideas: address verticals. 'Crowdsourcing' the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. --> Draft deck to be distributed 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. --> Has that happened? 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. 7. All: 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug - end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal --> Proposal from Satya under way... _____________________________________________ From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 Importance: High Hi there, Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well - We went through all agenda points - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. Any questions, please let me know. Best regards Guenter << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. Rolf. ______________________________ Dear all, As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas - Outreach Program Progress - Technical Program Progress - MEC Requirement Progress and go through the attached action item list. Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. Kind regards Rolf. Email from last meeting << Attachments: Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) >> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: 2015 11 10 OEC Initiative Review GK v2.pptx Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.presentationml.presentation Size: 584746 bytes Desc: 2015 11 10 OEC Initiative Review GK v2.pptx URL: -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: 2015-11 Workshop - Agenda and OEC Consortium Model.pptx Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.presentationml.presentation Size: 502841 bytes Desc: 2015-11 Workshop - Agenda and OEC Consortium Model.pptx URL: From Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com Tue Dec 1 11:19:08 2015 From: Rolf.Schuster at vodafone.com (Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group) Date: Tue, 1 Dec 2015 16:19:08 +0000 Subject: [oe-sync] Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call tomorrow Message-ID: <924D42A2C73D3148982CCE75409B3CC8903A853C@VOEXM21W.internal.vodafone.com> Dear all, Here are the action items from today and the re-worked agenda for the workshop in the presentation deck. Kind regards Rolf. Here are the action items from 1 December progress call: - (Rolf) send to Guenter regarding regarding the power save problem for Chris Pudney - (Kiryong) remind Ante of the review - (Yun-Chao) check with Ashlee regarding his support for QEMU and get back before Christmas - (Rolf) workshop prep call and re-schedule progress call next week to 18 Dec - (all) Long-term task: look at OEC integration / interaction with NFV and SDN _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Montag, 30. November 2015 11:49 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call tomorrow Dear all, As agreed, we will hold our bi-weekly progress call tomorrow. Here are the topics we will address: - Review progress action items (see below) - Update on technical program progress (Kiryong?) - MEC architecture progress (Patrice) - Direction Workshop 11 Dec at CMU: prep discussion (input from Guenter, Satya, Rolf, Yun-Chao?, Valerie?) - Update on Outreach activities (Satya, Rolf) - FogComputingConsortium.org - Update on information (all) - Shift the next Progress Call (many of us are in the plane to the Workshop) Anything else we should address? Looking forward to talk to you. Kind regards Rolf. Here are the action items from 12 November progress call: - (Kiryong) Meeting with Ashlee / on QEMU (next week Monday?) - (Kiryong, Rolf) ensure that there is feedback from Ante - (Prakash) talk to Vedams to --> position Kiryong as the technical project lead for the two Vedams resources --> ensure resources from Vedams until May 2016 - (Guenter) set-up a meeting on the networking problem with Kiryong Huawei experts - (Rolf) send a reminder to Chris Pudney regarding the power save problem - (Rolf) clarify with Valerie if we have to integrate with Intel SDK in the separate module we will create within the openstack community - (Rolf and Ashlee) progress the web-page etc. - (Rolf) move the next progress call (Thanksgiving in the US) _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 12. November 2015 18:00 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today -> action items Dear all, Thanks for the constructive progress call today. Here are the action items: - (Kiryong) Meeting with Ashlee / on QEMU (next week Monday?) - (Kiryong, Rolf) ensure that there is feedback from Ante - (Prakash) talk to Vedams to --> position Kiryong as the technical project lead for the two Vedams resources --> ensure resources from Vedams until May 2016 - (Guenter) set-up a meeting on the networking problem with Kiryong Huawei experts - (Rolf) send a reminder to Chris Pudney regarding the power save problem - (Rolf) clarify with Valerie if we have to integrate with Intel SDK in the separate module we will create within the openstack community - (Rolf and Ashlee) progress the web-page etc. - (Rolf) move the next progress call (Thanksgiving in the US) Just to let everybody know, it was not possible to set-up the F2F meeting for Nov 30- Dec 1st (Valerie and Yun-Chao had other commitments). Still everybody is encouraged to come to CMU for the student project demonstrations on December 1st in the afternoon. Kind regards Rolf. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 11. November 2015 15:29 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call tomorrow Dear all, Just as a gentle reminder, we will hold our bi-weekly progress call tomorrow. May I assume that you can all join that call? We have to agree on the way forward after all the events and changes... Here are some of the topics we will address: - Technical Program update including QEMU, network issue (Kiryong) - Own OpenStack Cloudlet Module - resources (including Vedams), work plan and next steps (Prakash, Kiryong) - Outreach Program update (Rolf, Satya) - Web page etc. (all) Yun-Chao, Prakash and Ashlee, will you be able to join - in spite of the OPNFV Summit? We can try to cover the topics relevant for you within the first hour? Kind regards Rolf. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 15. Oktober 2015 11:58 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Dear all, Below please find the action items from our last call we will go through during our call later on today. Here are some of the topics we will address: - PoC Attached, please find the PoC document Satya has put together and Valerie is trying to position within the MEC PoC framework this week. - Blueprint @Prakash / Kiryong / Ashlee, could you please share the link to the blueprint? May I assume that has been finalised by now (due until 11 Oct)? Should we sync that with other friendly Openstack experts? - Test plan Does it make sense to address that? As we make this more widely available it would be good to see the test results. - Web page @Yun Chao, Valerie and Adrian, as you are the the MEC F2F meeting, are you going to be able to join the progress call today at 16:00 CEST? Looking forward to talk to you. Kind regards Rolf. __________________________________________________________ Action Items from 6 October: 1. (Prakash, until 15 Oct) push for OEC code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit. 2. (Prakash supported by Valerie, Guenter, Kiryong, 9 Oct) Prakash to organise this week to finalise the MEC PoC proposal to be submitted at the MEC meeting next week. Valerie to send material on Intel technology that may be used for the PoC. 3. (Kiryong, until ?) Describe rational behind QEMU modifications. Upgrade QEMU-modifications to current QEMU version. 4. (Yun-Chao, Guenter until Nov) continue to liaise with GSMA and monitor their task force work on edge computing. 5. (Rolf, Guenter until Nov) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 6. (all, until 15 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 7. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 11 Oct) Finalise the blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 11 Oct. Prakash to organise a call on that matter this week. 8. (all, 15 Oct) send key material, text snippets for the OEC web page to Ashley. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 6. Oktober 2015 11:40 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Dear all, Thanks for the constructive discussion yesterday. Please find the action items from the call below. Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from 6 October: 1. (Prakash, until 15 Oct) push for OEC code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit. 2. (Prakash supported by Valerie, Guenter, Kiryong, 9 Oct) Prakash to organise this week to finalise the MEC PoC proposal to be submitted at the MEC meeting next week. Valerie to send material on Intel technology that may be used for the PoC. 3. (Kiryong, until ?) Describe rational behind QEMU modifications. Upgrade QEMU-modifications to current QEMU version. 4. (Yun-Chao, Guenter until Nov) continue to liaise with GSMA and monitor their task force work on edge computing. 5. (Rolf, Guenter until Nov) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 6. (all, until 15 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 7. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 11 Oct) Finalise the blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 11 Oct. Prakash to organise a call on that matter this week. 8. (all, 15 Oct) send key material, text snippets for the OEC web page to Ashley. _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Montag, 5. Oktober 2015 12:18 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - progress call today Dear all, Today we will have a shortened progress call in the beginning of the weekly call of the technical team. Hence, we will just address a few matters: - Action items from last call (see below and attachment for details) - Brief summary of MEC Congress in London last week - Status and next steps regarding Nova Blueprint Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from 17 September: 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 25 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack Summit AND OPNFV Summit 2. (Ashlee, until 25 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) 3. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 17 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie will send a draft of a OEC PoC proposal document the group. Satya and Kiryong support that process. Perhaps first E2E demo at Mobile World Congress in Barcelon 2016? 4. (Kiryong, until 23 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student 5. (Yun-Chao, until 25 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting? Check with Guenter if he is there as well. 6. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 7. (all, until 1 Oct) Cloudlet Class application demonstration session on 1 Dec 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All to check if they can come to CMU for the session and an OEC meeting. 8. (Prakash, Kiryong, Ashlee, 21 Sept) Finalise the draft blueprint and send the entire group by Monday 21 Sept. Ashlee & Prakash to send examples of "good" blueprints to Kiryong, Rolf and Satya asap. 9. (Ashlee, 21 Sept) send two final logo versions, prepare an early version of the webpage to be reviewed in Technical Program Call on Monday 21 Sept. << File: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call with actions.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 17. September 2015 10:45 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week --> Call NOT cancelled TODAY Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call later on today - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure Some of you might have received cancellation messages. This is just because I have updated the invite with the latest oec-sync list to ensure that Ashlee is also invited ;-) Also, I updated the meeting number as proposed by Chase. I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-09-17 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Donnerstag, 3. September 2015 18:23 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Thanks for the constructive call today. Here are the action items. I uploaded the meeting slides as well as the Open Edge Computing Overview slides to our file repository (link again below). @Ashlee, are you receiving these mails by now? Kind regards Rolf. Action Items from Progress call 3rd September 1. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 14 Sept) push for code demo at OpenStack summit AND OPNFV Summit 2. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) push for board presentation at OpenStack (with Alan Clark) 3. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 17 Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 4. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian, 4 Sept) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 5. (Kiriong, until 5 Sept) Meeting with Vedams on Monday, 7 September, Meeting on OpenStack roadmap on Monday, 14 September (with Yun-Chao) 6. (Kiryong, until 5 Sept) Set-up a discussion on QEMU roadmap with Ashlee, Kiryong , Satya & master student 7. (Ashlee, until 14 Sept) License discussion for Open Edge Initiative --> at Technical Program Call on 14 Sept? 8. (Yun-Chao, until 17 Sept) present Open Edge Computing at GSMA-Meeting 9. (Yun-Chao and Rolf, 14 Sept) put together a proposal for membership structure + web-site + new partner outreach 10. (Rolf, 17 Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 11. Info: Cloudlet Class applicatin demonstration session on 1 December 2015, 3-6pm EST @ CMU. All welcome! Link to repository: https://owncloud.cmusatyalab.org/owncloud/public.php?service=files&t=c9f5bf1c36948d874459dea2fa50e57a _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 2. September 2015 21:50 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and - draft ideas for the Web Site content and partner membership structure I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-09-03 OEC Initiative - Progress Call.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 1. September 2015 22:54 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say tomorrow, Wednesday noon and - please have a look at the action items below from our last call and make sure that your action items can be covered during the call Looking forward to talk to you on Thursday. Kind regards Rolf. Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 21. August 2015 16:38 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: RE: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Many thanks for the agile and constructive progress call yesterday. Below, please find the action item list from the call. Please send your comments and suggestions... Furthermore, as agreed I attach the OEC overview presentation. Please do not hesitate to send your comment until Tuesday 25 August. Many thanks Rolf. << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 5.pptx >> Action Item List from Initiative Progress Call on 20 August 2015 1. (everybody, until Tue 25 Aug) review the draft OEC Overview deck provided by Rolf and send him your feedback 2. (Ashlee, Prakash, until 3rd Sept) push for acceptance of our presentation at OpenStack summit (if appropriate also through Alan Clark) 3. (Prakash, until mid September) push for acceptance of our presentation at OPNFV Summit 4. (Prakash, until 24 Aug) gather feedback on our presentation acceptance at Openstack summit and make a proposal if and how to create OEC blue-prints for OpenStack. Decision on Monday 24 August in technical call (open to everybody through Kiryong) 5. (Valerie, Joe, Prakash, Adrian) MEC PoC platform is a good opportunity to get visibility. Valerie et.al. will draft a OEC PoC proposal document for the MEC POC process. Satya and Kiryong support that process. 6. (Babu supported by Satya, Kiryong and Ashley, until 3rd Sept) describe target latencies segments (1-10, 10-50, 50-100ms) and map those to technical solutions (stack SW, drivers etc.) 7. We decided to set-up a web-site / community platform for OpenEdge Computing - (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) will put together a more detailed content structure including cloudlet sandbox, download and demonstrator section etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will select a suitable software platform for the OEC community and set it up with domain names openedgecomputing.org and open-edge-computing.org etc. - (Ashlee, until 3rd Sept) will look into Intel SDK to be included in the platform and sandbox? 8. (Prakash, until Mo 24 Sept) send contacts to HP that might be interested in OEC 9. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) contact further OEC supporters / partners for example HP, Canonical etc. 10. (Rolf, until 3rd Sept) provide a detailed proposal for partner engagement structure (votes, rights, support etc.) 11. (Valerie, Kiryong, until 3rd Sept) continue to progress the OEC Class project _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Mittwoch, 19. August 2015 15:22 To: oe-sync at lists.andrew.cmu.edu Cc: ashlee at onosfw.com Subject: FW: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Attached, please find the material for our call tomorrow - Presentation with call agenda and outreach program update / decisions - Draft overview deck on Open Edge Initiative (to be approved by all partners) I very much look forward to talk to you tomorrow. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 2015-08-20 OEC Initiative - Call.pptx >> << File: 2015-08 Open Edge Computing - Initiative Overview new 4.pptx >> _____________________________________________ From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: Dienstag, 18. August 2015 12:15 To: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing Initiative - Progress Call on Thursday this week Dear all, Just to prepare our progress call on Thursday this week, - please do not hesitate to forward your documents / input to me by say today cob. I will distribute to everybody by tomorrow noon. - Please have a look at the action items below (and in the attachment) to make sure that your action items can be covered during the call As most of you know, we have further technical support from Huawei. Hence, I also invite Ashlee Young to this meeting. I will also send an update for the meeting invite, just to reflect the new Webex-dial-in details. Kind regards Rolf. << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> Action Items from Progress Call on 16 July (comments from Rolf in red) 1. Satya to send data for the Monday technical calls (currently attending: Satya, Kiryong, Prakash) --> DONE 2. Rolf: Work on the Marketing slides at an extra call. Add: business value, addressable market, etc. Collect data points beforehand. Think about aspects that help to convince other parties. Work offline and then polish off during one of our sync meetings. Ideas: address verticals. 'Crowdsourcing' the deck step by step, such that it includes good material for different verticals. --> Draft deck to be distributed 3. Prakash: regarding Openstack, we have started to engage with them --> need endorsements. Vendor, carrier, developers. There was a deadline for submitting a pitch to Openstack. Prakash has details. Goal: other people in the community shall vote for this, so we can get a presentation at the OS Summit. Action: Prakash to send a URL to all for this. Then all engage your internal stakeholders accordingly. --> Has that happened? 4. Valerie + Patrice to discuss whether ETSI MEC PoC concept could be used in our context. --> Feedback in call on 20 August 2015? 5. Prakash to educate us on the Umbrella Blueprint at one of the Mo technical conf calls. --> Update durich call on 20 August 2015? 6. Kiryong: send out and share the openstackpp.pdf design document to the list once ready. --> The document is ready? Please distribute to everybody. 7. All: 1) Check who can help Kiryong with coding and testing from early/mid Aug - end Sept. Profile: familiar with Glance, Nova, can code. 2) Check who has a person who is expert in installing differnet Openstack configurations, knows DevStack, is familiar with Openstack Network Configurations. Tester should have access to servers. --> DONE. Resources from Huawei! Big Thanks! 8. All: Discuss and clarify archive/storage for this project offline. Google docs? Own cloud at CMU? Satya will make a proposal. Aug 20 meeting can serve as a test case to try out the proposal --> Proposal from Satya under way... _____________________________________________ From: Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group Sent: Freitag, 17. Juli 2015 17:38 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Actions from call: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call 6 July 2015 Importance: High Hi there, Attached/below the summary from our conference call yesterday 16 July. - The new procedure with webex for doc sharing and audio-dial in from smartphones worked pretty well - We went through all agenda points - We talked through the action items from the previous conf. call. See the status on page 5 as per attached. - New actions from this call as per page 6+7 for all parties. - Various actions require follow-up in the next days. Any questions, please let me know. Best regards Guenter << File: 150716 OE Sync Call Actions.pdf >> -----Original Appointment----- From: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group Sent: 11 June 2015 22:31 To: Schuster, Rolf, Vodafone Group; Caikui; Patrice hede; Klas, Guenter, Vodafone Group; yunchao hu; Chenyuqiao; Mahadev Satyanarayanan; Chase Klingensmith (chasek at cs.cmu.edu); 'Young, Valerie J'; 'Rodgers, Jordan'; 'Chan, Caroline'; 'Prakash Ramchandran'; joe.g.cahill at intel.com; Neal, Adrian, Vodafone Group; Smith, Kevin, (R&D) Vodafone Group; Kiryong Ha (krha at cmu.edu); michael.a.kozuch at intel.com Subject: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call When: 16 July 2015 17:00-18:30 (UTC+01:00) Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna. Where: We use the WebEx service ONLY and dial-in via phone (no VoIP), details below Update on dial-in: For this call we use the WebEx service ONLY (for application sharing and voice dial-in, details below). Please dial-in via phone (no VoIP). Chase / Guenter will provide further dial-in numbers. Rolf. ______________________________ Dear all, As agreed here is he invite for the progress call. We will cover the areas - Outreach Program Progress - Technical Program Progress - MEC Requirement Progress and go through the attached action item list. Please remember to use the Huawei dial-in details that will be sent to you directly from uMeeting at huawei.com for the Voice dial-in (it is best to call the number directly rather than using VoIP) and the WebEx details from Chase for the application sharing (will be attached to this invite). Due to my annual leave I will not be able to join that call. I suggest that Satya is chairing this call. Kind regards Rolf. Email from last meeting << Attachments: Workshop Result Summary and Action Items.docx (34.5KB) Webex call-in information July 16, 2015 (11.7KB) RE: Open Edge Computing - Progress Call --> this afternoon (9.0MB) >> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: 2015-11 Workshop - Agenda and OEC Consortium Model new.pptx Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.presentationml.presentation Size: 502842 bytes Desc: 2015-11 Workshop - Agenda and OEC Consortium Model new.pptx URL: